False: the images don’t show weapons recently captured at Raya front

A Facebook page with more than 120 thousand followers shared a post on Sep 3, 2022, captioned “430 Kalashnikov and other weapons were captured at Raya front….”. 

By the time this article was published the post had more than a thousand reactions and was shared more than 150 times.

However, HaqCheck inspected the post and rendered it False.  

The Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) and the federal government of Ethiopia have been in an active war since Nov 2020.

On August 16, 2022, TPLF declared that the federal government had already broken the cease-fire that had been jointly declared at the end of March. The TPLF claimed that the armed forces of the federal government engaged in an artillery barrage and an assault on its positions.

Later, on Aug 24, TPLF alleged that the federal government had attacked its military forces in the southern Tigray provinces.

On the contrary, The federal government declined the claim and states that TPLF provoked the attack. 

On Aug 29, the Ethiopian National Defense Forces said that it is obtaining victory on different fronts.  

The post is produced in the context of this situation.

HaqCheck made an investigation on the images and spotted the pictures in a news video on Amhara Media Corporations’ Youtube channel published on Feb 2, 2022. By the time this article was published the video had more than 150 thousand views. 

One of The images is spotted in the news video at 23:05 minute. 

The other image is spotted in the news video on its 22:57 minute. 

The news video is headlined,  “In an operation undertaken by the defense forces and the federal police on the terrorist Shene, more than 100 members of the group were eliminated”

The video also shows surrendered members of the claimed rebel group.Therefore, HaqCheck inspected the images and rendered the images used to support the claim False.

False: The images do not show a recent rally in Tigray [Adigrat]

A Facebook page with more than 120 thousand followers shared a post on Aug 23, 2022, captioned, “ The people of Tigray in Adigrat held a rally today condemning TPLF….”

By the time this article was published the post had more than a thousand reactions and was shared more than 220 times.

However, HaqCheck inspected the images on the post and rendered them False.

The prolonged war between the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF), the federal government, and its allied forces remained unsolved.

In a news video released on May 10, 2022, TPLF has been stating that if the diplomatic means to end the war fail, it will resort to other means indicating that it will seek military solutions. TPLF has been accusing the federal government and regional authorities of blocking aid from entering Tigray and has complained the aid that has recently reached was below that need.

On Jan 13, 2022, Field Martial Birhanu Jula of the Ethiopian Defense Forces said in an interview, “Tigray people don’t have to die for the sake of TPLF anymore, thousands of lives are lost. People of Tigray have to say no to TPLF.”

The post is then produced in the context of these situations. 

HaqCheck inspected the images shared by the page and found the first image on a Facebook page with more than 22 thousand followers.

The image was shared on Sep 4, 2020, with a description of “Tigray will choose its leaders [Adigrat]. Even if the Ethiopian national election is postponed because of the Covid-19 pandemic the people of Tigray are about to choose their leaders”. The post also attached 3 images.

Link 

In the effort of verifying the images, HaqCheck found the second image on a website called borkena.com in an article shared under the title “Reported clash between students, security forces in Haramaya University.”The article was shared on Jan 9, 2020.

The article stated that the university says “students in the University’s technology institute caused a disturbance around 2:00 o’clock in the afternoon, local time, and went on a vandalism spree. They destroyed two Motorbikes, a coaster van the university uses as a shuttle bus for employees, and an ATM machine belonging to the Commercial Bank of Ethiopia (CBE).” 

Link 

The third image was also previously shared on a Facebook account along with the image used by Borkena [the clash between students of Haramaya university and security forces].

This image was shared on May 19, 2020, captioned, “Public protest in Tigray [Adigrat] against the TPLF administration.” 

Link   

Even though there had been different unconfirmed and False information about public protests of people in Tigray against the TPLF administration at different times. The images used by the page to support the claim [recent rally in Tigray] are False.Therefore HaqCheck inspected the images and rendered them False.

Does the image show a plane shot down by the Ethiopian Air Force?

