Fact Checks

False: the image doesn’t show the weapons discovered at Abune Abraham’s house.

On Feb 5, 2023, a Twitter account posted three images claiming illegal rifles and ammunition were discovered in the house of Abune Abraham, Archbishop of Bahir Dar and head of the Patriarchate Office. The post claimed that five Kalashnikov rifles with 235 bullets were retrieved during a police search.

The Twitter post was shared close to one hundred times and was viewed by more than twenty thousand users on the platform.

However, HaqCheck looked into the images and confirmed that they don’t support the claim. Thus, the post was rendered False.

On Jan 22, 2023, former archbishops of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church appointed bishops without the recognition of the synod of the church.

Abune Sawiros,  Archbishop of South West Shoa, and two others ordained 26 episcopates in Oromia and southern parts of the country. Seventy bishops nominated by Abune Sawiros have been assigned to dioceses in the Oromia regional state.

The breakaway bishops led by Abune Sawiros announced they established the ‘Synod of Oromia and Ethiopian Nations and Nationalities’.

The Ethiopian Orthodox Church’s Synod immediately convened about the issue and denounced the bishops who participated in the appointment of the breakaway episcopate. The synod excommunicated Abune Sawiros and other bishops for ‘violating the church’s canonical orders’.

A few days later, the breakaway archbishops responded by condemning and excommunicating twelve Ethiopian Orthodox Church archbishops.

Abune Abraham, Archbishop of Bahr Dar diocese and head of the Patriarchate Office of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church was among the bishops counter-excommunicated by the breakaway episcopates.

It was in this context a Twitter post emerged on Feb 5, 2023, sharing three images supporting a claim that illegal weapons and ammunition were found at the house of Abune Abraham, Archbishop of Bahir Dar diocese and head of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Orthodox Church Patriarchate Office. The post stated that five Kalashnikov rifles with 235 bullets were discovered.

However, HaqCheck looked into the images and confirmed that the pictures were old and don’t support the claim.

The first image was published on a website that advertises luxury hotels in Addis Ababa. The website claims that the image is of a hotel in Bole named Sheger Royal.

The second picture was previously published by a news site on Sep 30, 2020, in a report that India signed a deal with Russia to procure 770,000 Kalashnikov rifles.

The third image is a picture of Abune Abraham.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post as False.

False: The image does not show weapons found inside the premises of an Orthodox church in Shashemene

A Facebook page with over 39,000 followers shared an image with a short caption, “these [weapons] were found inside the premises of an Orthodox Church in Shashemene”. By the time this article was published, the post was shared thirteen times.

However, HaqCheck inspected the image and confirmed it was old. Therefore, the post was rendered False.

On Jan 22, 2023, former archbishops of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church appointed bishops without the recognition of the synod of the church.

Abune Sawiros,  Archbishop of South West Shoa, and two others ordained 26 bishops to various episcopates in Oromia and southern parts of the country.

The Ethiopian Orthodox Church’s Synod immediately convened about the issue and denounced the bishops who participated in the appointment of the breakaway episcopate. The synod excommunicated Abune Sawiros and other bishops for ‘violating the church’s canonical orders’.

The breakaway archbishops announced that the bishops appointed by Abune Sawiros would travel to their respective episcopates. Social media reports indicated that some of these bishops were welcomed by residents in Oromia.

The leader of the breakaway bishops, Abune Sawiros, appointed Abune Pawlos to the West Arsi diocese in Shashemene town. Tension and clashes erupted during the trip of the newly appointed bishop to Shashemene.

According to news reports, three people were killed in the town of Shashemene after a clash broke out between the supporters of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church Synod and the schismatic bishops.

It was in this context a Facebook post emerged sharing an image with a claim that weapons were found inside the premises of an Orthodox Tewahido church in Shashemene.

HaqCheck used a google reverse image to search if the image was previously published on the platform.

