Fact Checks

September week three summary

Oromia regional militia attacked Somali villages

An X (Twitter) post on September 18, 2023, claimed an image showed an Oromo militia attacking Somali villages. The post shared two pictures and claimed that the never-ending civil war in Ethiopia was spreading to the east and that heavily armed Oromo militia sponsored by the regional government of Oromia had attacked villages and the largest Somali refugee camp, Qolaji, near Jigjiga. The post was shared nearly 294 times and received over 428 reactions.

The conflict between the Oromo and Somali communities in Ethiopia is complex and has a long history. Both communities inhabit the areas around the regional border, and they often clash over resources such as land and pasture. The conflict has been exacerbated by the instability in Ethiopia, and it has led to the displacement of thousands of people.

HaqCheck investigated the claim and found that the images were old and did not support the claim. The first photo was originally posted on Facebook on August 19, 2019, with a caption that stated: “We know the administration of the region protects their seats and the civilians who don’t have interest. I don’t understand why ONLF is so short of the problems facing the people of Qoloji.”

The second image had been previously published on a website on May 27, 2018, with a caption describing how power lines touching trees caused four California wildfires that destroyed 134 buildings.

Thus, the image used in the Twitter post was not accurate and did not support the claim that Oromo militiamen were attacking Somali villages.

A video showing soldiers beating up people in Amhara

On August 11, 2023, an X (Twitter) post shared a video with the claim that it showed Ethiopian National Defense Force (ENDF) soldiers beating people based on ethnic identity in the Amhara region. The post went viral on the platform, with nearly 379 retweets and over 329 reactions.

The Amhara region in Ethiopia has been experiencing ongoing armed conflict between government armed forces and Fano militia groups. Last month, armed militia groups gained control over various areas in the region, prompting the Ethiopian federal government to declare a state of emergency in Amhara

In August 2023, the government launched a counteroffensive and managed to recapture major urban areas from Fano militants. However, reports indicate that armed clashes and confrontations continued in the region.

However, HaqCheck investigated the claim and found that the video was old and did not support the claim. The video had been previously posted on X on March 13, 2021, with a description that Ethiopian soldiers were beating people in Tigray.

Recommendations

Social media users are recommended to be careful what they read and share. They shouldn’t believe everything they see, and check other sources before sharing something.

Governments and other organizations should be transparent and give people accurate information. This is especially important during times of crisis when misinformation can spread quickly. The public and the media should be given unfettered access to information.

Social media content creators are advised to be responsible and not to spread false or misleading information.

September week two disinformation summary

Claims related to detention and editing old posts

Throughout the week, there were claims and controversies on Ethiopian social media over the detention of ethnic Amharas across various parts of the country. Images circulated on social media with claims that they showed recently detained ethnic Amharas, but HaqCheck could not confirm whether the images were true or false.

In this context, HaqCheck has observed a new disinformation tactic in the Ethiopian social media landscape: editing old Facebook posts to mislead people.

On September 13, 2023, a Facebook post shared four images, claiming that the people in the photos were ethnic Amharas detained by the government in Tulu Dimtu, a town near Addis Ababa. The post also alleged that they were suffering and dying from contagious diseases in the camp.

The post went viral and gained traction on social media platforms. However, HaqCheck could not confirm whether the post was true or false. We could not confirm the origin and authenticity of the images presented to support the claim.

Some pro-government social media accounts shared a screenshot of a Facebook post that had been edited to show that the images were posted a year ago, unrelated to the claim of government detention of ethnic Amharas. They presented this as evidence to disprove the claim, suggesting that the images were false.

HaqCheck checked the images and Facebook posts to see if they had been posted before and found that a Facebook post from June 29, 2022, contained the same images with an Amharic caption.

However, the old Facebook post was recently edited to add the images and change the caption. The original post, made on June 29, 2022, was in Afaan Oromo and compared five assassinated figures: John F. Kennedy, Martin Luther King Jr., Abraham Lincoln, Malcolm X, and Hachalu Hundessa. The original post had only one image, which HaqCheck could not see because it had been replaced.

