False: the image doesn’t show weapons seized by Afar militia at Berhale front

A Telegram channel with more than a thousand subscribers shared an image on Jan 31, 2022, captioned, “weapons captured by Afar militia at Berhale front.” By the time this article was published the post had 12,000 views and was shared with other Telegram groups having more than 46 thousand subscribers. 

However, HaqCheck inspected the image and rendered it False.

Tigray People Liberation Front (TPLF) forces and the Federal Government of Ethiopia have been in an active war in northern Ethiopia since November 2020.

At the end of June 2021, the Federal Government declared a sudden unilateral ceasefire and pulled out its troops from Tigray after a request from the Provisional Interim Government of the region. Thereafter, TPLF forces advanced southward to territories in the Amhara and the Afar Regions. 

Until Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed officially announced to join the army at the battlefront, TPLF was nearing the town of Debre Sina which is 183km away from the capital.

After the federal government and regional forces launched a counteroffensive against TPLF, the Tigrayan forces started to retreat back to Tigray. Thereafter, the federal government announced that its armies will not advance deeper into Tigray and will stay on the borders of the Afar and Amhara regions. However, TPLF continued accusing the Amhara and Afar militias of attacking Tigray.

On Jan 24 Afar Regional State Communication Affairs Office notified on its Facebook page that The TPLF had intensified its offensive in Ab’ala and Magale woredas of the Kilbati Rasu zone in the Afar region to compensate for its heavy defeat in the Afar region.

The Telegram post appeared in the middle of this contextual situation. 

HaqCheck used a Google reverse image search to prove the post’s claim. It is learned that the image was first posted on a website called (ጎልጉል)Goolgule, An internet newspaper, on Sep 05, 2021, in an article titled, “Illegal weapons confiscated in the month of August.” 

     

Even though there are several claims that there is a clash at the border of the Afar region, the image doesn’t show weapons captured by the Afar militia at the Berhale front. 

HaqCheck looked into the image that is used to support the claim and rendered it False. 

From Reuters’ misleading report to false images of the war: Weekly summary

False images of Somali and Oromia drought 

A new trend of misinformation is emerging on social media. The trend is sharing old and false images mingled with new images. Recently, there had been false images circulating on social media claiming that they show the ongoing drought in Somali and Oromia Regional States.

There have been many reports that the regional states of Oromia and Somalia are hit by severe drought. Addis Standard recently reported that many woredas in East Showa and Hararghe Zones of Oromia were affected by drought. Furthermore, 6,398 children, 9,078 women, and 2,226 elderly people have faced severe health problems associated with malnutrition due to a drought in the Borana zone of Oromia regional state.  The drought killed 7,540 cattle and some 13,641 cattle are moving around with the assistance of humans because the drought has weakened them. Many people and cattle have also suffered from drought in the Bale zone, Oromia.

Reports regarding the severe drought in the Somali region have also been coming out. According to a report, the drought which affected many woredas has killed thousands of livestock.

Despite the facts,, many old and false images were tracked circulating on social media platforms with claims of the ongoing drought in Oromia and Somali Regional  States.

Here are some of the posts that shared old images claiming to show the drought in Somali and Oromia Regional States.

A link to the original image.

The above post shared an old image claiming that a drought in the Bale Zone of Oromia is looming and people are starving due to the emerging drought. But the image is taken from a report published in 2018.

A link to the original image.

This post claimed that drought has occurred in Oromia and Somali regions. However, the first picture of the four images in the post is old and was taken from a report regarding drought in Somalia and Kenya.

A link to the original image.

This  Facebook post also claimed that drought occurred in the Somali regional state. It shared three images in support of the claim. But, the first image was taken and cropped from an image in a report published in 2019.

Reuters’ misleading state of emergency report

Reuters, on Jan 26, reported that Ethiopia’s cabinet approved the lifting of the ongoing state of emergency. The media outlet published a news article titled, “Ethiopia’s cabinet approves lifting of the state of emergency.”

On Jan 26, Ethiopia’s Council of Ministers passed a proposal of ending the state of emergency declared in November last year to be submitted to the House of Peoples’ Representatives (HPR) for approval. Following the statement, Reuters came out with a news article that Ethiopia’s cabinet of ministers lifted the state of emergency.

