Does the video demonstrate a recent massacre that took place in Western Wollega?

A Facebook page with more than 196 thousand followers shared a 13-minute and 5-second video on Jun 21, 2022, captioned “this video shows the massacre in west Wollega.” by the time this article is published the video had more than 83 thousand views and the post was shared more than thousand times.

However, HaqCheck has inspected the video and rendered it False.

On Jun 14, 2022, there was a report of gunfire exchange between joint forces of the Oromo Liberation Front (OLA) and Gambella Liberation Front (GLA). According to news reports, the two rebel forces conducted a sudden siege in the town and opened an attack on government forces. The government finally announced it controlled the situation. 

At the same day it is also reported that there was a skirmish in Dembi Dolo and Gimbi cities in western Wollega among OLA and government forces, and some parts of the cities are controlled by OLA. Odda Tarbi the International spokesperson of the OLA, said on his official Twitter account that OLA forces are engaging the government’s military in Dambidollo and Gimbi and Political prisoners that were being held in Dambidollo have been freed.

Later on, on Jun 18, different posts appeared claiming that the Oromo Libration Army (OLA) massacred Ethnic Amhara’s who live in west wollega Gimbi woreda Tole kebele.

But spoke person of the OLA Odda tarbii has denied the accusation of the killing by the federal government.

OLA has shared a statement on its communique website that PM Abiy’s regime organized a militia group called “Gachana Sirna” meaning “the guardians of the regime” that wear artificial wigs to impersonate members of the OLA and commit atrocity crimes in Oromia.

HaqCheck has inspected the video and found out that the video was first shared on  Jul 23, 2021, on a Facebook Account. The video iscaptioned, “WBO [OLA] is freeing prisoners, Thousands of WBO commandos are marching to 4killo.”. The post had more than 400 views.

HaqCheck Found the same footage of people and the armed militias in the videos.

Even though there are several claims that a massacre is conducted in West Wollega, the video used by the Facebook page to support the claim is found out to be old.

Therefore HaqCheck counterchecked the post and rendered it False.     

Did TPLF announce it has no interest in Negotiation?

A video clip emerged on YouTube on June 17, with a thumbnail on which is written a claim that the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF)  stated that it is not interested to hold a negotiation with the federal government of Ethiopia.

Though the thumbnail and the title of the video claim that TPLF has no interest in negotiation, the content of the video explains the five preconditions set by TPLF for the supposed negotiation.

HaqCheck, thus, rated the video clip MISLEADING.

The federal government of Ethiopia and the TPLF have been in an armed conflict since November 2020.

The belligerents declared a humanitarian truce in March 2022. Since then the flow of humanitarian aid flow was improved.

There have been unconfirmed reports of direct talks between senior leaders of the Ethiopian federal government and TPLF.

Claims also emerged that the federal government of Ethiopia and the TPLF were preparing for potential negotiations.

Last week, Le Monde, a French newspaper published a news article claiming that the Ethiopian government and TPLF will conduct a negotiation in Arusha, Tanzania at the end of the month of June 2022.

The news by the French newspaper also claimed diplomats told the paper that TPLF was gradually abandoning its claims to ‘Western Tigray’ territories.

TPLF later denied the claim that it dropped its claim to the contested territories.

Later on, the chairman of TPLF Debretsion Gebremichael wrote an open letter and confirmed that his administration will send a delegation to the peace talk initiative that will be held in Nairobi, Kenya.

Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed, during a parliament session last week said that the federal government has already formed a committee to undertake the negotiation with the TPLF.

Both Debretsion and PM Abiy confirmed that formal negotiation has not yet started between the belligerents denying claims that direct peace talks have already begun in secret.

TPLF recently announced five non-negotiable preconditions such as ‘Western Tigray’ and other territories, a referendum, preservation of its army, accountability to alleged crimes, and compensation to negotiate with the federal government.

On June 16, 2022, Kindeya Gebrehiwet, a senior TPLF official shared these five non-negotiable preconditions on his Twitter account.

The video clip appeared in this background with a misleading thumbnail reporting that TPLF refused to negotiate with the federal government.

It can be clearly indicated that there is no connection between the thumbnail and title of the clip and its actual content. The title and thumbnail say that TPLF announced it doesn’t want negotiation while the content states TPLF presented five preconditions for negotiation.