On September 13, 2023, the post was edited to change the text to Amharic and add five new images. The edited caption now claims that the Addis Ababa City administration is providing medical services to over a hundred homeless people.

Recommendations

One way that disinformation is spread on social media is through edited old posts. Social media users should be cautious of editing old posts, as they can be used to spread disinformation. They should check the edit history of posts.

Social media users should be skeptical of controversial information circulating on social media. They should get their news from reliable sources and verify information before sharing it.

The government and other organizations should be transparent and provide timely updates to the public. Lack of information prompts false information dissemination. The government should guarantee the right of citizens and the media to access information freely and securely. This includes the right to access government records and report on sensitive topics.

Editing Old Posts: A Tactic of Disinformation in the Midst of Amhara Conflict

The armed conflict in the Amhara region of Ethiopia has intensified in recent months. The immediate cause of the conflict was the Ethiopian government’s decision to dissolve regional special police forces.

Since then, the Amhara region has been engulfed in conflict and violence, with regular clashes between government forces and the Fano militias. The conflict has claimed the lives of many civilians, and there have been reports of human rights abuses.

In August, the Fano militias took brief control of several major towns in the Amhara region, including Gondar and Debre Tabor. The regional government of Amhara called on the federal government for help, and the Ethiopian military launched a counteroffensive. Later, the House of People’s Representatives(HPRs) declared a state of emergency in the region.  

The government forces were initially successful, and they managed to recapture some of the towns that had been lost. However, the conflict remains unresolved, and there is a risk of further conflict and violence.

Reports of the Detention of Ethnic Amharas

The Ethiopian government has arrested several ethnic Amharas, including politicians, journalists, and public figures, since declaring a state of emergency in the Amhara region on August 4, 2023.

Among those detained are Yohannes Buayalew, a former senior official of the Amhara region, a member of the ruling Prosperity Party, and a member of the Amhara regional parliament (state council); and Christian Tadelle, a former executive member of the National Movement of Amhara party and a member of the Ethiopian Parliament (HPR).

According to state-affiliated media reports, the Ethiopian government has arrested 764 people suspected of supporting armed insurgents in the Amhara region.

However, unconfirmed social media reports have claimed that many ethnic Amharas have been detained in detention centers across the country, including the warehouses in the capital, Addis Ababa, and that the government targets ethnic Amharas solely because of their identity.

These reports have been accompanied by images that purport to show innocent ethnic Amharas facing detention by the government. For instance, a Facebook post (screenshot below) published on September 13, 2023, shared four images claiming that the people shown in the pictures are ethnic Amharas detained by the government in Tulu Dimtu, a town on the outskirts of Addis Ababa. The post also stated that they are suffering and dying of contagious diseases in the camp.

[Caption: These are ethnic Amharas detained in Tulu Dimtu, suffering and dying of contagious diseases in the camp.]

The post went viral and gained traction on the social media platform. HaqCheck could not confirm whether the post was true or false. We could not confirm the origin and authenticity of the images presented to support the claim.

Editing old posts

On the other hand, some pro-government social media accounts shared a Facebook post and its screenshot, which indicated that the images were posted a year ago on Facebook and are unrelated to the claim. This was presented as evidence to disprove the claim that the government was detaining ethnic Amharas and that the images used to support the claim were false.

[Translation: These posts use false and old images to propagate false information.]

Below is a screenshot of the old Facebook post that claimed to be the first to publish the controversial images.

[Translation: The Addis Ababa City administration provides medical services to over a hundred homeless people.]

HaqCheck investigated the images and the Facebook posts to see if they were posted on another post a year ago. HaqCheck found that a Facebook post from June 29, 2022, contained the images with an Amharic caption.

The edit history of the Facebook post

HaqCheck found that the old Facebook post was recently edited, and the images were added later.

