Fact Checks

False: The image doesn’t show the gift the Amhara regional government presented to Eritrean President Isaias.

On Nov 30, 2022, a Facebook account posted an image showing Eritrean President Isaias Afwerki receiving a gift from Amhara regional state government delegates. The photo gift depicts a picture of Emperor Haile Selassie I and the post used the picture to criticize the supporters of the Eritrean ruling party saying “you are supporting this [President Isaias]” implicitly stating that the President was working with Eritrea’s historical enemies.

The post was shared several times on Facebook and got many reactions.

However, HaqCheck looked into the picture and confirmed that the image doesn’t show the present the representatives of the Amhara regional state gave to president Isaias. The image used in the post was photoshopped.

After Italy was defeated by the Allied Powers during WWII, the British military took control of the administration of the former Italian colony, Eritrea. In 1952, the United Nations decided that Eritrea should be federated with Ethiopia.

However, the last Emperor of the Ethiopian Empire, Haile Selassie I dismissed the federation and annexed Eritrea to be one of the provinces of Ethiopia with no autonomous status.

The Emperor had been facing armed resistance in Eritrea before he was overthrown by the Derg regime. The Eritrean President Isaias Afwerki himself was the leader of a popular armed insurgent (Eritrean People’s Liberation Front) resisting the Emperor and for the self-determination right of Eritrea.

After a two-decade of the no-peace-no-war situation between Eritrea and Ethiopia, peace was made between the countries. The leaders of the two countries signed a peace agreement in 2018.

The relationship between Ethiopia and Eritrea was greatly improved. Following the peace agreement, there were many government official tours and from-and-to travels.

Eritrean President Isaias Afwerki along with Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy visited various places in Ethiopia including Addis Ababa, Gondar, Hawassa, and Arba Minch.

In Sep 2018, delegates of the Amhara regional state government, led by Worksemu Mamo, speaker of the regional State Council traveled to Eritrea for a five-day visit. The delegation presented a gift to Eritrean President Isaias Afwerki.

The present given to the President was a picture that depicts the Geez alphabet, the Castles of Gondar,  the Obelisk of Axum, and the rock-hewn Church of Lalibela.

When the war between the Ethiopian government and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) broke out in October 2020 Eritrea was by the side of the Ethiopian federal government and allied regional forces helping defeat the TPLF armed forces.

It’s in this context that a Facebook post came out on Nov 30, 2022, claiming that Eritrean president Isaias Afwerki received a picture gift that depicts the image of the last Ethiopian Emperor, Haile Selassie I.

However, HaqCheck cross-checked the claim and confirmed that the image doesn’t prove the claim. The image presented to support the claim was altered.

The original image was first published on Facebook on Sep 14, 2018, and the gift that was presented to the President portrays the Geez alphabets, the Castles of Gondar, the Obelisk of Axum, and the rock-hewn Church of Lalibela.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the Facebook post False because it used an altered image.

False: The image doesn’t show a 25-meter-tall human skeleton found in Gojjam, Amhara region.

Two Facebook pages, West Gojjam Communications which has more than fifty-six thousand followers, and ShegerTimes-ሽገር ታይምስ with close to half a million followers shared an image on Nov 28, 2022, claiming that the picture shows a 25-meter tall human skeleton recently excavated in a small village in the West Gojjam zone of Amhara regional state.

The image-backed posts made by the Facebook pages went viral and gained many reactions on the same platform.

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the image doesn’t show a 25-meter-tall giant human skeleton discovered in the West Gojjam zone of the Amhara region. Therefore, the claim was rated False.

Prehistoric human skeletons and fossils have been excavated in Ethiopia. Archeologists discovered 3.2 million years old pieces of human fossils in a place called Hader in Afar regional state in 1974.

On this basis, a social media claim emerged and alleged that a 25-meter-tall human skeleton was recently discovered near a cemetery in the West Gojjam zone of the Amhara regional state. HaqCheck observed two viral Facebook posts using the same image to support the same claim.

HaqCheck investigated the image that was presented to back the claim. However, the image doesn’t show a 25-meter tall giant human skeleton recently found in the alleged area.