A Facebook page with more than 11 thousand Followers shared a post on Aug 25, 2022, captioned “The huge military Antonov cargo plane shot down by the Ethiopian Air force.”

By the time this article is published the post had more than 90 reactions and was shared more than 60 times.

However, HaqCheck inspected the image and rendered it False.

The press release by the Tigray Army’s military command on Aug 17, 2022, stated that “on August 15, 2022, the Ethiopian National Defense Force, which claims to have built an impregnable fortress in Western Tigray, bombarded Tigray Army forces around Dedebit for an hour with heavy artilleries and tanks.” 

The spokesperson of TPLF Getachew Reda said that the Federal Government [Abiy’s administration] had opened an attack on the southern front of Tigray, and the Amhara special forces and Fano militias from Wollo also participated in the offensive. He also added that the Tigray defense forces are defending their territory.

Later, on Aug 24, 2022, Major general Tesfaye Ayalew said that the Ethiopian Air Force shot down an Airplane carrying weapons for TPLF. 

It is not mentioned to whom the plane belongs except being referred to as “an airplane believed to be the property of historical enemies which are long been interested and working in weakening of Ethiopia and are supporting the TPLF”.

On the contrary, TPLF denied the claim that the Ethiopian Air Force shot down a plane. 

HaqCheck assessed the image and found it on a website called C-130.net. The image is found in an article written about an Egyptian C-130 plane crash during training. 

Link  

About 100 kilometers (62 miles) south of Cairo, in the Fayoum region, the plane reportedly crashed down in Kawm Awshim.

According to Egyptian news media, Mohamed Sayed Ahmed, Brigadier Amr Abdo Rashwan, Majors Ahmed Ibrahim Muwafi, Ahmad Saeed Ali Mchale, Ahmed Fathi Ahmed Mehanna, and Assistant Mohamed Abdel Hakim Abdullah Zenati, all died in the accident.

Even though the government claimed that an airplane passing across the Ethiopian air space was shot down by the Ethiopian Air force, the image used by the Facebook page is wrong.
Therefore HaqCheck inspected the post and rendered it False.

Does the image show an airplane shot down by the Ethiopian Air Force?

A Twitter account with more than 150 thousand followers shared a post on Aug 24, 2022, captioned “Breaking news! An enemy airplane which was about to cross the Ethiopian airspace  was shot down by the Ethiopian air force.”  

By the time this article is published the post had more than a thousand reactions and was retweeted more than 300 times.

However, HaqCheck inspected the image and rendered it False.

The press release by the Tigray Army’s military command on Aug 17, 2022, stated that “on August 15, 2022, the Ethiopian National Defense Force, which claims to have built an impregnable fortress in Western Tigray, bombarded Tigray Army forces around Dedebit for an hour with heavy artilleries and tanks.” 

The spokesperson of TPLF Getachew Reda said that the Federal Government [Abiy’s administration] had opened an attack on the southern front of Tigray, and the Amhara special forces and Fano militias from Wollo also participated in the offensive. He also added that the Tigray defense forces are defending their territory.

Later, on Aug 24, 2022, Major general Tesfaye Ayalew said that the Ethiopian Air Force shot down an Airplane carrying weapons for TPLF. 

On the contrary, TPLF denied the claim that the Ethiopian Air Force shot down a plane. 

HaqCheck assessed the image and spotted it on a YouTube channel called AERO press BG which has more than two thousand subscribers, captioned, “National Air Cargo’s Boeing 747-400 freighter crash in Afghanistan” on Apr 30, 2013. The video got more than 3 million views.

The video of the incident also appeared on CNN aired on May 2, 2013. It was reported in the news that, “a civilian cargo plane crash killed seven Americans. The moment after taking off from Bagram airbase in Afghanistan six of the Americans on board were from Michigan and one from Kentucky. An American contractor nearby filmed the incident.”

Besides finding the image in the video HaqCheck made a comparison between the video and the image.