When the Facebook post was made on June 29, 2022, it originally had an Afaan Oromo caption that compared five “great” personalities who were assassinated: John F. Kennedy, Martin Luther King Jr., Abraham Lincoln, Malcolm X, and Hachalu Hundessa. The original caption compared Hachalu Hundessa, the late popular Afaan Oromo musician shot dead on June 29, 2020, to the other four figures. The old post originally contained one image, but HaqCheck could not see it because it had been deleted and replaced with others.

[Screenshot: The original Afaan Oromo caption of the Facebook post.]

However, the Facebook post was edited on September 13, 2023. The Afaan Oromo text was replaced with a different Amharic text, and the original image was replaced with five new images. The edited caption of the post now claims that the Addis Ababa City administration was providing medical services to more than a hundred people living on the street (homeless people).

[Caption edited and five new images added on September 13, 2023.]

HaqCheck rated the Facebook post as False. The post was intentionally edited to mislead and disinform people.

HaqCheck recommends social media users be cautious of such kinds of misleading posts. Social media users are advised to check the publication date and the editing history of social media posts, particularly Facebook posts since the platform allowed users to edit posts in 2013.

Did Field Marshal Birhanu Jula say Fano militants seized ENDF weapons?

A Facebook page with over 5,000 followers shared a video on August 28, 2023, claiming the Cheif of Staff of the Ethiopian National Defence Forces (ENDF), Field Marshal Birhanu Jula said that Fano militants seized ENDF weapons including tanks and artilleries. The Facebook post went viral, with over 90  thousand views and close to 1.3 thousand reactions by the time this article was published.

However, HaqCheck investigated the post and found that the video was old and did not support the claim. Therefore, HaqCheck rated the claim as False.

In April 2023, the Ethiopian government decided to dissolve regional special forces and merge them with other security institutions. This caused protests and unrest in the Amhara region, leading to ongoing clashes between government forces and Fano militia groups.

The security crisis worsened when the federal government ordered the Ethiopian National Defense Force (ENDF) to take action against “extremist” groups after the head of the Amhara Prosperity Party, Girma Yeshitla, was killed by unidentified armed individuals in late April.

In August 2023, the armed conflict in the Amhara region escalated as Fano militants gained control of several cities and towns in the region. In response, the Ethiopian government declared a state of emergency and deployed armed forces to reverse the situation. While the government managed to retake major cities and towns from armed insurgents, armed confrontations and fighting have continued in the region.

HaqCheck observed social media claims alleging that Fano militants were capturing weapons and routing ENDF troops. However, some of these posts were accompanied by false and old images.

Against this backdrop, a Facebook page shared a short video clip in which Fiel Marshal Birhanu Jula is heard saying “They took countless weapons of ours including our tanks and artilleries”, with a claim that the chief of staff had recently said that Fano militants seized weapons from the ENDF during the ongoing conflict. The short video clip was used to prove a narrative that ‘even the chief of staff confirmed that Fano militias were capturing ENDF weapons’.

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the video clip does not support the claim. The clip was taken from a video published on YouTube in October 2021 by the Ethiopian Satellite Television (ESAT). The video is an interview with the chief of staff about the armed conflict between the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) and the Ethiopian government at the time. In the video, Field Marshal Birhanu Jula says that the TPLF forces took countless tanks and weapons from the ENDF.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the Facebook post as False.

September week one summary

Soldiers being transported to the Amhara region

On August 26, 2023, an X (Twitter) account shared an image that they claimed showed Ethiopian military personnel being transported by helicopter to the Amhara region amid the ongoing conflict.

Despite the Ethiopian government’s recapture of many areas, including major cities, from Fano militia groups in the Amhara region, fighting and armed clashes between the Ethiopian military and Fano militia groups continued.

In this context, an X (Twitter) post appeared that shared an image allegedly showing Ethiopian military soldiers being transported by helicopter to the Amhara region amid the ongoing conflict.