It is true that the Council of Ministers approved a proposal to end the state of emergency. But the cabinet has no legal mandate to lift it by a decision without the approval of the HPR. Hence, the cabinet sends the proposal to the HPR for ratification.

The sub-article two of article 11 of the proclamation of the state of emergency declared on Nov 2, 2021, states that the HPR can lift the state of emergency ahead of its expiration.

Therefore, HaqCheck fact-checked the claim and found it MISLEADING.

False images of alleged fresh skirmishes between Tigray and Afar forces

There were also false images on social media, particularly Facebook, supposed to be supporting claims of the fresh fighting between TPLF forces and Afar regional armed forces.

A Facebook post was shared more than 50 times since it was published on January 25, 2022, on a page with more than 62,560 followers, which mostly features pro-Afar content. The post generated 1,200 reactions. A picture attached in the post shows a bulk of ammunition. Written in Amharic, the caption reported that Afar troops recently seized firearms from Tigrayan forces. 

“The Afar are receiving the weapons the Junta is handing over,” reads part of the caption. Junta refers to the Tigrayan forces, while Afar is a neighboring region, which allies with the federal government against Tigrayan troops.

 

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the image shows weapons recovered by the African Union Mission in Somalia (AMISOM) in August 2014. Even though the image shows ammunition, it is old and unrelated to the recent conflict in northern Ethiopia. Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post-FALSE. 

Recommendations

HaqCheck recommends international media outlets be careful and accurate while reporting. They should also offer readers a rational and professional explanation of the subject under discussion rather than leaving readers in the dark. They should abstain from misinforming audiences by making misleading and inaccurate headlines of news articles. They should avoid ambiguity.

We observed social media influencers and content creators sharing false images mixed up with new pictures. This makes it hard for users to identify the false from the true images. Using false images also undermines the truth on the ground. Thus, they should be responsible and abstain from sharing false and unauthenticated images and information.

Social media users should question the authenticity of the information before they read and share it with others.  They should be conscious of the origin and intention of unverified information posted on social media platforms and spot out trustable pages and sources to grasp the crux of the issue.

As we always do, we recommend the government provide sufficient and up-to-date information to the public and to the media. Disinformation and information disorder intensifies during times of shortage of information.

False: The picture does not show firearms seized by Afar troops during a recent conflict

The Facebook post, archived here, has been shared more than 50 times since it was published on January 25, 2022, on a page with more than 62,560 followers, which mostly features pro-Afar content. The post generated 1,200 reactions. 

The picture attached in the post shows a bulk of ammunition. Written in Amharic, the caption reported that Afar troops seized firearms from Tigrayan forces in the recent front. 

“The Afar are receiving the weapons the Junta is handing over,” reads part of the caption. Junta refers to the Tigrayan forces, while Afar is a neighboring region, which allies with the federal government against Tigrayan troops. However, even though the image shows ammunition, it is old and unrelated to the recent conflict in northern Ethiopia, and HaqCheck found it to be FALSE.

War in Ethiopia erupted in November 2020 when Tigray People Liberation Front (TPLF) rebels reportedly attacked a military command of Ethiopian National Defence Forces (ENDF) in the Tigray region of Ethiopia. It has affected three countries (Ethiopia, Eritrea, and Sudan) on different scales and has impacted three Regions of Ethiopia; Tigray, Amhara, and Afar.

In recent developments, the government announced its intention to start a new national dialogue to pave the way for national consensus and keep the integrity of the country. In a bid for national dialogue, Ethiopian authorities pardoned a number of high-profile political prisoners, including a prominent figure of TPLF. Recently, Afar regional state accused Tigrayan forces of continuing an intensified offensive in Afar. 

HaqCheck inspected the images’ accuracy and Google reverse image search results show that the picture had been used in multiple online stories since 2014.

Moreover, HaqCheck has confirmed that the picture shows weapons recovered by African Union Mission in Somalia (AMISOM) in August 2014.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated it FALSE. 