The picture was taken from an online publication made in September 2013. The image shows a giant prehistoric human skeleton excavated in the Sahara Desert in Niger by a scientist named Paul Sereno.

The image was also used in a documentary film named Skeletons Of The Sahara, produced by National Geographic Television.Therefore, HaqCheck rendered the claim False.

False: The circulating video of alleged Debretsion Gebremichael’s recent remarks on the peace deal and PM Abiy’ is old

A viral video was shared across social media platforms, mainly Facebook and Twitter, with a claim that the video was of a recent interview with TPLF chairman, Debretsion Gebremichael (PhD) about the peace agreement and he made good remarks on the deal and PM Abiy Ahmed (PhD).

The video was shared many times. It was watched by over 41 thousand users on a particular Twitter post.

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the video clip was taken from an old interview in 2018 on the peace agreement between Ethiopia and Eritrea. It was published on YouTube on Jul 15, 2018.

The Ethiopian federal government and the TPLF had been fighting a two years war that started on Nov 3, 2022.

They agreed to a humanitarian truce at the end of March 2022. However, fighting resumed between the belligerents in August.

Reports indicated that there were informal talks between the TPLF and the Ethiopian federal government to solve the war peacefully.

Finally, they signed a peace deal dubbed ‘Agreement for lasting peace through a permanent cessation of hostilities between the Government of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF)’ on Nov 2, 2022.

According to the deal, TPLF agreed to surrender its weapons to the Ethiopian government and a transitional government to be installed in Mekelle until a regional election is conducted.

The hostile propaganda against each other seems to have discontinued since the agreement was signed.

Against this backdrop, a viral video came out with a claim that it was a recent interview with TPLF chairman, Debretsion Gebremichael (PhD) about the peace agreement and he made good remarks on PM Abiy. The video clip circulated across social media platforms such as Facebook and Twitter.

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the video clip was taken from an old interview with Debretsion in 2018 about the peace agreement between Ethiopia and Eritrea. The recent video was extracted from the old one and was edited to make it look like a recent interview.

The original video was published on YouTube on Jul 15, 2018.

Thus, the posts were rated False.

December week one summary

HaqCheck investigated and debunked three viral social media claims during the first week of the month. Below are the false claims HaqCheck cross-checked throughout the week.

An alleged video of Debretsion Gebremichael’s recent interview

HaqCheck observed a viral video circulating across social media platforms, mainly Facebook and Twitter, with a claim that the video was of a recent interview with TPLF chairman, Debretsion Gebremichael (PhD) about the peace agreement and he made good remarks on the deal and PM Abiy Ahmed (PhD).

The claim came out after the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) and the Ethiopian government signed a peace agreement last month to end the two-year war that erupted in November 2020.

The TPLF chairman, Debretsion Gebremichael is heard in the clip saying, “our Prime Minister [Abiy Ahmed] opened a new chapter [of peace]”.

But, the video clip was not new. The clip was taken from an old interview made with the TPLF chairman in 2018 regarding the peace agreement between Ethiopia and Eritrea that ended the two-decade no-peace-no-war situation.

The original video was published on YouTube on Jul 15, 2018. HaqCheck confirmed that the recent video was extracted from the old one and was edited to make it look like a recent interview.

A 25-meter-tall human skeleton discovered in Gojjam

Another false claim HaqCheck looked into was an image-backed claim that a 25-meter-tall human skeleton was recently discovered in a small village in the West Gojjam zone of the Amhara regional state.

Two Facebook posts with the same claim and the same image emerged and were shared multiple times.

We inquired into the claim and the image presented to support the claim. However, HaqCheck confirmed that the picture doesn’t show a 25-meter tall giant human skeleton recently found in Gojjam, Amhara region.

The image was taken from an old publication made in September 2013 and it shows a giant prehistoric human skeleton excavated in the Sahara Desert in Niger. It was also used in a documentary film named Skeletons Of The Sahara, produced by National Geographic Television.