HaqCheck investigated the claim and found that the image does not support the claim. The original photo appeared in a video clip that was shared on Facebook on August 2, 2021. The video clip described Ethiopian Airlines as being involved in ethnic cleansing, transporting soldiers, logistics, and weapons to the war in Tigray.

Birhanu Juna said Fano seize ENDF tanks

On August 28, 2023, a Facebook page shared a video that falsely claimed that Field Marshal Burhanu Jula, chief of staff of the Ethiopian National Defense Forces (ENDF) had recently said that Fano militants in the Amhara region had seized countless tanks from the ENDF during the ongoing conflict.

In the video clip, the chief of staff is seen saying, “They took countless tanks and weapons from us”. This claim was made amid intensified conflict between Fano militants and the Ethiopian government in the Amhara region.

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the video clip does not support the claim. The clip was taken from a video posted on YouTube in October 2021 by the Ethiopian Satellite Television (ESAT). The video is an interview with the chief of staff about the armed conflict between the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) and the Ethiopian government at the time. In the video, Field Marshal Birhanu Jula says that the TPLF forces took countless tanks and weapons from the ENDF.

HaqCheck’s investigation found that the video clip was taken out of context. The chief of staff was not referring to the Fano militants in the Amhara region but to the TPLF forces.

Christian Tadelle was released from detention

On August 9, 2023, a TikTok page with over 12,000 followers shared a video that they claimed showed Christian Tadelle, a member of the House of People Representatives who had been detained, being released from detention.

The Ethiopian government declared a state of emergency and arrested people, including politicians and opposition party leaders. Christian Tadelle, a former executive of the National Movement of Amhara (NaMA) and member of the House of People’s Representatives, was among those arrested. The Ethiopian Human Rights Commission confirmed that he was detained in Awash Arba.

Against this backdrop, a TikTok video surfaced claiming that Tadelle had been released from detention.

However, HaqCheck investigated the claim and confirmed that the video did not support it. The original video was found to have been published on March 9, 2020, on the YouTube channel of Asrat Media. It showed Tadelle speaking at a public discussion event.

Recommendations

Social media users should be cautious about misleading and controversial claims. They should look for additional information such as fact-checks for potential false claims. They should also be aware of the techniques used to spread disinformation, such as using sensational headlines and creating fake accounts.

Government offices and other entities should provide timely updates to the public. This is especially important during times of crisis when there is a lot of uncertainty and misinformation circulating. Governments should also be transparent about their activities and decisions.

The government should guarantee the right of citizens and the media to open and secure access to information. This includes the right to access government records, to report on sensitive topics, and to express dissenting views.

Does the video prove Christian Tadelle being released from detention?

A TikTok page with more than 12 thousand followers shared a video on Aug 9, 2023, claiming that it shows Christian Tadelle, a member of the House of People Representatives who had been detained, being released from detention.

The post had been shared 3439 times by the time this article was published. 

Haqcheck inspected the video and confirmed that it doesn’t support the claim. As a result, the claim was rated False.

On April 6, 2023, the Ethiopian federal government announced plans to disarm regional special police forces. The government started to disband the regional paramilitary forces and gave the troops three choices to join: the military, regional police forces, or the federal police force.

The decision of the federal government to dissolve regional special police forces was met with widespread protests and resistance in the Amhara region.

Public protests erupted in opposition to this decision, leading to armed confrontations and clashes in the region. The Fano militants gained control of many areas, including major cities. In response, the Amhara regional government requested assistance from the federal government, prompting the declaration of a state of emergency by the Ethiopian parliament.

As the state of emergency was declared, the government arrested people, including politicians and opposition party leaders. Christian Tadelle, a former executive of the National Movement of Amhara (NaMA) and member of the House of People’s Representatives, was among those arrested.

The Ethiopian Human Rights Commission, recently confirmed that Christian Tadelle was detained in Awash Arba.

Against this backdrop, a TikTok video came out claiming that Christian Tadelle was recently released from detention.