Annual Report on Disinformation in Ethiopia

The Ethiopian social media landscape was evolving faster than you can refresh your page in 2021. It was rife with controversies, disinformation, and organized social media campaigns, mostly due to major political events that took place within that time. The war that broke out at the end of 2020 between forces loyal to the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) and the Ethiopian federal government exacerbated propaganda campaigns targeting both locals and the international community.

Furthermore, cross-border conflicts, the 2021 sixth general election, and other issues aggravated the circulation of disinformation in 2021.

This report analyzes the causes and the major actors in the dissemination of dis/misinformation along with the platforms widely used by them. In addition to that, the tactics used by those perpetrators to deceive and manipulate their consumers are covered in-depth.

The report also covers the evolving trend of disinformation throughout the year.

Read the whole report here

Demolished compound of the Ethiopian Islamic Council in Bahir Dar and others: weekly disinformation summary

Orthodox Epiphany not celebrated in Tigray amid fears of aerial attacks

Claims that the annual Orthodox Epiphany celebration was not held in Tigray due to fears of aerial attacks appeared on social media. Images were shared inciting controversies regarding the matter.

On Jan 19, 2022, a Facebook post appeared claiming that the Orthodox Epiphany was not celebrated by the believers in Tigray amid fears of drone attacks. The post received over a thousand reactions and was shared close to a hundred times.

Counterclaims also emerged claiming the image was old and doesn’t prove that people in Tigray abstained from attending Epiphany celebrations because of the aerial attacks.

On Jan 19, 2022, another Facebook post was published with the same image above. The post asserted that the image was five years old.

Images of maps showing Eritrea and Ethiopia merged

There were claims that an image of a map merging Ethiopia and Eritrea as one country appeared during Epiphany celebrations in Addis Ababa and other areas.

A viral tweet was made with the claim that the map in the image appeared during the Epiphany celebration in Ethiopia and Cautioned people to stop such acts since it undermines the sovereignty of Eritrea.

The tweet was retweeted over four hundred times and was seen by many users on the platform.

The tweet shared three images to prove the claim. However, one of the three images was false and taken from publications years ago. The third image was taken from an article published by The National News, a United Arab Emirates (UAE) based news outlet. The original image was published in January 2019 along a story entitled, “Ethiopia apologizes after Dubai marathon fans ‘erase Eritrea’ from map”.

Demolished compound of the Ethiopian Islamic Affairs Supreme Council in Bahir Dar

Controversial images and claims had also emerged last week following the information that the premises of the Bahir Dar office of the Ethiopian Islamic Affairs Supreme Council was smashed on the eve of the Epiphany holiday. A Facebook page with the name of Ethiopian Islamic Affairs Supreme Council shared three images along with the claim that the compound was destroyed by the mobs who were celebrating the holiday.

However, many posts appeared counterclaiming that the images shared don’t prove the alleged claim that the premises sustained damages by attendees of the Epiphany celebration

On Jan 19, 2022, a Facebook post emerged with a refutation that the images show when the compound was demolished for reconstruction purposes previously. There also emerged a similar counterclaim alleging the images were old and show the premises during reconstruction.

Amhara militia & Fano checking the movement of departing Ethiopian army

A Facebook post was published with three pictures to prove the claim on Jan 17, 2022. claimed that Fano and local militia checked the movements of the departing federal government army in Kobo, Amhara Regional State. According to the post, the federal army was leaving the area with the command of the Ethiopian army Chief-of-Staff following the approach of TPLF forces which supposedly intended to re-control the town. 

However, two of the three images were learned to be falsely taken from sources dated 4-8 years ago.

The first image was first posted on 16 Dec 2015 in an article about the then youth protests against the rule of the EPRDF regime. The link to the first image can be found here.

The third image out of the three images was taken from a Facebook post in Mar 2019. The post shared the image with a claim to show people blocking the road that connects Bahir Dar and Hamusit. Here is a link to the original image.

However, we could not find the second image that is shared to support the post’s claim.

Therefore, HaqCheck rendered the post PARTLY FALSE.

Recommendations

We recommend social media influencers and content creators be responsible and abstain from sharing false and unauthenticated images and information. They should not misinform their followers and the social media populace in general. 