 The image on Twitter

Footages detected inside the video

The Twitter post cropped out an image from the video of the cargo crash accident and employed it to accompany its claim. This Twitter account shared an image that was also cropped out from this video on Mar 16, 2022, with a claim that “an Antonov plane was shot down by an Eritrean anti-aircraft.”

Link 

Even though there are claims from the government that the Ethiopian Air force shot down an Airplane intruding into the Ethiopian Airspace, the image used by the Twitter account is wrong.

Therefore, HaqCheck inspected the post and rendered it False.  

Does the image show people suffering from hunger in Ethiopia [Oromia]?

A Twitter account shared a post on Aug 20, 2022, Captioned “The United Nations and other organizations should reach out to the Oromo people suffering from Hunger.”

By the time this article is published the post had more than 13 retweets including a Twitter account with more than 15 thousand followers retweeting the post.

However, HaqCheck inspected the image and rendered the post, Partly-False.  

According to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA’s) Report rainfall deficits during the recent March-April-May 2022 rainy season have been the most severe in at least the last 70 years in Ethiopia, Kenya, and Somalia. The ongoing, four-season drought has been the most extensive and persistent event since 1981. 

The report by The Africa Watch which is now part of (the Human Rights Watch) shows that many historic famines were the result of the way civil wars were waged. Sometimes, food stores were seized to feed huge armies of tens of thousands of soldiers. In other cases, cattle and crops were confiscated as a military strategy. These measures degraded communities, making them vulnerable when drought struck.

The claim is thus produced in the context of the current drought situation in the region.

HaqCheck used a Google reverse image search to prove the correctness of the images used by the Twitter account to support the claim.

One of the images is found shared on different Social media platforms to show the drought in the Oromia West Guji zone. 

Link 

The other image was posted on May 19, 2022, on a Facebook page with more than 57thousand followers. The post claimed the image is from Mekele, Tigray. 

Link 

The third image was also shared on different Social media and websites in different descriptions at different times.

On Apr 4,2017, a Website shared this image on an article wriiten about the Somalian parliament approving the state budget.  

 One of the Facebook post uses the image to show the poverty in Nigeria posted on World poverty day on On Oct 18 2018. 

Link 

Link 

The Fourth image was taken by a South African photojournalist in which he wins the Pulitzer award. The photo shows a starving child who collapsed on the ground and was struggling to get to a food center in Sudan in 1993.

Link 

Even though there are several claims that there is starvation caused by drought in Ethiopia, among the four images used by the Twitter account, three of them don’t show the hunger caused by drought in Ethiopia [Oromia].
Therefore, HaqCheck inspected the post and rendered it  Partly-False.

Does the image show the drought in Ethiopia [Oromia region]?

A Twitter account shared a post on Aug 2, 2022, captioned, “URGENT! HIDDEN #genocide #WeaponizedStarvation in Oromia under Command Post since 2018…” and attached three images. The image was also shared on YouTube and other two Facebook posts. 

However, HaqCheck inspected the images and rendered the post Partly-False.

These three images were also used as a thumbnail of a video on a YouTube channel with more than 900 subscribers titled “Beela Gujii fi Booranaa Itti fufeera | Deeggarsi Dhaabbate | በቦረና ዞን ድርቁ የቀጠለ ቢሆንም የሚላከው ድጋፍ ቆሟል |”. The video was taken from EBC (Ethiopian broadcasting corporation) shared on Jul 6, 2022, titled “the drought in Borena zone requires an immediate response by the Gov’t.”

Link

Link

One of the 20th century’s biggest humanitarian crises was Ethiopia’s famine and hunger crisis in the 1980s, which sparked a global effort to provide food aid and save lives. According to the United Nations, Ethiopia’s food shortages and hunger crises between 1983 and 1985 resulted in an estimated 1 million famine fatalities.  

According to OCHA’s Report Rainfall deficits during the recent March-April-May 2022 rainy season have been the most severe in at least the last 70 years in Ethiopia, Kenya, and Somalia. The ongoing, four-season drought has been the most extensive and persistent event since 1981. 