However, HaqCheck investigated the claim and confirmed that the video doesn’t support the claim. The original video was found to have been previously published on March 9, 2020, on the YouTube channel of Asrat Media. The video clip shows Christian Tadelle making a speech during a public discussion event.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post as False.

Does the image show a plane transporting soldiers to the Amhara region?

An X (Twitter) account with more than 50,000 followers shared an image on August 26, 2023, claiming that it shows Ethiopian military personnel being transported by helicopter to the Amhara region amid the ongoing conflict. The tweet has since been shared nearly 61 times and has received over 88 reactions.

However, HaqCheck inspected the post and found that the image was old and does not support the claim. As a result, the claim was rated False.

On April 6, 2023, the Ethiopian federal government announced that it would disarm regional special police forces.

The announcement sparked unrest in the Amhara regional state, where people protested against the decision to dismantle the regional special police forces. The Amhara region has since seen violent clashes and confrontations.

The Fano militants took control of many areas, including important cities in the region. The government quickly declared a state of emergency in the Amhara region in an attempt to address the situation.

The federal government regained control of large parts of the Amhara region, but fighting and armed clashes between the Ethiopian military and Fano militia groups continued.

Against this backdrop, an X (Twitter) post appeared that shared an image allegedly showing Ethiopian military soldiers being transported by helicopter to the Amhara region amid the ongoing conflict.

HaqCheck investigated the claim and found that the image does not support the claim. The original image appeared in a video clip that was shared on Facebook on August 2, 2021. The video clip described Ethiopian Airlines as being involved in ethnic cleansing, transporting soldiers, logistics, and weapons to the war in Tigray.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the Twitter post as False since it had used an incorrect image.

Does the image show Fano militants downed an Ethiopian helicopter in Debre Markos?

A Facebook page with over 46,000 followers shared a video on August 28, 2023, claiming that it showed an Ethiopian military helicopter being shot down in Debre Markos by Fano militants.

The Facebook post went viral, with over seven thousand views and close to 300 reactions by the time this article was published. 

However, HaqCheck investigated the post and found that the video was old and did not support the claim. Therefore, HaqCheck rated the claim as False.

In April 2023, the Ethiopian government announced plans to integrate regional special forces into other security institutions. This announcement unleashed widespread protests and unrest in the Amhara region.

Since then, there have been frequent clashes between state forces and Fano and Amharic ethnic militias, and the situation remains volatile.

The crisis escalated when the federal government ordered the Ethiopian National Defense Force (ENDF) to take action against “extremist” elements after unidentified armed entities killed the head of the Amhara Prosperity Party Girma Yeshitla at the end of April.

The armed conflict in the Amhara region escalated in August 2023, when Fano militants took control of several cities and towns. The Ethiopian government responded by deploying the Ethiopian National Defense Force (ENDF) to retake the cities.  The ENDF recaptured most of the major cities, but the conflict continues in some areas

In this context, a Facebook page shared a video claiming that an Ethiopian military helicopter was shot down in Debre Markos by Fano militants.

HaqCheck investigated the claim and found that the video does not support it. The original video was posted on Facebook on April 26, 2019, and the caption stated that the helicopter, owned by Trans Nation Airways (MIDROC Ethiopia Technology Group), had crashed due to engine failure.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the Facebook post as False because it used an old, inaccurate video.

August week three summary

False Image of Aerial Attack in Finote Selam

A Facebook page with over 40,000 followers posted an image claiming that the Ethiopian government had recently conducted an aerial attack in Finote Selam, resulting in the deaths of 270 civilians, including children as young as three.

The post went viral on the platform, garnering nearly 30 shares and over 150 reactions at the time.

This claim emerged amidst a security crisis in the Amhara region, prompting the Ethiopian federal government to declare a state of emergency due to armed militia groups gaining control of various areas within the region.