HaqCheck confirmed that TPLF has not refused negotiation with the federal government and only announced its preconditions for the negotiation.Therefore, HaqCheck rated the video clip MISLEADING as there is no coherence between the title of the YouTube video and its content.

Is Yemane Gebremeskel Eritrea’s Foreign Minister?

A video claiming that Yemane Gebremeskel is the Foreign Minister of Eritrea was published on YouTube on June 9, 2022. The video explains that while Ethiopia’s relations with the United States have recently improved, Eritrea’s on the contrary worsened. 

It is stated in the video that Eritrean Foreign Minister Yemane Gebremeskel and the US embassy in Asmara have been quarreling over political, international, and religious issues signaling the deterioration of the relationship between the two countries.

HaqCheck, however, confirmed that Yemane Gebremeskel is Eritrea’s Minister of Information, not the Foreign Minister.

The US relations with Eritrea and Ethiopia worsened since the outbreak of the war in Tigray in November 2020. US-Ethiopia relations began to deteriorate in 2020 when the US halted financial assistance to Ethiopia over the first filling of the Great Ethiopian Renaissance Dam.

The US government has accused the Eritrean and Ethiopian governments of human rights abuses during the armed conflict with Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF).

The Biden administration repeatedly called for the withdrawal of the Eritrean army from Ethiopia and later sanctioned Eritrea and the Eritrean army chief.

Eritrea in its part accused the American government of destabilizing the region by supporting TPLF.

Yemane Gebremeskel an Eritrean senior government official who is active on social media has been accusing and blaming the US for supporting the TPLF and destabilizing the Horn of Africa region on his verified Twitter account.

The American Embassy in Asmara, Eritrea, on its verified Facebook page, also accused the Eritrean government of human rights abuses in Ethiopia’s Tigray regional state and inside Eritrea. The page of the embassy also blamed Yemane Gebremeskel for fabricating disinformation on social media platforms.

However, Yemane Gebremeskel is Eritrea’s Information Minister. The Minister of Foreign Affairs of Eritrea is named Osman Salih and is usually accompanied by Presidential advisor Yemane Gebreab during his official visits outside Eritrea.

Yemane was appointed Information Minister in 2015 after the former Minister Ali Abdu defected. Previously, he was chief of staff of the Office of the Eritrean President.

Thus, HaqCheck confirmed that Yemane Gebremeskel is not Eritrea’s Foreign Minister and debunked the claim rating it FALSE.

Does the image show property of Zemene Kassie’s mother destroyed by government forces?

A Facebook page with more than 150 thousand followers shared a post on May 31, 2022, captioned, “This is breaking news!! The TPLF did not loot and burn the property of  Zemene Kassie’s mother when he escaped to Eritrea. But today, Abiy Ahmed’s government, whose seat and the people are rescued at turbulent times by Zemene Kassie, burnt and demolished the house of Zemene’s mother as such.” Zemene Kassie claims to be the leader of Fano, a volunteer Amhara youth militia. 

By the time this article is published the post had more than 190 reactions and was shared more than 65 Times.

However, HaqCheck inspected the image and rendered it False. 

Fano is the name for an Amhara youth volunteering to defend the Country. Fano responded to the government’s call to arms as the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) launched a military offensive on the Amhara and Tigray regions. The group was armed by the government and was fighting alongside the Ethiopian National Defence Forces (ENDF) during the war.  

On Dec 20, 2021, Tigrayan forces fighting the central government said they have withdrawn from neighboring regions in northern Ethiopia, a step toward a possible ceasefire after 13 months of the brutal war.

On Mar 24, 2022, The Federal government declared a humanitarian truce in Tigray.

“Cognizant of the need to take extraordinary measures to save lives and reduce human suffering, the Government of Ethiopia hereby declares an indefinite humanitarian truce effective immediately.” the statement reads.

On May 25, 2022, the Amhara regional government releases a statement that internal enemies of the Amhara people are engaging in acts of violence, instability, and disorder in the Amhara region and, The people of the region have repeatedly called on the government to uphold the rule of law. Therefore the Regional government will work to fulfill its obligation and maintain the law and order.

