False: BBC Amharic didn’t report an interview with Fano Asres Amare.

During conflicts, the prevalence of false information increases. Recently, a Facebook post incorrectly attributed a statement to Asres Mare, identified as the head of the political department of the Fano, a rebel group in Amhara Region, in the Army division of Gojjam.

The quote in question, “We have been outmatched in the fight we are having with the enemy, but it does not lead to defeat,” circulated widely, sparking discussions and reactions. Allegedly Asres told BBC about the ascendancy of the government forces during the battle the fano forces engaged in.

However, a thorough investigation by HaqCheck has debunked this assertion, as there is no record of such an article on the BBC News Amharic website. This absence of credible sources solidifies the conclusion that the claim is baseless and false.


Screenshot taken from the Facebook account

Gojjam is a zone of Ethiopia’s Amhara region, located in the northwest. The name Fano loosely translates to “freedom fighter” for paramilitary forces claiming to represent Amhara ethnic groups. 

What makes this assertion particularly alarming is the assertion that BBC News Amharic reported on this statement. 

Screenshots of Facebook accounts mentioning BBC Amharic

Asres Mare is a key leader within the Gojjam faction of the Fano militia, actively involved in military operations against Ethiopian federal forces.

HaqCheck searched BBC Amharic’s posts over the past three months and found no news report asserting the conversation between BBC Amharic and Fano soldier Asres Mare. We can’t also find the date of publishing on the alleged post circulating online.


The screen record displays the posts from BBC Amharic over the past three months

BBC-Amharic is the Amharic-language service of the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC), which provides news and information to Amharic-speaking audiences, primarily in Ethiopia, and covers regional affairs in the Horn of Africa and significant international events. It is part of the BBC World Service, which aims to inform, educate, and entertain audiences through various languages.

Furthermore, upon closer inspection through visual investigation techniques, it has been determined that the associated image has been doctored, casting further doubt on the authenticity of the purported statement by Asres Mare.

The image used in the claimed BBC Amharic post was also spotted by HaqCheck. The alleged Facebook page by the name አስረስ ማረ ዳምጤ – Asres Mare Damtie as he updated a new profile picture on June 20, 2022.


Screenshot taken from the post on June 20, 2022

There are rare cases when news outlets remove articles from their websites after they have reached a wide audience.

Therefore, HaqCheck reached out to Ashagre Hailu, BBC Amharic editor about the viral post that had been spread online. He stated that the content was fabricated despite using their template. BBC Amharic posts frequently include links to stories on their website. 

He also advises that viewers should seek a link that takes them to the official BBC Amharic website, https://www.bbc.com/amharic to determine whether the story is from the BBC or not.

The implications of such misinformation are significant. False narratives not only distort the truth but also have the potential to sow confusion, incite panic, and harm the credibility of legitimate news sources.

Because of the reasons stated above HaqCheck rated the post false.

Does this video show a recent speech of President-elect Donald Trump about DV lottery?

Recently, a video featuring a speech by the President-elect Donald Trump discussing restrictions set to be imposed on the Diversity Visa Lottery resurfaced on TikTok.

A screenshot taken from the TikTok video

This video, however, is a repost from 2017, where Trump expressed his intentions to terminate the Diversity Visa program, citing it as a detriment to the country. HaqCheck rendered the post Misleading.

A screenshot of the original video taken from NBC News official Youtube channel

NBC News is a prominent American news organization that provides comprehensive coverage of national and international news, including politics, business, health, science, and pop culture. It offers a variety of content through its website, TV broadcasts, and digital platforms, ensuring audiences stay informed with the latest breaking news, in-depth analysis, and exclusive reports.

Throughout his presidency and beyond, Donald Trump has been known for his hardline stance on immigration, often advocating for stricter border control measures and limits on certain immigration programs. In the case of the Diversity Visa Lottery, Trump has been vocal about his opposition to the program, labeling it as a potential security risk and criticizing it for what he perceives as its failure to serve the best interests of the United States.

Trump’s views on immigrants, particularly those entering through programs like the Diversity Visa Lottery, have been characterized by his “America First” rhetoric, emphasizing the protection of American jobs and national security above all else. His criticism of the Diversity Visa program has been rooted in concerns about the vetting process for applicants and the perceived lack of merit-based criteria in selecting beneficiaries.

A screenshot taken from Time website

Trump’s stance on the Diversity Visa Lottery has been a contention throughout his political career. While some support his efforts to tighten immigration restrictions for national security reasons, others view such actions as detrimental to the values of diversity and inclusion that the United States has long championed.

The deceptive nature of this video, falsely implying it was a recent speech, would raise concerns about manipulating information and spreading misinformation on social media platforms. 