As a result, HaqCheck discovered that the picture was old and published two years ago. The image was previously shared on Facebook on Mar 15, 2021. The original image was shared with a description that the Ethiopian Federal Police seized weapons and ammunition in the Sidama regional state.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post False.

False: The image doesn’t show a church destroyed in Tigray during the armed conflict

A Facebook post emerged on Feb 6, 2023, sharing an image with a claim that the picture shows a church destroyed in Tigray during the armed conflict between the Ethiopian government and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF). The post alleges that the Ethiopian and Eritrean Orthodox Tewahdo churches were collaborators when churches were destroyed in Tigray during the war.

However, the image was very old and doesn’t prove the claim that it shows a church destroyed in Tigray during the recent war. HaqCheck rated the claim as False.

War broke out on Nov 3, 2020, between the Ethiopian government and the TPLF forces after the latter attacked Ethiopian military bases in Tigray.

On Nov 17, 2020, Ethiopian state-affiliated media outlets (EBC, Ethiopian News Agency) reported that the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church expressed its support for the Ethiopian armed forces.

News reports indicate that churches were damaged in Tigray regional state during the armed conflict.

Amid the war, Orthodox Tewahido clergies in the Tigray regional state announced last year that they cut ties with the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church.

On Jan 22, 2023, Abune Sawiros, Archbishop of South West Shoa, along with two others appointed 26 bishops without the recognition of the Holy Synod of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church. The breakaway clergy announced that seventy bishops would be dispatched to churches in the Oromia regional state.

The Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church denounced and excommunicated Abune Sawiros and other bishops who co-organized the appointment.

A few days later, the breakaway archbishops denounced and excommunicated twelve archbishops of the Ethiopian Orthodox Church.

The split stirred up tensions in various parts of the country. VOA reported that conflict erupted in Shashemene town at a church and three people were killed.

The Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church called upon its members to wear black for three days to protest against the breakaway group and alleged government involvement in the issue.

Against this backdrop, a Facebook post shared an image on Feb 6, 2023, claiming that the picture shows a church destroyed in Tigray during the war between the Ethiopian government and TPLF forces. The Facebook account has over twenty thousand followers and the post can reach many audiences.

However, the image was old and doesn’t support the claim that it shows a church destroyed in Tigray during the recent war.

The image shows a church in the town of Adi Keyh, Eritrea, destroyed during the war between Ethiopia and Eritrea. The picture was taken from a video published by Reuters in April 1999.

Later on, the post was edited and the image was replaced with three pictures. HaqCheck could not confirm whether the later three images prove the claim or not.Therefore, the post was rated False.

February 2023: Week one disinformation summary

Eritrean troops are still in Tigray

The peace agreement between the Ethiopian government and the TPLF in November 2022 concluded the war that broke out exactly two years ago.

The Eritrea Defence Forces, Amhara regional militia, and other armed forces had been involved in the war alongside the federal government of Ethiopia against TPLF forces.

The peace agreement signed in Pretoria, South Africa asserts that TPLF forces shall surrender their weapons and foreign and non-ENDF armed forces to leave the regional state of Tigray.

The Ethiopian government and the TPLF agreed that the disarmament of heavy weapons of the TPLF should be done concurrently with the withdrawal of Eritrean and non-ENDF forces from the Tigray.

Recent news reports indicate that Eritrean soldiers started withdrawing from Tigray last month. They left the towns of Aksum, Adwa, and Shire. Additionally, Amhara regional armed forces also reportedly left Shire town.

Yet, it is still unknown whether the non-ENDF and Eritrean troops have fully withdrawn from the Tigray regional state.

Against this backdrop, a Facebook post emerged on Feb 3, 2023, sharing an image with a claim that Eritrean soldiers had not fully withdrawn and were still in northeastern parts of Tigray.

Yet, the image was old and taken from a publication made in May 2021. The picture was first published along with a news story by CNN.

Therefore, HaqCheck rendered the post False.