The report by The Africa Watch which is now part of (the Human Rights Watch) shows that many historic famines were the result of the way civil wars were waged. Sometimes, food stores were seized to feed huge armies of tens of thousands of soldiers. In other cases, cattle and crops were confiscated as a military strategy. These measures degraded communities, making them vulnerable when drought struck.

The claim is produced in the backdrop of the current drought situation in the region.

HaqCheck used a Google reverse image search to prove the correctness of the images  used by the Twitter account to support the claim.

One of the images was shared on different Social media platforms to show the drought in the Oromia West Guji zone. 

Link 

Link 

The other image was found on different social media accounts along with other pictures to show the famine caused by the drought in Ethiopia [oromia].

Link 

But, HaqCheck found out that one of the images used by different social media accounts doesn’t show the drought in Ethiopia [oromia].

HaqCheck found the images posted on Jul 13, 2022, on a website called The Kampala report.com Under the title “Karamoja MPs to Parliament: We do not want any more deaths from starvation.”. 

Even though, there are several claims that there is a famine caused by the drought in Ethiopia’s Somali and Oromia regions, one of the images used by these different accounts is learned to be wrong.
Therefore, HaqCheck inspected the post and rendered it Partly-False.

Does the image show Amhara victims of the massacre in Ethiopia?

A Twitter account with more than 4 thousand followers shared two images with a descriptive text on Jul 26, captioned “Amhara people in Ethiopia every place been targeted by their identity by the genocidal government of Ethiopia.” One of the images is a graphic image of a slaughtered child and the other shows a pile of corpses of massacred people.

However, HaqCheck inspected the image and rendered the post Partly-False.

There have been various reports of ethnically targeted mass killings and massacres in West Oromia [Wollega] at different times.

On June 18, there were different reports that more than 100 people were massacred in Wollega. The government and different reports claimed that the Oromo Liberation Army (OLA)-Shane is behind the mass killings. 

However, the international spokesperson of the OLA, Odda Tarbbi denied the claim that OLA soldiers conducted a massacre in Wollega, but rather that the killings were perpetrated by local militia.

The tweet is thus produced in the context of this situation.

In an effort to examine the image, HaqCheck found one of the images posted on Jul 5, 2022, on different social media platforms. All the posts related to the image reported the ethnic-based massacre in Wollega conducted on Amharas. According to our search, the image first appeared for the first time on this day claimed to picture massacred Amharas.  

Link 

Link  

However, HaqCheck discovered the other image published on Mar 12, 2018, on the website called BIAtimes.org under the headline “Nigeria: Fulani Herdsmen Invade Primary School in Ogun State Killing Children.” 

Link

Fulani herdsmen are believed to be responsible for thousands of death in Nigeria’s Middle Belt, mostly in terror attacks committed against Christian farming communities. But the conflict is complicated: While the Fulani are Muslim, religion is only one aspect of the attacks waged in Nigeria in recent years. Fulani Herdsmen are the fourth most deadly terrorist organization and are responsible for a series of killings in Nigeria, especially against the Christians and the Nigerian Government led by President Buhari has failed to bring them to book.

According to BIAtimes.org Fulani herdsmen invade St.John’s Anglican Primary School Agodo, Ogun State Nigeria, and turned the school into a pool of the blood of innocent, little kids and students. 

Even though there have been reports of massacres conducted on Amharas in Wollega, one of the images doesn’t show the atrocity committed on Amhara people in Ethiopia.
Therefore HaqCheck Analysed the post and rendered it as Partly-False.

Does the academic dress recently worn by Tedros Adhanom represent the Flag of Tigray?

A Facebook page with more than 54 thousand followers shared on July 17 a collection of images featuring the Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Director of the World Health Organization Tedros Adhanom (Ph.D.), Indian movie actor Sha Rukh Khan, and the football legend Pele all wearing a similar academic dress of red gown and yellow velvet hood, captioned with lines of a song from a popular Tigrigna singer that reads, “The Tigrean flag does whatever it wants without bragging”.