Amhara regional government presented Emperor Haile Selassie’s photograph as a gift to President Isaias

An image showing Eritrean President Isaias Afwerki receiving a gift from Amhara regional state government delegates was posted on Facebook on Nov 30, 2022.

The gift being presented to the President was a photograph of Emperor Haile Selassie I. The post used the picture to criticize the supporters of the Eritrean ruling party saying “you are supporting this [President Isaias]” implicitly stating that the President was working with Eritrea’s historical enemies.

It is true that delegates of the Amhara regional state government, led by Worksemu Mamo, speaker of the regional State Council traveled to Eritrea for a five-day visit in September 2018. The delegation presented a gift to Eritrean President Isaias Afwerki.

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the image shared by the Facebook account was altered. 

The original picture shows that the delegation presented to the President an image that contains the Geez alphabet, the Castles of Gondar,  the Obelisk of Axum, and the rock-hewn Church of Lalibela.

Thus, the post was rated False.

Recommendations

As always, HaqCheck recommends social media users be cautious about misleading and controversial claims. They should look for additional information such as fact-checks for potential false claims.

Disinformation and information disorder, in general, become intensified when sufficient information about ongoing issues is unavailable. We urge government offices and other entities to provide timely updates to the public.

We recommend the government to guarantee the right of citizens and the media to an open and secure access to information.

November monthly analysis

The settlement of the war lowered the disinformation dissemination rate

The phenomenal event that changed the course of the disinformation trend that had been in place for the last two years was the settlement of the war between the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) and the Ethiopian government at the beginning of the month.

The parties signed an ‘Agreement for lasting peace through a permanent cessation of hostilities between the Government of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF)’ in South Africa on Nov 2, 2022.

Before the signing of the peace agreement to resolve the two years war, the overwhelming majority of the false social media claims were related to the war. Seemingly organized groups had been orchestrating social media campaigns circulating false information.

The belligerents and affiliated entities had manufactured disinforming and toxic propaganda outputs. These propaganda outputs prompted false social media posts.

The disinformation trend was significantly decreasing immediately after the peace pact was stroke in Pretoria. 

Later on, the issue of false information transitioned from the war in the northern parts of the country to other different issues such as armed conflict and violence in Oromia.

New issues dominated the course of the disinformation trend

Few false claims related to the war in Tigray appeared, despite the main topics of false information being other that the armed conflict.

Since a peaceful settlement was reached to the armed conflict between the TPLF and the Ethiopian government other issues or topics of information disorder emerged.

HaqCheck observed three main topics of information disorder during the month. They were false claims regarding the alleged satellite town to be built in Addis Ababa, an ongoing armed conflict and violence in Wollaga, and post-war situations in the Tigray regional state.

False images of the alleged to-be-built satellite town

There were reports that the Ethiopian government was planning the construction of a new palace with one billion US dollars. During a parliamentary session on Nov 15, 2022, Prime Minister Abiy (PhD) confirmed that his government was constructing a modern satellite town that will cost billions of dollars.

False images of the design of the alleged satellite town were shared on social media platforms and virally circulated.

The images were old and taken from other places.

Armed conflict and violence in Wollega

As soon as the war in Tigray ended with the peace deal, social media posts related to conflicts and violence in Oromia started popping up.

Such social media posts were not new. HaqCheck had been debunking false claims regarding conflict and violence in the region. But the attention that had been given to the war between the TPLF and the Ethiopian government seems to shift to conflicts and attacks in Ormia, particularly Wollega.

Reports indicated that there had been armed conflict and attacks on civilians in Wollaga.

Granted this, false images were circulating on the Ethiopian social media landscape to support claims that recent government aerial and ground attacks targeted civilians in Wollega, Oromia.

Post-war situations in Tigray

HaqCheck came across a few social media claims regarding ongoing post-war situations in Tigray such as a public protest in Mekelle, TPLF hiding firearms, and TPLF combatants begun surrendering their weapons. These claims were accompanied by false images.

The peace agreement signed between the TPLF and the Ethiopian government asserts that the TPLF shall disarm and demobilize its armed combatants.