Thereafter, different social media and news outlets were claiming that there had been an engagement between the Federal Government and Local Fano militias.

A popular English news website reported that Clashes broke out on March 6 in Mota town, in East Gojjam Zone of Amhara Regional State, leaving unknown numbers injured. Moreover, according to a news by Wazema Radio, tension was running high in the town following the arrest of the leader of the local Fano by government security forces.

The regional government however defended the actions as law enforcement measures taken against informal groups it claimed are working to destabilize the region. The President of the Amhara Region, Yilkal Kefale (Ph.D.), said, “The regional government has no intentions of disarming or attacking Fano.” He explained that the measures targeted those who are involved in criminal activities such as illegal arms trafficking, killing, and robbery.

Despite the Government’s assurance, federal and regional security forces were reported to conduct a crackdown on major Fano leaders arresting them and raising their houses.  

On the other hand, A website called My views on news published a post on May 23 that Zemene Kassie warned the Federal Government.     

Zemene Kassie, Fano militia commander warns the Ethiopian gov’t 

Different social media posts were also observed reporting the properties of Fano Zemene Kassies’ families were destroyed by the federal and regional Forces. 

A Facebook page with more than 180 thousand followers said in a post that Zemene Kassie’s brother Nebret Kassie confirmed government militias destroyed their property and left their 85-year-old Mom on the streets.   

It was taking this background of the situation that the Facebook post emerged.

In an effort of counterchecking the claim, HaqCheck found the image alongside other three posted on Jan 23 previously on a Twitter account with more than 13 thousand followers captioned in Affan Oromo language, “These pictures show the damage the armed forces, who came here crossing the Nile, did to Oromo farmers in #Amuruu District of Horroo Guduruu Region.”

Even though there are several claims that the property of Zemen Kassies’ Family was destroyed by armed forces, the image used by the Facebook post to support the claim is wrong.
Thus, HaqCheck checked the image used to prove the claim and rendered it False.

False: The image doesn’t show Olusegun Obasanjo recently met with Merara Gudina

A Twitter Account with more than 25,000 followers posted an image on Jun 02, 2022, claiming “Olusegun Obasanjo also held talks about peace with the great political scholar Professor Merara Gudina!”

By the time this article was published, the post had more than 150 reactions and was retweeted more than 35 times. 

However, HaqCheck looked into the image and rated it FALSE.

The Ethiopian federal government has been engaged in an armed conflict with TPLF forces in the Tigray region since November 2020.

A humanitarian truce was declared by the federal government and was also adopted by the TPLF a few months ago.

On 26th August 2021, Olusegun Obasanjo, former President of the Federal government of Nigeria, was appointed as High Representative for the Horn of Africa region. The representative is entitled to work towards entrenching durable peace and stability within the Horn of Africa.

To seek a peaceful solution H.E. Olusegun Obasanjo met with the leader of TPLF and government officials several times. The representative has been tasked with convincing parties to accept a ceasefire and choose dialogue.

On May 31, the AU special envoy met with TPLF leader, Debretsion Gebremichael in the capital of the region of Tigray, Mekelle. After two days, he arrived in Bale Robe Oromia state, with Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed and government officials for a working visit. 

Based on this background, the Twitter post came out claiming that Obasanjo talked about peace with Professor Merara Gudina, a prominent Oromo opposition leader.

However, the image was taken from an old publication on the Internet. The original image was published on African Union’s official website on Jun 21, 2021, with the caption “The Head of the AU election observation mission, H.E. Chief Olusegun Obasanjo, meeting with the leader of the Oromo Federalist Congress (OFC), Dr. Merera”.  

Therefore, HaqCheck confirmed that the image used to support the claim is old and rated it FALSE.

False: The image doesn’t show recent dead bodies of Amhara civilians killed by the government

On May 26, 2022, a picture tweet appeared on a Twitter page with the description phrase, “Dead bodies of Amhara civilians in Gojjam. These victims were killed by the government forces.”

At the time this article was published, the tweet was shared 40 times and got 47 reactions.

However, HaqCheck interrogated the image and confirmed that the image doesn’t show dead bodies of Amhara civilians in Gojam killed by the Government recently.

