From US Embassy opening a consular office in Mekelle to people killed in mine collapse: Weekly summary

US Embassy opening a consular office in Mekelle

The claim that the US embassy in Addis Ababa opened a consular office in Mekelle, Tigray was one of the major topics of social media controversies over the week.

Wazema Radio reported that the American Embassy in Addis Ababa opened a consular office in Mekelle.

Thereafter, counterclaims came saying that the information was false. Sheger FM, a local radio channel reported that the American Embassy denied the information that it opened a consular office in Mekelle.

HaqCheck asked the US embassy in Addis Ababa regarding the issue. The Embassy’s spokesperson told HaqCheck that the claims regarding the opening of a consular office in Mekelle, Tigray are all false.

Eritrean soldiers recently killed in Tigray

A Facebook post shared an image on Feb 19, 2022, claiming that thousands of Eritrean soldiers were recently killed in Tigray. The Facebook post published by the page, which has over 54 thousand followers, was shared more than 169 times at the time.

The post shared an image with the claim that Eritrean troops were recently killed in Tigray after they tried to invade the regional state.

However, the image was taken and cropped from an old post on the Internet. The original image was published on June 13, 2019, along with an article written on the Eritrean Martyrs’ Day, annually commemorated on June 20.

Cropped image

Original image

HaqCheck fact-checked the claim and confirmed that the image below doesn’t show the Eritrean troops recently killed in Tigray. Therefore, it is confirmed that the image used to support the claim is old and rated the post FALSE.

People killed due to mine collapse

One of the claims HaqCheck fact-checked last week was a claim that seven people were killed by a mine collapse. Africanews.com, a news website on Feb 23, 2022, shared a news report titled, “Seven killed in Ethiopia mine collapse.”

According to Africanews’ news report, the incident occurred as the artisanal gold miners were caught up by the incident and buried underground while they were searching for gold.

However, HaqCheck inspected the image and proved that the image doesn’t prove a mine collapse incident in Ethiopia. The picture was first found on Dec 28, 2021, on different news websites with a title, “More than 30 killed in Sudan gold mine collapse.” At least 31 miners were killed and eight missing in Sudan, according to the reports in the different websites. 

The Associated Press reported the incident that a rudimentary gold mine collapsed and the country’s state-run mining company said, “workers and villagers were searching the Darsaya mine for more bodies and possible survivors” On Dec 29, 2021. The mine is located in the Fuja village, around 700 kilometers south of the capital of Khartoum.

The News report also used two of its tweets from last year. Both of them are about a mine collapse that happened in Niger and Sudan respectively.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the picture used to support the claim False. Additionally, there is no official news about the mine collapse incident so far.

Recommendations

We recommend local and international media outlets to be responsible during reporting and make holistic analysis regarding any matter at hand. They should give suffising information to the audience.

Social media users are urged to cross-check information, images, videos, or claims before they share them with their fellows. They should be able to question the credibility of the information they see before they take it for granted. 

HaqCheck always recommends that social media influencers and content creators be responsible for their activities on their platforms. We urge them to refrain from intentionally or unintentionally creating and circulating false information.

False: The image doesn’t show Eritrean soldiers recently killed in Tigray

An image shared in a Facebook post on Feb 19, 2022, claimed that thousands of Eritrean soldiers were recently killed in Tigray. The Facebook post published by a page that has over 54 thousand followers was shared more than 169 times by the time this article was published. 

However, HaqCheck fact-checked the claim and confirmed that the image below doesn’t show Eritrean troops recently killed in Tigray. 

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post FALSE.

There is an armed conflict between the Ethiopian federal government and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF), an armed resistance front turned ruling party.

Months ago, there were battles between these forces in the neighboring Afar and Amhara regional states. The TPLF-led armed forces were driven out of the two regional states.

Recently, skirmishes between forces loyal to TPLF and Afar regional armed forces were reported in some districts of the Afar region.

There were social media allegations that Eritrean soldiers were backing Afar regional armed forces.

In this context, the post came out sharing an image with the claim that Eritrean troops were recently killed in Tigray after they tried to invade the regional state.

However, the image was taken and cropped from an old post on the Internet. The original image was published on Jun 13, 2019, along with an article written on the Eritrean Martyrs’ Day, annually commemorated on June 20.

Cropped image

Original image

Therefore, HaqCheck confirmed that the image used to support the claim is old and rated it FALSE.