Celebration over the appointment of new bishops in Oromia

On Jan 22, 2023, Abune Sawiros, Archbishop of South West Shoa, along with two archbishops appointed 26 bishops without the recognition of the Holy Synod of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church. Seventy of the bishops appointed by Abune Sawiros were announced to be dispatched to churches in the Oromia regional state.

Following this appointment, the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church denounced the act. The Church also excommunicated Abune Sawiros and other bishops who co-organized the appointment.

A few days later, the breakaway archbishops announced that nominee bishops would soon be dispatched to various parishes in Oromia.

Social media reports indicate that the newly appointed bishops were sent to their respective domains and were warmly received by residents.

In this context, the Facebook page followed by over two million accounts shared three images on Jan 27, 2023, claiming that residents of many towns in the Oromia region were celebrating the appointment of new bishops.

The images, however, do not support the claim. The first two images in the post were taken from a YouTube video published in February 2020.

The third picture depicts Abune Sawiros who appointed the new bishops. The image was recently posted on Facebook.

Recommendations

Social media users are recommended to be skeptical of potentially misleading and fraudulent posts. They should look for additional information before reacting.

HaqCheck urges public offices and other institutions to offer sufficient and timely updates regarding ongoing issues that are of public interest.

The government should secure the right of citizens and the media to access information.

We recommend social media content creators be responsible and avoid circulating false and misleading information.

False: The image doesn’t prove the presence of Eritrean soldiers in Tigray.

On Feb 3, 2023, a Facebook page posted an image claiming that Eritrean troops were still in the northeastern parts of the Tigray regional state. The post also said that Eritrean soldiers detained workers of international organizations.

The Facebook page has over a hundred thousand followers and the post was shared twenty-five times.

However, HaqCheck checked the image and proved that the image was old and doesn’t support the claim that Eritrean soldiers were still in Tigray.

War broke out between the Ethiopian government and Tigray Liberation Front (TPLF) on Nov 3, 2020, following months of tension.

The Eritrea Defence Forces, Amhara regional militia, and other armed forces were involved in the war alongside the federal government of Ethiopia against TPLF forces.

The belligerents signed a peace agreement in November 2022 to end the two years war. The peace agreement concluded in Pretoria asserts that TPLF forces shall surrender their weapons and foreign and non-ENDF armed forces to leave the regional state of Tigray.

The Ethiopian government and the TPLF agreed that the disarmament of heavy weapons of the TPLF should be done concurrently with the withdrawal of Eritrean and non-ENDF forces from the Tigray.

News reports indicate that Eritrean soldiers started withdrawing from Tigray last month. They left the towns of Aksum, Adwa, and Shire. Additionally, Amhara regional armed forces also reportedly left Shire town.

Yet, it is still unknown whether the non-ENDF and Eritrean troops have fully withdrawn from the Tigray regional state.

In this background, a Facebook post emerged on Feb 3, 2023, sharing an image  with a claim that Eritrean soldiers had not fully withdrawn and were still in northeastern parts of Tigray.

However, HaqCheck cross-checked the claim and confirmed that the image doesn’t support the claim. The image was taken from an old  publication made in May 2021. It was first published along with a news story by CNN.

Therefore, HaqCheck rendered the post False.

Partly False: The images don’t show people celebrating the appointment and dispatching of new bishops in Oromia

On Jan 27, 2023, a Facebook page, followed by more than two million accounts, shared three images claiming that the residents in many towns in the Oromia region were celebrating the appointment of new bishops.

The Facebook post went viral and gained close to twenty thousand engagements on the platform.

However, HaqCheck inquired about the post and confirmed that two of the three images were old. The two pictures don’t support the claim. As a result, the post was rated Partially False.

On Jan 22, 2023, Abune Sawiros, Archbishop of South West Shoa, along with two archbishops appointed 26 bishops without the recognition of the Holy Synod of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church. Seventy of the bishops appointed by Abune Sawiros were announced to be dispatched to churches in the Oromia regional state.