Tensions between the Fano militia and the federal government has been rising in the Amhara region over the past few months. Last week, tensions came to a head and several rounds of clashes were reported as regional special forces attempted to arrest or disarm Fano militia leaders. 

A crackdown on Amhara ethno-nationalist actors, including members of the seat-holding National Movement of the Amhara (NaMA) party, journalists, and individuals throughout Amhara region is reported to signify a new rift in the relationship between Amhara ethno-nationalists and the Amhara Prosperity Party.

From the federal government’s perspective, Fano militias operate outside of the federal government’s command structure and are thus a threat to the safety and security of Ethiopia.

Violence began last week shortly after Amhara regional authorities issued a decree requesting that all weapons be registered by the end of the week. According to the regional government, a “law enforcement operation” was necessary for the Amhara region given a recent spate of smuggling incidents, shootings, and interference with court decisions.

As part of the operation, over 4,500 people have been arrested. The regional government reaffirmed that this operation is not against Fano militias but against “criminals” who operate under the Fano name. However, for many in the region, the language of the decree and the following government’s actions were understood as a crackdown on Amhara ethno-nationalist interests and actors.

Last week, on 19 May, members of Fano and government forces clashed in Mota in East Gojam zone of the Amhara region after government forces entered the area and attempted to disarm the group’s members. At least two people were killed and 15 others were injured.

The tweet is published taking advantage of this situation and HaqCheck found that the image used in the post is from a report published on a website in 2015 titled “Ethnic Based Massacre & Genocide Of Ethiopia (2003 – 2018)”

Therefore, HaqCheck confirmed that the image used to support the claim is old and does not relate to the claim to represent the recent news reported by the post, and rated it FALSE.

Altered: The image doesn’t show a recent mass revolt in Tigray

A Twitter account with more than 1100 followers shared a post on May 24, 2022, captioned, “In Tigray, there has been civil unrest, the people of Tigray are saying, ‘May Abiy Ahmed lead us’.” In the picture are depicted rallying people holding different slogan signs having an overlay text that read “May Abiy Ahmed lead us”, “Getachew Reda is criminal”, “TPLF is a thief” along with other two arbitrarily placed texts over the images.

By the time this article was published the post had more than 80 reactions and was retweeted more than 30 times.

However, HaqCheck has examined the image and rendered it Altered.

The prolonged war between the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) and the federal government and its allied forces has remained unsolved.

TPLF has been stating that if the diplomatic means to end the war fail, it will resort to other means indicating that it will seek military solutions. TPLF has been accusing the federal government and regional authorities of blocking aid from entering Tigray and has complained the aid that has recently reached was below that need.

On May 20, TPLF announced in its press release that “The Government of Tigray, consistent with its principled preference for the peaceful resolution of political differences, had agreed to undertake even unilateral confidence-building measures. Accordingly, per the promise we made to chief Obasanjo, we have decided to release 4208 prisoners of war. Of those to be released 401 are women,” reads the statement.

On Jan 13, 2022, Field Martial Birhanu Jula of the Ethiopian Defense Forces said in an interview, “Tigray people don’t have to die for the sake of TPLF anymore, thousands of lives are lost. People of Tigray have to say no to TPLF.”

In a close inspection of the images, HaqCheck found out that the two images on a Facebook post are from DW Amharic’s page on Oct 2, 2018, which reads, “University students and their families who claim to feel insecure held demonstrations in Mekele today. Speaking of their fear of attending their classes in areas where there is a security concern, they appealed to the government to come up with a possible solution. On the rally signs having the messages, ‘I’m concerned about the life of Tigrayans’, ‘we don’t send our children to an insecure place’, ‘students shouldn’t pay sacrifices in vain’, ‘may regional and federal governments give us solutions’ were displayed”

Image one 

Image two

The third image was found on borkena.com in a news article on June 27, 2018, titled, “Fresh ethnic-based violence in Asossa left at least eight people dead.”

The news stated, citing social media reports that “ ethnic Berta youth, who consider themselves to be “locals” as they tend to see everyone else as aliens, organized themselves to launch an attack on businesses owned by ethnic Amhara and Oromo. And in what seems to be an effort to defend themselves, ethnic Amhara tried to respond to the attack but it is not clear if there are victims from the ethnic Berta community.”