The post is published after Tedros Adhanom, Director of WHO, received an Honorary Degree from the University of Edinburgh clad in similar academic dress. Different social media pages have shared an image of different celebrities and influencers wearing red and yellow Gown claiming it to be the Flag of Tigray. 

However, HaqCheck inspected the claim and rendered it False.

On Jul 14, 2022, The University of Edinburgh gave an  Honorary Degree to Tedros Adhanom, the Director of the World Health Organization (WHO) for the significant contribution he has made to raise the profile of nurses and midwives across the globe.

Later on, Dr.Tedros Adhanom forwarded his gratitude on his Twitter account for the honor bestowed on him by the University of Edinburgh. 

The graduation ceremony was held in the graduation hall called McEwan Hall of the University of Edinburgh, in Edinburgh, the capital of Scotland.

Tedros received his honorary degree as part of the graduation ceremony for Nursing Studies students.

Given the fact that Tedros Adhanom was a senior leadership member of the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) and has been observed defending the TPLF in the Tigray war, the color of the academic dress he wore happened to be familiarized to the flag of Tigray. 

The social media posts took the incident supposedly claiming that Tedros chose the gown to honor and remember Tigray. Besides, the posts used images of various politicians and celebrities wearing the same academic dress in a bid to show that these renowned personalities followed Tedros’ lead of honoring Tigray by wearing the same dress. 

A Facebook page with more than 138 thousand followers shared a post on Jul 16, captioned, “Indian Movie Actor Sha Rukh Khan has joined ‘The Tigray Prevails Movement’.”  by the time this article is posted the post had more than 300 reactions. 

Since 1695 the University of Edinburgh has awarded Honorary degrees to over 2,900 individuals.

In 1984 The University of Edinburgh awarded an honorary degree to the former President of Zimbabwe Robert Mugabe for his service to education in Africa. But later He has been blamed for Zimbabwe’s failing economy and accused of running an oppressive regime which later made his degree to be revoked by the university on Jul 16, 2007. 

Flag of Tigray

Honorary degree recipients of the University of Edinburgh wear the scarlet gown with a yellow velvet hood according to the university’s code of gown dressing and has no connection with the Flag of Tigray or any movement. And the referred recipients of the University’s honorary degree, Justin Trudeau, Sha Rukh Khan, and Pele received their degrees on Jul 2017, Oct 2015, and Aug 2012 respectively, which shows they were not part of a claimed Tedros-led pro-Tigray campaign. 

Even if the Honorary Graduates wear a graduation gown with the same color as the flag of Tigray. The claim used by different Social media posts is Wrong.
Therefore HaqCheck interrogated the Claim and rendered it False.

Does the image show a recent victim of the massacre in Ethiopia?

A Facebook page with more than 200 thousand followers shared an image on Jul 14, captioned, “This baby is not the Rwandan Tutsi Immaculée [Immaculée Ilibagiza] … She is the Ethiopian Amhara Immaculée who survived to tell us what really happened. Abiy Ahmed and his group are killing people whom the world saved in the ‘We are the World’ campaign in 1985.” 

The post analogized the pictured girl it claimed is Amhara with the renowned Rwandan Tutsi Immaculée Ilibagiza who related the story of the Rwandan massacre and her journey in her book “Left to Tell”. Immaculée Ilibagiza was spared from the Rwanda genocide hidden in a house of a Hutu pastor who sheltered her and a few other Tutsi girls during the three months massacre. 

By the time this article is published the post had more than 3 thousand reactions and was shared more than 700 times.

However, HaqCheck inspected the image and rendered it False.

There have been different reports of ethnic-based mass killings and massacres in West Oromia [Wollega] at different times.