False: The image doesn’t show people who died due to the collapse of an illegal mine.

Africanews.com, a news and media website on Feb 23, 2022, shared a news article titled, “Seven killed in Ethiopia mine collapse.” By the time this article was published the news was shared four times on Africa News’ Facebook page.

However, HaqCheck inspected the image and proved that the image doesn’t prove a mine collapse incident in Ethiopia.

Therefore HaqCheck rendered the post False. 

 

Even though the oil and gas sector is still at the exploration phase, Ethiopia Has a rich deposit of Coal, Tantalum, iron, Nickel, Manganese, Potash, and Phosphate.

The Ministry of Mines and Petroleum announced that in the 2020/2021 fiscal year, Ethiopia has secured 682 million US Dollars from the mineral and gemstone mining sectors.

State Minister of  Ministry of Mines and Petroleum, Simegn Wube stated that the revenue is earned from the supply of over 9,384 Kg of gold to the National Bank of Ethiopia and mining of gemstones including Tantalum and Opal.

 

According to the Africanews’ news report, the incident occurred as the artisanal gold miners were caught up by the incident and buried underground while they were searching for gold.

In the course of HaqCheck’s investigation, the image was first found on Dec 28, 2021, on different news websites with a title, “More than 30 killed in Sudan gold mine collapse.” 

According to the reports in the different websites, at least 31 miners were killed and eight missing in Sudan. 

The Associated Press reported the incident that a rudimentary gold mine collapsed and the country’s state-run mining company said, “workers and villagers were searching the Darsaya mine for more bodies and possible survivors” On Dec 29, 2021. The mine is located in the Fuja village, around 700 kilometers south of the capital of Khartoum.

The News report also used two of its tweets from last year. Both of them are about a mine collapse that happened in Niger and Sudan respectively.

Until this article is published there is no official news about the mine collapse incident. Therefore, HaqCheck inspected the image used as a reference to the news report and rendered it False. 

False: The pictures don’t show recent TPLF POWs in Afar Region

A Facebook page with more than 60,000 followers posted four images claiming to show TPLF POWs captured recently in the war between the Afar region and TPLF. It stated that they were captured in a fight trying to control Serdo, a place in Afar. 

But, HaqCheck looked into the pictures that are used to support the claim and rated them False.

It has been more than a year since a war between The Federal government of Ethiopia and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front( TPLF) broke out. Following the departure of the Federal government from Mekelle, TPLF started to advance southwards to the neighboring Afar and Amhara regions.

A fresh counteroffensive led by PM Abiy Ahmed from the frontlines was launched and freed areas that were under TPLF’s control. Marking the end of the operation led by the Prime Minister,  the government announced that its forces won’t advance further to Tigray and will be positioned at the borders.

However, TPLF accused the federal government and its allies of trying to get into the Tigray region. President of the Afar region, Awel Arba also accused TPLF of opening a fresh offensive on Afar. and reports show that fighting between TPLF and Afar region continued. 

In relation to this situation were the images posted on Facebook claiming to show POWs of TPLF in the Afar region.

HaqCheck looked into the images used to support the claim and found out that two of them were posted on Dec 01, 2021, with a claim that they were TPLF POWs captured by the army led by P.M Abiy Ahmed and 3 pictures were posted on Dec 02, 2021, with a claim that they were Tigrayans who were arrested by the federal government. 

Therefore HaqCheck rated it the claim False.

From the looted artifacts to the release of Tamrat Negera: Weekly summary

The week was relatively moderate in terms of disinformation and information disorder in general. We observed some posts of disinformation on social media. Most of the social media was filled with opinions and controversies not supported by any images, videos, or data worth fact-checking.

HaqCheck fact-checked two Facebook posts. Below is a summary of the information disorder during the week.

The release of Tamrat Negera

Last week was the time the state of emergency was lifted by the parliament. Immediately, social media activists and human rights groups began to call for the release of detainees who were detained during and in relation to the state of emergency.

Henceforth, the Ethiopian Human Rights Commission released a statement urging the government to release people detained in relation to the state of emergency.

There was also an online hashtag campaign that demanded the release of Tamrat Negera and others.

Images of the journalist were trending on social media. On Feb 14, 2022, an image was shared on Twitter with a tweet that demanded the release of Tamrat Negera. The caption of the tweet reads, “If the Parliament lifted the state of emergency, I hope Tamrat Negera and others detained in relation to the state of emergency would be released.”

