Does Ethiopia own the “Picture-Perfect” apples the prime minister shared on social media?

Updated!

Ethiopia is known worldwide for its farming and agricultural products. For centuries, it has grown crops like coffee and teff, feeding its population and exporting different agricultural products to other countries. Apple cultivation in Ethiopia dates back to the 1950s when missionaries brought apple seedlings to Chencha town in southern Ethiopia, establishing them in the Kale-Hiwot Church garden. Ethiopia imported 1,328 tons of apple fruit valued at 1,776,000 US dollar in 2016 and the import grows by 27% yearly.

Different studies show the performance of the apple fruit value chain produced in Chencha district and identified constraints along the chain. Despite the potential, apple production in Ethiopia faces challenges like land fragmentation, input shortages, and knowledge gaps in harvesting. However, apple production has positively contributed to farmers’ livelihoods, with improved livelihood assets ownership.

On Mar 10, 2025, Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed shared a post on his X account about the progress of the country’s apple production.

However, we cross checked the images and proved that the images are not from Ethiopia, and rendered the Prime Minister’s post false.


Screenshot shows a post shared by the Prime Minister on Mar 10, 2025

Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed has implemented several initiatives aimed at enhancing agricultural production and ensuring food security in the country. One of the key initiatives is the Homegrown Economic Reform, which seeks to diversify the economy, including the agricultural sector, by promoting private sector involvement and improving productivity.

Additionally, there has been a focus on digital agriculture, with investments in technologies that provide farmers with real time information on weather, market prices, and best practices, thereby enhancing decision-making.

On Nov 5, 2024 Prime minister Abiy Ahmed remarked at the World Without Hunger Conference that climate change, natural disasters, covid19 pandemic, and conflicts affected the global efforts to achieve Zero Hunger, adding that these challenges have only underscored the urgent need to redouble efforts towards food security.”

The Prime Minister also underscored that countries must adopt sustainable practices, advance modern farming, expand access to essential agriculture inputs and address climate change to enhance productivity.

Whilst the Prime Minister’s emphasis on sustainability and agricultural innovation shows an optimistic vision, the methods and resources selected to promote these priorities have also been questioned. For example, while investigating the imagery related to his latest policy assertions on social media, we found issues.

We at HaqCheck investigated images that were used by the prime minister in his latest post on X account. We found the first image shared nine years ago on pixabay as a stock image that was published on Mar 29, 2015.


Screenshot shows the first image shared 9 years ago on pixabay

We also found the second image shared on September 13, 2013 on a website called Sripoku.com where it was shared in Indonesian language where it was focused to explain the use of eating apples for skin health.


Screenshot shows the other image shared on Sep 13, 2013

The third image was also found previously shared on a Facebook page named India Glorious Nursery on Dec 22, 2024 where it advertised as a supplier of all kinds of fruit plants, roadside plants, hilly area and flower plants. The phone number on the Facebook post refers to a Nursery and cultivation provider in  Kolkata,West Bengal, india.


Screenshot shows a post shared on Dec 22, 2024 on another Facebook page

We are also able to detect the last image on a website called Pomona fruits where they offer high-quality, UK-grown plants and provide a personal service backed by years of experience.


Screenshot shows the image previously shared on a website called Pomona fruits

What could be the intention?

A prime minister’s claim using false image might be used to boost public morale by projecting agricultural success amid economic hardships, attract foreign investment by portraying Ethiopia as a competitive agro exporter, or reinforce political narratives of progress ahead of elections or diplomatic engagements.

The post also might reflect oversight using aspirational imagery without verifying authenticity, which hardly misleads its citizen and the wider public. 

By the time this article was published, we had contacted the Office of the Prime Minister-Ethiopia for clarification for the image claim made by the Prime Minister but had not received a response. However, we assured our readers that we would provide an update once we had received a response from the office.

The day after the post was shared, the Office of the Prime Minister-Ethiopia admitted that some of the images were taken from the wrong source. The office acknowledged the public for pointing out the mistake, and the post was eventually taken down. They promised that steps are being taken to avoid other instances of the same issues.

Conclusion

Even Though Ethiopia produces apples in the country, the images used by the Prime minister are proved to be wrong. Therefore HaqCheck inspected and rendered the images as false.

Exit mobile version