Following this appointment, the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church denounced the act. The Church also excommunicated Abune Sawiros and other bishops who co-organized the appointment.

A few days later, the breakaway archbishops denounced and excommunicated twelve archbishops of the Ethiopian Orthodox Church. They also announced that nominee bishops would soon be dispatched.

Social media reports indicate that the newly appointed bishops were sent to their respective domains and were warmly received by residents.

It is in this context, the Facebook post emerged on Jan 27, 2023, sharing three images with the claim that the residents in many towns in the Oromia region were celebrating the appointment of new bishops.

The images, however, do not support the claim. The first two images in the post were taken from a YouTube video published in February 2020.

The third picture depicts Abune Sawiros who appointed the new bishops. The image was recently posted on Facebook.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post as False due to the usage of inaccurate images.

January week four disinformation summary

Almost all the social media false claims debunked by HaqCheck last week were related to an ongoing conflict in the Oromo Special and North Shewa zones of the Amhara regional state.

The Ethiopian social media landscape is always dominated by posts related to ongoing incidents. Media reports indicate that there was an ongoing conflict in the North Shewa and the Oromo Special zones of the Amhara regional state.

Thus, the claims and controversies during the week were mostly related to the looming conflict in the areas of the two zones which are characterized by ethnic and religious diversity.

HaqCheck did three fact-checking articles last week. A summary of the issues is presented below.

A video of torched Oromo houses

On Jan 23, 2023, a video was shared by a Facebook page with more than six thousand followers claiming that houses belonging to ethnic Oromos were torched in an ongoing conflict in the Oromo Special Zone of the Amhara region.

The claim emerged amid surfacing social media reports that there was an ongoing conflict in areas of the two volatile zones. The post claimed that the video shows Oromo houses being burnt in an ongoing conflict in the Amhara region.

The video, however, does not support the claim. The video was made up of images by converting a picture into a moving image or video.

The original image was taken from an old publication made on Dec 23, 2020. The original image was published along with a report that many civilians were massacred in the Metekel zone of Benishangul Gumuz.

Therefore, the post was rated False.

A false image of a recent conflict in Ataye town, Amhara region

An image was shared on Facebook with a claim that the picture shows an ongoing violent conflict in the town of Ataye, Amhara regional state. The image was posted along with two others on Facebook on Jan 24, 2023, by a page that has over five thousand followers.

The same image was also shared in another Facebook post with the same claim that it shows an ongoing conflict in Ataye.

The posts by the Facebook pages with over five thousand followers each are expected to reach many audiences.

Yet, HaqCheck confirmed that the image was old and doesn’t show an ongoing conflict in the area. However, HaqCheck investigated the claim and confirmed that the image was old.

The original picture was first published on Facebook in April 2019 with a caption that the image shows a church destroyed by fire in the town of Ataye at that time.

Therefore, the claim was rated False.

OLA militants attacked police officers in Jewha, Amhara regional state

Oromo Liberation Army militants opened a sudden attack on a camp and killed more than 20 police officers during an ongoing conflict in Jewha town, Amhara regional state, claimed a Facebook post made on Jan 22, 2023. The claim was backed with an image.

The claim was made in the context of the ongoing conflict in the area. However, HaqCheck investigated the image and confirmed that the image used to support the claim was old.

The image was originally published on a website on  March 20, 2021, along with a short news story.

Thus, HaqCheck rated the post as False.

Recommendations

HaqCheck urges social media content creators and influencers to be responsible and avoid disseminating false information.

We recommend social media users be cautious and look for additional sources for misleading and controversial claims.

The government and public offices are recommended to provide updates and sufficient information about ongoing public matters.

Annual Report 2022: War and Disinformation

The disinformation trend intensified whenever the conflict intensified. The Ethiopian social media landscape was highly dominated by false and misleading claims related solely to the armed conflict between the federal government and the TPLF. Due to the war, other issues such as conflict and violence in other parts of the country, or controversies related to issues other than conflict gained little attention.