It is in this scenario the claim that Tamrat Negera is released from prison emerged on Facebook on Feb 15, 2022.

The caption of the Facebook post which shared a picture that shows Tamrat Negera and others reads, “We were told by our brother Yonas Weldeyes that Tamrat Negera is released. Extrajudicial detention has to be stopped.”

However, the image used in the post was first published on Facebook on Aug 7, 2021, by the name Tamrat Negera. Moreover, HaqCheck instantly reached out to Tamrat Negera’s family and confirmed that he was not released yet. Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post FALSE.

Looted artifacts from Tigray

There were also claims and many posts regarding alleged looted artifacts amid the war in Tigray.

There were reports that ancient heritages and artifacts appeared for sale on websites including eBay, raising suspicions that they could have been plundered from churches during the conflict in Tigray, according to The Independent, a London-based news outlet. 

eBay removed from its platforms a number of rare Ethiopian items. But still, there are a number of cultural and religious Antiques on its platforms.

Meanwhile, a Facebook page with more than 13 thousand followers shared a post captioned, “looted artifacts from Tigray are being sold like this.” Under the caption is attached a link that leads to a news website called africanews.com.

The website posted a video on Feb 14, 2022, entitled “Tigray conflict: surge in ancient Ethiopian relics for sale.” By the time, the Facebook post had more than 200 reactions and was shared more than 90 times.

However, HaqCheck investigated the video and proved that it doesn’t show looted artifacts presented on e-commerce websites for sale at negligible price.

 

The video on the website claims, the latest victims of the year-long war in Tigray are the country’s rich artifacts, centuries-old manuscripts, scrolls which are offered on websites for a few hundred dollars and experts suspect that they have been plundered during the conflict. 

HaqCheck found out that the video referred to by the Facebook post was first released on a YouTube channel on Nov 23, 2021, having more than 4.5 million subscribers entitled, “13 stolen artifacts returned after 150 years.” The video had over five thousand views. 

Even though there are several claims that different artifacts are looted from Tigray during the war, neither the Facebook post nor the website video does not prove the claim.

Therefore, HaqCheck fact-checked the post and rendered it False.

Recommendations

HaqCheck recommends social media users question the credibility of the information they see before they take it for granted. They should try to cross-check information, images, videos, or claims before they share with their fellows.

Social media influencers and content creators should be responsible for their activities on their platforms. They should avoid, intentionally or unintentionally, creating and circulating false information.

Multinational corporations whose names are subject to such claims should give timely and sufficient information to prevent the dissemination of disinformation from reaching the point it can no longer be regressed.

Does the video show looted artifacts from Tigray?

A Facebook personal blog account with more than 13 thousand followers shared a post captioned, “looted artifacts from Tigray are sold like this.” Under the caption is attached a link that leads to a News website called africanews.com.

The website posted a video on Feb 14, 2022, entitled “Tigray conflict: surge in ancient Ethiopian relics for sale”. By the time this article is published the Facebook post had more than 200 reactions and was shared more than 90 times.

However, HaqCheck investigated the video and proved that it doesn’t show looted artifacts presented on e-commerce websites for sale with a price of a few amount of dollars.

Therefore, HaqCheck rendered the post as False.

The Tigray People Liberation Front (TPLF) and the Federal government of Ethiopia had been in an active war since Nov 2020. During the war, different important and cultural heritages were destroyed. 

The Ethiopian government promised to repair a centuries-old mosque and a nearby church which were damaged during the conflict in the Tigray region. 

Given the impact of the war endangering loss of such heritages, there were claims that Ethiopian ancient heritages and artifacts appeared for sale on websites including eBay, raising suspicions that they could have been plundered from churches during the conflict in Tigray, according to reports of a British online Newspaper The independent. 

E-bay an e-commerce company has removed from its platforms a number of rare Ethiopian items. But still, there are a number of cultural and religious Antiques on its platforms.  

The website video claims, the latest victims of the year-long war in Tigray are the country’s rich artifacts, centuries-old manuscripts, scrolls offered on websites for a few hundred dollars and experts suspect that they have been plundered during the conflict. 

 HaqCheck found out that the video referred to by the Facebook post was first released on a YouTube channel on Nov 23, 2021, having more than 4.5 million subscribers entitled, “13 stolen artifacts returned after 150 years.” By the time this article is published the video had more than 5000 views. The video reports that after a century and a half away, 13 Ethiopian artifacts returned to their home. 