Recently, On June 18, there were different reports that more than 100 people were massacred in Wollega. Different unofficial social media posts claimed that the number of civilians killed by the armed group [OLA] is far larger than official reports and would reach close to a thousand.

The government and different reports asserted that the Oromo Liberation Army (OLA)-Shane is behind the mass killings. 

However, the international spokesperson of the OLA, Odda Tarbbi denied the claim that OLA soldiers conducted a massacre in Wollega, but rather were perpetrated by local militia.

The other background referred to in the post is the collective initiative of American musicians, We are the World campaign of 1985 aimed at rescuing the victims of the hunger emergency in Ethiopia. The population mainly affected by the hunger crisis were people in the Amhara region, whom the post claimed are being currently killed by the government, the same people who were rescued by the We are the World aid initiative. 

The post is thus produced in the context when ethnic based mass killings, especially targetting the Amhara ethnic group, were rampant. 

HaqCheck inspected the image used by the Facebook page to support the claim. It is realized that the image is from the genocide that happened in Rwanda. HaqCheck found the images in different posts at different times. 

Link 

Link

The Rwandan Genocide is one of the most notorious modern genocides. During this 100-day period between April and July 1994, nearly one million ethnic Tutsi and moderate Hutu were killed as the international community and UN peacekeepers stood by. 

On April 6, 1994, when the President’s plane was shot down, killing both the Rwandan and Burundian presidents, the radical Hutu radio channel announced the deaths, urging Hutus to “go to work” and attack the Tutsi population marking the beggining of the genocide.

Even though there are several claims that different massacres happened in Wollega , Western oromia, the image used by the Facebook page is out of context and doesn’t show an Amhara victim from the mass killings. 
Therefore, HaqCheck has inspected the image and rendered it False.

Does the image show armed Amhara militias launching an assault on Ataye?

A Facebook page with more than 38 thousand followers shared a post on Jul 12, 2022, Captioned “Amhara extremists have turned back to Ataye because their deadliest massacre plan in Wollega has not worked out.”

The Page uses the map of the Amhara region and from the map points to an image claiming to show Amhara militias in Fortress.

However, HaqCheck has inspected the image used to support the claim and rendered it False.

On Jun 18, different posts appeared circulating the report that the Oromo Liberation Army (OLA) massacred Ethnic Amharas who live in west wollega Gimbi 

woreda Tole kebele. Different unofficial social media posts claimed that the number of civilians killed by the armed group is far larger  and reaches close to a thousand.

The international spokesperson of the OLA Odda Tarbbi denied the claim that OLA soldiers conducted a massacre in wollega against the civilians, but rather local militia.

Ataye Google Map View 

On Jul 11, 2022, there were different reports of Gunfire in Ataye town, a place in Northern Shoa. the posts claimed that the members of OLA opened gunfire on Amhara residents of the town.

In this regard, a  video claims  OLA militants were entering Ataye with gunshots heard from afar.  

Later on Jul 12, 2022, different media reported that federal and regional security forces arrived in the area to quell the clashes.

The post was shared in the backdrop of these situations.

HaqCheck tried to inspect the image used to support the claim that Amhara armed militias opened an attack on Ataye. It is found out that the image was published on May 12, 2015, on a website called intriguing history.com under the title “New Data Register of the Anglo Boer War 1899-1902”.

The South African War, sometimes called the Boer War or Anglo-Boer War was the first major conflict of a century that was to be marked by wars on an international scale. The war began on October 11, 1899, following a Boer ultimatum that the British should cease building up their forces in the region.

The Boers had refused to grant political rights to non-Boer settlers, known as Uitlanders, most of whom were British, or to grant civil rights to Africans.

But later the two belligerents had a meeting In Pretoria, when representatives of Great Britain and the Boer states signed the Treaty of Vereeniging, officially ending the three-and-a-half-year South African Boer War.

Even though there are several claims of recent skirmishes in Ataye town, the image used by the Facebook page to support the claim is wrong.
Therefore HaqCheck has inspected the image and rendered it False.

Exit mobile version