In this context, two social media posts supported by false images emerged. Four false images were shared on Facebook claiming that the TPLF was burying [hiding] weapons and ammunition.

The other debunked claim related to the issues was that a Tweet containing four images was made alleging TPLF militants in Maytsemri surrendered their weapons to local authorities and gathered in temporary camps.

However, the images presented to back the claim were old and taken from publications made two years ago.

A claim was also made on Twitter on Nov 20, 2022, sharing three false images alleging that Mekelle residents protested against [TPLF] armed forces for hindering the delivery of food aid to the city.

Change and consistency in the information disorder trend

HaqCheck figured out a change and continuity in the course of information disorder across the Ethiopian social media landscape.

The visible change we observed is that the main issue, the war between the TPLF and the Ethiopian government which was behind the disinformation trend is no longer the major topic. The issues of information disorder are now diversified.

HaqCheck spotted two continuity in the trend. One consistency was the application of false images. All the false claims HaqCheck debunked during the month of November were accompanied by images.

Besides, Facebook and Twitter continue to be the dominant pipelines of false claims. The two social media platforms, particularly the former, were the main grounds for false-image-backed information dissemination. All the false claims across-checked by HaqCheck in November were found on these platforms.

Recommendations

HaqCheck recommends social media users be skeptical of misleading and controversial information. They should look for original sources and additional details regarding potentially false claims.

Public authorities and other bodies should offer timely information about ongoing issues. Disinformation dissemination aggravates where information is limited.

Social media content creators are advised to be responsible and avoid circulating false information. They are one of the main factors for disinformation dissemination at a large scale.

Open access to information would greatly improve the availability of sufficient and accurate information reducing disinformation in the process. Governmental and non-governmental agencies should work towards the realization of the right to access information.

False: The images don’t show TPLF combatants disarming weapons

A Twitter account with more than 200 thousand followers shared a post claiming that TPLF militants in Maytsemri surrendered their weapons to local authorities and gathered in temporary camps. The post presented four pictures to support the claim.

By the time this article is published the post had close to two thousand reactions and was retweeted more than half a thousand times.

Yet, HaqCheck inspected the post and confirmed the images don’t support the claim. Accordingly, the post is rendered False.

On 2 November 2022, a peace deal was signed between Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) and the Ethiopian federal government.

The TPLF agreed to surrender its weapons and demobilize its combatant forces. The peace pact nullified the regional election conducted in the Tigray regional state without the consent of the federal government in September 2020.

On Nov 12, 2022, top military leaders of the Ethiopia National Defence Force (ENDF) and the TPLF forces (under the name of Tigray Armed Combatants) agreed to form a joint committee to “elaborate on the modalities for the implementation of comprehensive disarmament, demobilization and reintegration program.”

Per the peace agreement, disarmament of heavy weapons will be conducted when foreign forces and non-ENDF forces leave the Tigray region.

After disarmament and demobilization, TPLF combatants will be reintegrated into the Ethiopian army, according to the peace deal.

Against this backdrop, a claim appeared on Twitter sharing four images that TPLF combatants in Maytsemri were already surrendering their weapons to local authorities and gathering in temporary camps.

In an effort to verify the claim, HaqCheck spotted the images in a video shared by a local media outlet, Fana Broadcasting Corporation (FBC), on its Facebook and Youtube channels. The video was shared with the claim that TPLF’s arms depot was found in a raid in Mekelle.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post False due to its usage of inaccurate images to support the claim.

Do the images show Ethiopian armed forces in control of Aksum and Selekhlekha towns?

On Oct 19, 2022, a Facebook post was made sharing an image with a claim that the Ethiopian armed forces took control of the towns of Aksum and Selekhlekha. The first picture shows two men who wear the uniform of the Ethiopian National Defence Force (ENDF) walking and the obelisks of Aksum shown behind them. The other two depict persons carrying light weapons.

HaqCheck inspected the images to see if they support the claim and confirmed that one of the pictures was old and doesn’t prove the Ethiopian armed forces took control of the towns. Thus, the post was rated Partly false.