The disinformation trend had been prompted by the war. Many false claims appeared when there was ongoing fighting or standoff.
Organized campaigns were made on social media by supporters and sympathizers of the belligerents. These organized social media campaigns, often employing copy and paste and tagging tactics had a significant effect in unleashing false claims and controversies.

Read the whole report here

False: the image doesn’t show OLA militants assaulting police officers in a recent conflict in Amhara regional state

On Jan 22, 2023, a Facebook page with close to one hundred thousand followers posted an image claiming that Oromo Liberation Army militants opened a sudden attack on a camp and killed more than 20 police officers during an ongoing conflict in Jewha town, Amhara regional state.

The post was viral and was shared close to forty times on Facebook.

However, HaqCheck investigated the image and confirmed that the image used to support the claim is old. Therefore, the post was rated False.

Ethiopia has been experiencing recurrent conflict, particularly in recent years. The armed conflict between the Ethiopian government and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) was settled in a peace agreement signed at the beginning of November last year.

The Ethiopian government has been fighting insurgency with the Oromo Liberation Army, which is addressed by the government as Shene.

Mass killings and displacement occurred amid the insurgency. The belligerents have been accusing each other of targeting civilians.

There have been intercommunal conflicts and violence in Oromia and Amhara regions. The Wollega zones in Oromia and the North Shewa and Oromo Special zones in Amhara were rage by recurrent conflicts.

Conflict broke out in the Oromo Special Zone in October 2019 in which three people were killed.

In March and April 2021, over three hundred thousand people were displaced in a conflict in the troubled zone. A year later, violence ensued and more than a dozen people were reported killed.

Social media and news reports this week indicate that conflict erupted in the North Shewa and Oromo Special zones and in the towns of Ataye and Jewha in particular.

Against this backdrop, a Facebook post emerged claiming that Oromo Liberation Army militants launched a sudden attack on a camp and killed more than 20 police officers during an ongoing conflict in the town of Jewha, Amhara regional state.

However, HaqCheck investigated the image and confirmed that the image used to support the claim was old. The picture doesn’t prove the claim.

The image was originally published on a website on  March 20, 2021, along with a short news story.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post False due to its usage of an inaccurate image.

False: The video doesn’t show Oromo houses torched in a recent conflict in Wollo

On Jan 23, 2023, a Facebook page, followed by more than six thousand users shared a video claiming that houses belonging to ethnic Oromos were torched in an ongoing conflict in the Oromo Special Zone of the Amhara region. The post also claimed that armed militias were killing Oromos and looting houses.

The Facebook post went viral and got many reactions on the platform. 

HaqCheck, however, found out that the image was old and does not support the claim. Therefore, the post was rated False.

Intercommunal conflicts have been recurrently occurring in the Oromo Special zone and the adjacent North Shewa zone in the Amhara regional state.

Recently, social media reports indicate that there was an ongoing conflict in areas of the two volatile zones.

On Jan 24, 2023, the Oromo Liberation Front (OLF) released a statement stating that there was a coordinated attack by Amhara regional authorities against ethnic Oromos in the Oromo Special zone.

The statement claimed that regional security forces and militias assaulted civilians on Jan 21, 2023, torched houses, and looted properties.

The OLF stated that more than 65 civilians were killed during the ongoing conflict.

It is in this context a Facebook post emerged on Jan 24, 2023, sharing a video that shows torched houses. The post claimed that the video shows Oromo houses being burnt in an ongoing conflict in the Amhara region.

The video, however, does not support the claim. The video was made up of images by converting a picture into a moving image or video.

The image that was used to fabricate the video was taken from an old publication made on Dec 23, 2020.

The original image was published along with a report that many civilians were massacred in the Metekel zone of Benishangul Gumuz.

Therefore, the post was rated False.

Exit mobile version