Misleading posts can have detrimental effects on immigrants and immigrant communities. Such content perpetuates false narratives about immigration policies and individuals seeking to migrate to the United States, potentially fueling xenophobia and discrimination. Immigrants may face increased hostility or prejudice as a result of misinformation that portrays them in a negative light or inaccurately depicts the intentions of political figures regarding immigration.

Misrepresentations of government actions or intentions can lead to heightened anxiety and mistrust within immigrant communities, impacting their sense of security and belonging.

This underscores the importance of fact-checking and verifying sources in an era where misinformation can easily proliferate online. It highlights the need for critical thinking and discernment when consuming content, especially when it comes to sensitive and politically charged topics such as immigration policy.

Despite numerous assertions, the video featuring President-elect Donald Trump discussing the proposed Diversity Visa Lottery restrictions appears outdated.

Because of the reason stated above, HaqCheck inspected the post and rendered it misleading.

Is Ethiopia the second country in Africa in terms of military capacity?

In recent years, it has been common that whenever Ethiopia encounters a conflict or other foreign diplomatic issues that are directly or indirectly related to war, Ethiopian social media is swamped with videos comparing Ethiopia’s military power to neighboring countries.

Recently, a claim with an infographic representation went viral on Facebook, claiming to show the African military strength rank of 2024. According to the post shared by the Facebook account, South Africa, Ethiopia, Algeria, Egypt, and Nigeria are ranked respectively. Identical claims were also shared here, here, and here on Nov 12, 2024.

Nevertheless, HaqCheck analyzed the source and allegation and declared the post false. 

      Screenshot of multiple misleading Facebook posts, captured on November 12, 2024

A country’s military strength is typically evaluated through various metrics, including the number of active and reserve personnel, equipment capacity, which refers to the amount of material personnel and resources military equipment can handle, defense budgets, and logistical capabilities, which involve planning, executing, and managing the movement and maintenance of forces and their supplies. 

What defines a country’s military power? 

Military strength is a broad, diverse concept that includes many factors contributing to a country’s ability to demonstrate power and defend its interests. The size of a country’s armed forces does not solely determine its military power; it also involves an intricate interplay of factors that either enhance or diminish military effectiveness.

These factors include the quality and technological advancement of military equipment, the strategic positioning of forces, and the financial resources available for defense spending.

A country’s military power can also be defined by its personnel strength, equipment quality and quantity, strategic positioning, financial resources, industrial base capabilities, doctrine and strategy formulation, alliances, and operational readiness.

Military rank of Africa 2024

Some key organizations and entities assess and rank countries’ military capabilities worldwide. These rankings typically consider various factors, including military personnel, equipment, budget, logistics, and overall strategic capabilities.

Among those organizations, Global Firepower is widely recognized for its comprehensive assessments of national military capabilities and defense resources of countries worldwide. Global firepower uses a unique ranking system that evaluates nations’ military strength based on various quantitative and qualitative factors.

The military data we found from different websites and news sources are taken from the Global Fire Power website as a source.

Their annual report, often referred to as the GFP Index, ranks countries based on their military capabilities, resources, and overall power. The reports by Global Firepower contain more than 60 factors to measure a country’s power index. In the 2024 GFP report, 145 countries are considered. 

               
Screen record is taken from Global Fire Power African Military Strength (2024) Ranking

Statista, which has been used as a source of the claims, is a global data and business intelligence platform providing access to a vast collection of statistics, reports, and insights across over 80,000 topics. It also released a report about the Military power ranking in Africa in 2024.

     
Screen record is taken from:
Statista Military power ranking in Africa 2024, by leading countries

As per our research, Statista receives information and data from market research institutes, government agencies, academic institutions, industry reports, and publications.

The infographic information these Facebook posts share holds a logo named “Statisense.” HaqCheck tried to find information about this platform and discovered that Statisesne is a pioneering AI data company focused on transforming how businesses interact with and analyze their financial data. It also operates as a data visualization platform, providing released insights through its evolving AI capabilities.

                 
                    Screenshot of a Statisense logo detected on the alleged posts

HaqCheck looked for the original infographic post uploaded on Statisense’s social media platforms and found it. The original post was shared on Statisense’s official X account on February 6, 2024. According to our assessment, the infographic disseminated on the Ethiopian social media site has been modified. The accounts modified several of the country’s flags and ranked them. 


                            Screen records taken from the original and alleged claims

We emailed Statisense to confirm whether their office identified or detected this content but did not receive a response when the article was published. 

Conclusion 

The claim that Ethiopia has the second-most powerful military in Africa circulated widely on Ethiopian social media. However, HaqCheck rated this claim as false. The original infographic does not support this assertion, nor do widely recognized platforms corroborate it.

Exit mobile version