After months of tension, the federal government of Ethiopia and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) went to war on Nov 3, 2020.

The federal government allied with other regional armed forces removed TPLf from Mekelle and other major Tigayan towns after three weeks of conventional war.

However, the conflict became protracted as the TPLF resorted to guerrilla warfare.

After months, the federal government together with the provisional administration of Tigray declared a humanitarian ceasefire and withdrew its forces from Mekelle and other towns.

Thereafter, TPLF armed forces took control of the areas and advanced southward seizing territories in the Amhara and Afar regional states.

As the Ethiopian military and allied regional forces launched a counterattack against  TPLF, the federal government regained the captured areas of the Amhara and Afar regions.

On March 24, 2022, the Ethiopian government declared a truce and it was adopted by the TPLF.

There were informal talks between the parties to reach a peace pact with the help of the African Union and the United States.

On Aug 16, 2022, TPLF announced that the federal government already violated the cessation of hostilities jointly declared at the end of March. The TPLF said that the armed forces of the federal government fired artillery and attacked its forces.

It further stated that the main intention of the attacks by the federal government was to launch an integrated attack on the western front.

On the other hand, the Ethiopian government asserted that the TPLF resumed the fighting.

Sooner TPLF leaders also announced that there had been full-scale attacks around the Tigray region.

The Ethiopian government said that it controlled the Shire, Tigray region and began humanitarian aid delivery into captured areas.

In this context, a Facebook post emerged on Nov 19, 2022, sharing three images with a claim that the Ethiopian armed forces seized the town of Aksum and Selekhlekha.

However, one of the pictures was old and doesn’t prove the claim. The image was first published on a website on Feb 19, 2021.

Yet, Haqcheck could not confirm whether or not the second and third pictures support the claim.Therefore, the post was rated Partly False.

False: the images don’t show a design of a satellite town to be built in Addis Ababa.

A Facebook page with more than 38 thousand followers shared four images on Nov 18, 2022, claiming that the pictures are of a design of a satellite town to be built in Addis Ababa. The post also states that the satellite town (aka the Chaka Project) covers a large swath of land stretching from around Entoto to Tafo.

The Facebook post was viral and was shared many times on the same platform.

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the images don’t show a design of the so-called project and rendered it as False.

Since the coming of Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (PhD) to the premiership, the government launched ambitious projects in the capital city.

Among these fancy projects are Entoto Park, Friendship Park, Unity Park, the Meskel Square Underground Parking Lot, the Beautifying Sheger riverside project, the Science Museum, and the Abrehot Library. All except the riverside project are completed and open for visitors.

Reports show that the Office of the Prime Minister is undertaking the construction of a satellite town which will comprise a new national palace.

The project will lay on a thousand hectares of land in the Yeka district of Addis Ababa.

On Nov 15, 2022, Prime Minister Abiy (PhD) told members of the Parliament that the government is constructing a modern satellite town that will cost billions of dollars.

In this context, a claim emerged on Facebook sharing four images alleging that the pictures were of the design of the satellite town which is currently under construction.

Nonetheless, HaqCheck found out that the pictures don’t show the design of the alleged project.

The first image was published on a website on  Jul 15, 2010, and allegedly shows a design of a hotel in Moscow, Russia.

The second, third, and fifth pictures of the post are of a design of a smart forest city in Mexico. The images were first published on a website in October 2019.

The fourth image shows an overhead shot of Entoto Natural Park built on the northern outskirts of Addis Ababa.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post as False.

November week three summary

HaqCheck observed some false social media posts during the third week of November. Below are some of the debunked claims circulated across various social media platforms.

A design of a satellite town to be built in Addis Ababa

False images allegedly showing a design of a satellite town to be built in Addis Ababa were circulating across the Ethiopian social media landscape. On Nov 18, 2022, a Facebook post shared four images claiming that the images are of a design of the satellite town also known as Chaka Project.

However, the images don’t show the design of the so-called satellite town.

The images were old and show designs of other projects such as Entoto Natural Park, a hotel in Russia, and a smart forest city in Mexico.

Thus, the post was rated False.