Image three

Even though the first two images show a protest in Tigray, the Doctored images used to support the claim are learned to be False. Besides, the second picture is known to be not from Tigray,
Therefore HaqCheck has inspected the images and rendered them Altered.

False: the screenshot doesn’t show Eritrean security officials exposed Ethio 360, Ethio Forum’s conspiracy with TPLF

A viral tweet appeared on May 25, 2022, claiming that Eritrean security officials recently exposed that Ethio 360 and Ethio Forum discussed online with senior TPLF leaders and agreed to work together. The tweet implicitly accused the media outlets of echoing ‘TPLF’s agenda’.

It presented a screenshot of a text written in Tigrinya in a bid to support the claim.

However, HaqCheck looked into the case and confirmed the screenshot doesn’t show that Eritrean security officials claimed to reveal the three mentioned entities recently discussed and agreed to work together.

There has been an armed conflict between the federal government along with Ethiopian allied forces and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front/TPLF since November 2020. A few months ago, a humanitarian truce was declared by the Ethiopian government and instantly adopted by the TPLF.

The federal government and the Amhara regional administration recently started a military campaign named ‘law enforcement operation’ to disarm armed groups and criminal gangs.

Meanwhile, the Ethio 360 and Ethio Forum online media remained critical of the Ethiopian government and the ruling Prosperity Party, especially following the war in Tigray.

The National Movement of Amhara in its recent statement issued on May 24, 2022, criticized the Ethio 360 media for working with TPLF to destabilize the Amhara Regional State.

There has also been a claim and accusation that Ethio Forum is affiliated with TPLF. There was recently an allegation that Ethio Forum received 1.8 million Birr in funds from TPLF.

The tweet emerged in this background claiming that Eritrean security officials exposed there was a recent online discussion organized by the TPLF in which the Ethio 360, Ethio Forum, and members of the ‘Digital Weyane’ took part. The claim stated that the Ethio Forum and Ethio 360 received a new agenda from the TPLF with a mission of fuelling conflict and instability in the country.

HaqCheck checked the screenshot to examine whether it proves the claim. The screenshot was taken from a Facebook post made on May 23, 2022. The Facebook post was made by a page named ‘Center for Research and Documentation’, a social media portal for a news and media website. The page claimed that it got the information from its exclusive sources that there was an online discussion in which TPLF senior leaders, Ethio Forum, Ethio 360, and members of digital Weyane participated.

The page wrote that it obtained the information from its exclusive sources, not that from Eritrean security officials as claimed by the tweet post under discussion. Hence the screenshot documentation presented by the post as evidence happens to be different from what it reported.

Thus, HaqCheck rated the tweet FALSE

False: the image doesn’t show members of defense forces who joined OLA

A Facebook page with more than 70 thousand followers shared a post on May 14, 2022, with a picture captioned, “we have heard that several members of the [federal] defense forces have joined the Oromo Liberation Army (OLA).”

By the time this article is published the post got more than 200 reactions and was shared more than 20 times.

However, HaqCheck has interrogated the image used to support the claim and rendered it False. 

Oromo Liberation Army (OLA), which is called OLF-Shane by the federal government of Ethiopia, was a military wing of the Oromo Liberation Front (OLF) from which it claimed to split independently later on May 1, 2021.

On Apr 9, 2022, the Oromo Federalist Congress (OFC) released a statement urging the Federal government to resolve the armed conflict it is engaged in with OLF-Shane in peaceful terms and bring the armed group to the political space. The party also appealed to the government to stretch its hands of peace to OLF-Shane as it did in Tigray.

Several reports of summary executions and civilian casualties of airstrikes have been coming out of Oromia in the past weeks. Civilians continue to be targeted by government forces.

On Saturday 02 April, Colonel Girma Ayele, Coordinator of ENDF’s Southern Command, said that the army has launched a decisive action against the group. According to the Colonel, a coordinated operation against the group by the federal and regional forces resulted in the arrest of OLA members and confiscation of a variety of weapons and ammunition as well as medical supplies. 

Different posts have been appearing with the claim that members of the defense forces, the federal police, and republican guards are splitting into ethnic lines and joining OLA.