Even though there are several claims that different artifacts are looted from Tigray during the war, neither the Facebook post nor the website video does not prove the claim.

Therefore HaqCheck inspected the post and rendered it False.  

False: Tamrat Negera is not released

A claim appeared on Facebook on Feb 15, 2022 that Tamrat Negera, editor-in-chief of Terara Network, was released from prison. The caption of the Facebook post which shared a picture that shows Tamrat Negera and others reads, “We were told by our brother Yonas Weldeyes that Tamrat Negera is released. Extrajudicial detention has to be stopped.”

Tamrat Negera was arrested on Dec 10, 2021. He was taken from his house and his whereabouts were not disclosed for a week. Later, he appeared at court on Dec 16.

After the arrest, Addis Ababa Police transferred the journalist to Gelan City Police Department in the Oromia Regional State.

His case was finally transferred to the state of emergency so that the detainee wouldn’t need another court appearance schedule.

On Feb 15, 2022 the House of Peoples’ Representatives lifted the state of emergency that was declared in the beginning of November last year.

Henceforth, the Ethiopian Human Rights Commission released a statement and urged the government that people detained in relation to the state of emergency should be released.

It is in this scenario the claim that Tamrat Negera is released from prison emerged.

However, the image used in the post was first published on Facebook on Aug 7, 2021 by the name Tamrat Negera. The image was also recently shared along with a tweet that demands the release of Tamrat Negera on Feb 14. The caption of the tweet made on Feb 14, 2022 reads, “If the Parliament lifted the state of emergency, I hope Tamrat Negera and others detained in relation to the state of emergency would be released.”

Moreover, HaqCheck instantly reached out to Tamrat Negera’s family and confirmed that he was not released yet. 

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post FALSE.

False: The image doesn’t show Tigrayan mothers digging trench

A Facebook account with more than 100,000 followers posted an image on Feb 02 claiming to show Tigrayan mothers (whom it labeled ‘traitors’) digging trenches at a place called Aredo in Afar front in an effort of helping  TPLF war efforts in the Afar regional state. By the time this article was published it had more than one thousand reactions and was shared nearly two hundred times. Other Facebook accounts also posted it with the same claim.

However, HaqCheck looked into the picture used to support the claim and rated it FALSE.

The war between TPLF and the federal government of Ethiopia has been ongoing for more than a year now. After the Ethiopian federal forces left Mekelle, Tigray’s capital, TPLF forces started to advance southward to neighboring Amhara and Afar regions. 

A fresh counteroffensive led by PM Abiy Ahmed from the frontlines was launched and freed areas that were under TPLF’s control. Marking the end of the operation led by the Prime Minister,  the government announced that its forces won’t advance further to Tigray and will be positioned at the borders. 

There had been accusations by the TPLF that there were engagements with forces of  the federal government and its allies on trying to advance into Tigray on different fronts. President of the Afar region, Awel Arba also accused TPLF of opening a fresh offensive on Afar.

The post appeared on facebook in light of this scenario claiming to show that Tigrayan mothers are helping TPLF in digging fortresses.

HaqCheck interrogated the image used to support the claim and found out that it is an old picture posted on Apr 12, 2019 on Facebook with a caption that people in Raya, Tigray Regional State were making terraces for water conservation and soil erosion prevention. 

Therefore HaqCheck rated the claim as FALSE. 

From the controversial letter to weapons captured at Raya front: Weekly summary

The effect of misinformation and disinformation is not limited only to the online milieu and social media platforms. It will also spill over into other parts of our life. The trend of information disorder and disinformation is varying with the course of the conflict in Ethiopia. In the following summary, HaqCheck covers the major disinformation trends observed in the previous week along with important recommendations. 

False and manipulated images

Oromia Liberation Army closing  the road from Addis Ababa to Gojam

On Feb 9, 2022, A Facebook page with more than 150 thousand followers shared an image captioned, “Oromia Liberation Army (OLA) closed the road from Addis Ababa to Gojjam as reported by various Amhara regional media.”

Oromo Liberation Army (OLA), is an ethnic Oromo armed group fighting the Ethiopian government alongside Tigrayan rebels.

In August, the armed group announced that it formed an alliance with the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF), which has been fighting government forces in the north of the country since Nov 2020.