Additionally, clashes between Fano militants and Ethiopian government forces in the Amhara region further exacerbated the situation. Later on, government forces managed to regain control of major cities and towns after initially losing ground to Fano armed militias.

The claim gained traction following reports of a suspected airstrike in Finote Selam that resulted in the deaths of at least 26 people.

HaqCheck conducted a Google reverse image search, revealing that the image had been previously posted on Facebook on July 21, 2023.

Ethiopian Military Tank Destroyed by Fano Militants in Motta

On August 9, 2023, a Facebook page with more than 46,000 followers shared an image alleging that it depicted an Ethiopian military tank destroyed by Fano militia groups during the ongoing armed conflict in the Amhara regional state. The post also claimed that Ethiopian troops and their tanks had been routed in Motta, in the East Gojjam zone of the Amhara region.

Despite the federal government reclaiming major areas of the Amhara region, fighting and armed confrontations between Ethiopian armed forces and Fano militia groups persisted.

Reports indicated that casualties had occurred during these clashes.

In this context, a Facebook post came out sharing an image with a claim that Fano militia groups destroyed Ethiopian army troops including tanks.

HaqCheck investigated the claim and determined that the image did not support the claim.

The original image was previously published on X (Twitter) on August 8, 2022, with a caption stating that the Russian army had destroyed Ukrainian artillery vehicles in a recent battle.

Consequently, HaqCheck rendered the Facebook post as False due to its use of an inaccurate image.

Fano Militia Down Ethiopian Military Helicopter

On August 7, 2023, a Facebook account shared an image claiming to depict an Ethiopian military helicopter brought down by Fano militia groups during the ongoing armed conflict in the Amhara region state.

The post also alleged that the helicopter had attacked and crashed in the Amhara region. This Facebook post gained attention on the platform.

HaqCheck investigated the claim and found that the image did not substantiate the claim.

The original image had been previously published on a website on March 3, 2022, with a caption describing the crash of a Romanian helicopter searching for a fighter jet in the Black Sea.

As a result, HaqCheck rated the Facebook post as False.

Recommendations

HaqCheck urges social media users to exercise caution and be critical when encountering potentially false information across various media platforms. It is essential to verify the source of information before sharing it and ensure that the information originates from a credible source.

The government is advised to provide timely, accurate, and sufficient information to the public and media. This is crucial in preventing the spread of disinformation, as the absence of accessible information can lead to the proliferation of disinformation.

Content creators and media outlets on social media have a responsibility to share accurate information with their followers, refraining from disseminating false information.

Does the image show an Ethiopian military helicopter downed by Fano militias?

On August 7, 2023, a Facebook account shared an image claiming to depict an Ethiopian military helicopter brought down by Fano militia groups during the ongoing armed conflict in the Amhara region state.

The post also alleged that the helicopter had attacked and crashed in the Amhara region. This Facebook post gained traction on the platform, with 21 shares by the time this article was published.

Haqcheck inspected the image and confirmed that the picture doesn’t support the claim. As a result, the claim was rated False.

On April 6, 2023, the Ethiopian federal government announced that it had decided to disarm regional special police forces.

After the decision of the government, instability stormed the Amhara regional state opposing to dissolution of regional special police forces. Then Armed confrontations and clashes have taken place in the Amhara region.

The Fano militants took control of many areas including major cities in the region. The government soon after declared a state of emergency in the region to reverse the situation.

Despite the federal government reclaiming major areas of the Amhara region, fighting and armed confrontations between Ethiopian armed forces and Fano militia groups persisted.

In this context, a Facebook post came sharing an image with a claim that Fano militants downed an Ethiopian military helicopter in a recent confrontation.

HaqCheck investigated the claim and found that the image doesn’t support the claim. The original image had been previously published on a website on March 3, 2022, with a caption describing the crash of a Romanian helicopter searching for a fighter jet in the Black Sea.

Therefore, HaqCheck rendered the Facebook post False due to its usage of an inaccurate image.

Exit mobile version