Republican guards defected to OLA Link

The Ethiopian military has been separated from ethnic groups. Link

The Facebook post is, thus, published taking advantage of this situation as a context to justify its claim.

HaqCheck has looked into the image used in the post and discovered that the image was previously published on a Facebook page having more than 140 thousand followers as breaking news on Oct 31, 2021, with the description, “Abiy Ahmed’s defense force is completely destroyed. The soldiers spared from Dessie are handing over their weapons at Kemise  managing to get transportation to central Ethiopia.”  

Even though there are several claims that government forces are defecting to OLA, the image used by the Facebook page to support the claim is wrong.
For that reason, HaqCheck has checked the image and rendered it False.

Do the images show Ethiopia’s C-130 Hercules aircrafts?

A Facebook post sharing five images emerged on May 15, 2022, claiming the pictures show the C-130 Hercules jets Ethiopia is armed with.

The post went viral and was shared over 44 times and got more than half a thousand reactions.

However, HaqCheck cross-checked the images and confirmed the claim to be Partly False.

The protracted war between the TPLF and the federal government and its allied forces has remained unsolved.

A humanitarian truce was declared by the federal government and was also adopted by the TPLF a few months ago. This was seen as a glimmer of hope and a window of opportunity for peace talks and peaceful resettlement of the armed conflict.

There was also an unconfirmed report that Debretsion Gebremichael, TPLF chairman, and Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy directly talked to one another over the phone after the truce was announced.

In audio released on YouTube, a senior military leader of the TPLF armed forces disclosed that there were direct talks and stated that he and Tadesse Werede met Field Marshal Birhanu Jula, chief staff of ENDF in Mauritius.

Asked, Birhanu Jula denied the claim that he met with the senior TPLF military leaders.

TPLF has been stating that if the diplomatic means to end the war fail, it will resort to other means indicating that it will seek military means. TPLF has been accusing the federal government and regional authorities of blocking aid from entering Tigray and complained that the aid that has recently reached was below what is needed.

A week ago Prime Minister Abiy visited the Ethiopian National Defence Forces in the town of Humera and observed its status.

Meanwhile, public conferences have been conducted in Tigray in many towns. Senior TPLF leaders including Debretsion Gebremichael, Fetleweerk Gebregziabher, Getachew Reda, and Alem Gebrewahd led the public forums and made speeches.

In a meeting in Mekelle on May 10, 2022, Debretsion Gebremichael said that the peaceful means to resolve the war has already been exhausted and called on the people to prepare for the ‘final stage’.

Reports of incursions have also appeared recently and there is a fear that a full military engagement may resume.

Recently, the Ethiopian government accused TPLF of ‘beating drums of war’ and appealed to the European Union to reprimand and urge TPLF to stop ushering in another potential war.

In this background, a Facebook post came out sharing five images to support a claim that they show Ethiopia’s C-130 Hercules jets.

The US government on June 6, 2018, delivered Ethiopia one C-130 Hercules aircraft to help the country in its peacekeeping operations, whose image is included among the five images of the post.

However, four of the five images were taken from other old publications and don’t show Ethiopian C-130 Hercules jets.

Image one

The image was taken from a video published on a YouTube channel on Jul 1, 2014, showing an Airbus A400M aircraft.

Image two

This image was snipped from a video clip released by the US Department of Defense on Twitter on Feb 28, 2018, picturing an AC-130 Hercules aircraft, nicknamed ‘the Angel of Death’.

Image three

The image was taken from a video published by the US Department of Defense and shows American crews training Ethiopian officers on how to maintain the C-130 Hercules aircraft delivered by the US to Ethiopia on June 6, 2018.

Image four

This image was a screenshot from a video published on YouTube on May 13, 2022. The video on the channel itself was also taken from another previous video published on Sep 15, 2020, on YouTube that shows an American C-130 Hercules aircraft.

Image five

Similar to image four, this image was a screenshot from a video published on YouTube on May 13, 2022. The video on the channel itself was also taken from another previous video published on Sep 15, 2020, on YouTube and explains the strength of the American C-130 Hercules aircraft.

Thus, it is found out that only one of the five images posted to support the claim was true. The rest four images were false and don’t show Ethiopia’s C-130 Hercules aircrafts.Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post PARTLY FALSE.

Exit mobile version