However, the image is found to be False, taken from a previous video on Aug 25, 2021, on a news and media website entitled,f “OLA is committing violence and crime on innocents in Wollega and Gujji zones.”

Even though there are several claims that OLA closed the road from Addis Ababa to Gojam the image used to support the claim is False.

Therefore HaqCheck checked the image and rendered it False. 

weapons captured at Raya front 

A Telegram channel and A Facebook page shared a post on Feb 4, 2022, captioned, “weapons captured from TPLF forces at the Raya front.”

The post had more than 800 reactions and was shared more than 100 times. By the time this article was published the Telegram post had more than 6700 views.

In order to prove the claim HaqCheck made an investigation on the images and spotted the pictures in a news video on Amhara Media Corporations’ YouTube channel published on Feb 2, 2022.

The first image is spotted  in the news video on its 23 minute and 05 seconds

The second image is spotted in the news video on its 22 minutes and 57 seconds

Tigrayan women digging trench to help TPLF

A Facebook account with more than 100,000 followers posted an image on Feb 02, 2022, claiming to show a Tigrayn mother digging a trench to help TPLF attack Afar. By the time this article was published it got more than one thousand reactions and was shared nearly two hundred times.

HaqCheck investigated the post and proved that the image was first posted on Apr 12, 2019, on a Facebook page captioned, “a terrace will not help for the people of Raya, rather removing bad administration (governance).”

Therefore HaqCheck rendered it False.

The letter of Tsega Arage 

A letter circulating on social media claimed to be written by the name of Agenew Teshager was another subject of controversy last week. But, the letter is actually written by Tsega Arage, a member of the prosperity party central committee, to the Prosperity Party Control and Inspection Commission.

Tsega discussed in his letter that “the Rules and regulations were broken in the party.”

Apart from the reality, there was a manipulated image circulating on Facebook. The post used a caption, “Agegnew Teshager has broken his silence” and attached the letter of Tsega Arage to support its assertion.

Since the letter was written by Tsega Arage, HaqCheck proved that the image was manipulated.

Therefore HaqCheck checked the post and rendered it False. 

Recommendation 

Social media influencers and content creators should be responsible for their activities on their platforms. We observe that social media influencers and content creators were sharing false images mixed up with  new pictures. This makes it hard for users to identify the false from the real images which may also undermine the truth on the ground. Thus, they should be responsible and abstain from sharing false and unauthenticated images and information.

As a fact-checking initiative we recommend, everyone should inquire about the authenticity of the information before they read and share it with others. Users should identify and detect trustable, verified page sources to grasp the crux of any issue.

False: the images don’t show weapons captured at Raya front

A Telegram channel with more than a thousand subscribers shared a post on Feb 4, 2022, captioned, “weapons captured from TPLF forces at the Raya front.” By the time this article was published the post had more than 6700 views.

A post with the same caption was also shared on another Facebook page with more than 17 thousand followers. The Facebook post had more than 800 reactions and was shared more than 100 times. However, HaqCheck inspected the images and rendered them False.

The Tigray People Liberation Front (TPLF) and the Federal government of Ethiopia have been in an active war since Nov 2020. 

At the end of June 2021, the Federal government declared a sudden unilateral ceasefire and pulled out its troops from Tigray after a request from the Provisional Interim Government of the region. Thereafter, TPLF forces advanced southward to territories in the Amhara and the Afar Regions. 

After the federal government and regional forces launched a counteroffensive against TPLF, the Tigrayan forces started to retreat back to Tigray. Thereafter, the federal government announced that its armies will not advance deeper into Tigray and will stay on the borders of the Afar and Amhara regions. However, TPLF continued accusing the Amhara and Afar militias of attacking Tigray.

HaqCheck made an investigation on the images and spotted the pictures in a news video on Amhara media corporations’ Youtube channel published on Feb 2, 2022. By the time this article was published the video had more than 150 thousand views.

The first image is spotted  in the news video on its 23 minute and 05 seconds 

 

The second image is spotted in the news video on its 22 minutes and 57 seconds

The news video is headlined,  “In an operation undertaken by the defense forces and the federal police on the terrorist Shene, more than 100 members of it are eliminated”

The video also shows surrendered members of the claimed terrorist group. 

Therefore, HaqCheck inspected the images and rendered the images used to support the claim False.

Exit mobile version