Civilians killed in a drone attack in Oromia

Another claim HaqCheck debunked during the week was that the Ethiopian government conducted an aerial strike in the town of Mendi, in Wallagga, Oromia, and civilians were killed. A Twitter post shared two pictures and a cartoon image to support the claim.

However, HaqCheck cross-checked the authenticity of the pictures and confirmed that one of the images was taken from an old publication.

The first picture was taken from a Facebook post made on Jan 18, 2020. The post claimed that it shows a Uzbekistani fighter jet conducting an exercise.

But, HaqCheck could not verify whether the second picture is old or new. The picture is taken from a video clip that was recently circulating on Twitter.

Thus, the post was rated Partly False.

TPLF burying [hiding] weapons and ammunition

HaqCheck came across a viral Facebook post made on Nov 18, 2022, sharing four images to support a claim that the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) was burying [hiding] weapons and ammunition.

Nonetheless, the images don’t support the claim.

The first image was taken from a website and allegedly shows underground LPG (liquefied petroleum gas) tanks made by a manufacturer in China.

The second picture is of a surviving World War II tank which was dug up in May 2017.

The third image was first published by Reuters on Jul 27, 2021, and shows abandoned ammunition boxes in Tigray. The fourth picture was captured by the New York Times and it shows munitions and an upturned truck abandoned by the Ethiopian military.

Therefore, the post was rated False.

Recommendations

HaqCheck urges social media users to be conscious of potentially false and controversial social media posts and should look for additional sources for dubious claims.

We recommend the government and other relevant entities ensure the right of the public to full access to information. Government bodies should avail timely and sufficing updates for the public and the media.

Social media personalities are recommended to be responsible and avoid making and circulating false and misleading information.

Do the images prove Mekelle residents recently protested against TPLF armed forces?

A Twitter account that has sixteen thousand followers posted three images on Nov 20, 2022, to support a claim that residents of Mekelle protested against [TPLF] armed forces. The tweet alleges that the people protested because armed forces [of TPLF] hindered the delivery of food aid to the city. The Twitter post was viral and was retweeted over 250 times at that moment.

However, HaqCheck inquired into the claim and proved that two of the three images don’t show Mekelle residents recently protesting. Thus, the post was rated Partly False.

Fighting between the Ethiopian federal government and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) resumed on Aug 24, 2022, after TPLF announced that the truce that was bilaterally adopted at the end of March 2022 was already violated by the Ethiopian government.

Later on, the TPLF announced that the Ethiopian armed forces and allied combatants launched massive attacks from all directions into Tigray.

After fighting in northwestern Tigray, the federal government-led allied forces took control of major Tigrayan towns including Shire, Axum, and Adwa.

Reports indicated that there were informal talks between the TPLF and the Ethiopian federal government to settle the armed conflict.

Finally, the belligerents signed a peace deal dubbed ‘Agreement for lasting peace through a permanent cessation of hostilities between the Government of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF)’ in South Africa on Nov 2, 2022.

The Ethiopian government stated that aid has been flowing into the regional state after the peace agreement was signed. Other reports also indicate that humanitarian aid has since been delivered to Tigray.

The TPLF armed forces had been accused of looting USAID food aid in Amhara regional state. The World Food Program (WFP) also claimed that TPLF forces stole over half a million liters of fuel designated for humanitarian aid distribution in Tigray

Against this backdrop, a claim emerged on Twitter on Nov 20, 2022, alleging that Mekelle residents protested against [TPLF] armed forces for hindering food aid delivery into the city. The tweet shared three images to support the claim.

HaqCheck, however, proved that two of the three pictures were old.

The first image was taken from a Facebook post made on Jul 16, 2019. The picture shows a popular memorial monument in the heart of Mekelle city.

The second image was first published by Deutsche Welle (DW) Amharic on Jul 27, 2021, along with a short news story that Mekelle University students who were stranded in Tigray after TPLF armed forces captured the regional capital were safely evacuated.

HaqCheck could not confirm whether the third image supports the claim or not.Therefore, the post was rendered as Partly False.

Exit mobile version