HaqCheck recommends social media users be conscious of the origin and intention of the unverified information posted on social media platforms. They should question the authenticity of the information before they read and share it with others. They should identify trustable pages and sources to grasp the crux of the issue.

The government should avail sufficient and up-to-date information to the public and to the media. Disinformation and information disorder intensifies during times of shortage of information.

False: The video doesn’t show celebration marking the release of TPLF officials

A Facebook page with more than 52 thousand followers posted a video on Jan 10. Its caption reads, “The celebration of the release of Sebahat Nega and Abay Woldu in Addis Ababa.”  By the time this article was published, the video had more than 1000 reactions and more than 200 shares. It was viewed by over 81 thousand users.

However, HaqCheck looked into the video and rendered it False.

Tigray People Liberation Front (TPLF) officials, who were arrested after the federal government-controlled Mekelle in Dec 2020, were in jail for almost a year.

Charges of overthrowing a constitutionally established regional government, launching attacks against the National army, and engaging in an armed struggle were filed against them in July 2021 by the Federal Attorney General.

The Ministry of Justice, on Jan 07, dropped charges of six individuals, including Sibhat Nega and Abay Weldu, among the charges in the case of Debretsion Gebremichael, TPLF chairman. Their release incited a wide public controversy and debate.  They were released from prison on that day.

In the context of their controversial release,  the post appeared on Facebook claiming to show a celebration that took place in Addis Ababa marking the celebration of the release of Sebhat Nega, TPLF founding member, and Abay Weldu, a higher official of the party.

HaqCheck looked into the video and found out that it was published four years ago on YouTube claiming to show Sebhat Nega in a birthday party with his family.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post as FALSE.

From celebration of the release of TPLF officials to disarming Amhara militia: Weekly disinformation summary

The trend of disinformation and information disorder in the Ethiopian media landscape often varies with the course of the armed conflict in the northern part of the country. Moreover, the disinformation happened to be overhyped recurrently during times of inter-ethnic conflict and violence.

Nevertheless, the disinformation trend during the second week of the first month of this new year was comparatively limited. There were controversies, but most of them were mere opinions and are not worthwhile to be included in this summary.

We also observed fewer false claims emerged mainly on Facebook. Here are the notable controversies that were observed on social media and false claims fact-checked by HaqCheck.

Celebration marking the release of TPLF officials

A viral video was posted by a Facebook page that has more than 52 thousand followers on Jan 10, claiming that the video shows a celebration marking the release of Sebhat Nega, a co-founder and former chairman of the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF). 

The caption of the video post reads “The celebration of the release of Sebehat Nega and Abay Woldu in Addis Ababa.” At the time, the video had more than one thousand reactions and two hundred shares and was viewed by over 81 thousand users.

However, the video is proved to be old, taken from previous publications. HaqCheck interrogated the video clip and found out that it was posted four years ago on YouTube. The description of the original video clip on YouTube claims that Sebhat Nega was celebrating a birthday party with his family in Addis Ababa.

TPLF military truck destroyed by a drone attack

Another disinformation piece that was rendered FALSE by HaqCheck last week was a Facebook post that claimed to show a truck belonging to the TPLF destroyed by a drone attack. The post stated that TPLF launched an attack on the Humera front during the Orthodox Christmas and action was taken in response by the government. Other Facebook pages also posted the image with the same claim.

However, the image is Checked out to be false and does not prove the claim. HaqCheck found out that the image was posted on Dec 26, 2021, on a website with a claim that the truck was destroyed by TPLF forces in Kombolcha town, Amhara Regional State.

Government to disarm Amhara militia

Last week there was a controversy regarding an alleged document drafted by the Ethiopian government. Based on the alleged document, many claims appeared that the government is preparing to disarm Amhara militia (a.k.a Fano) in the Amhara Regional State.

The Amhara Prosperity Party issued a defensive statement that the document circulating on social media was somewhat altered. It explained that part of the document that elaborates the contribution of the Amhara people during the war with the TPLF was intentionally cut out of the document.

Besides, the Amhara regional government said that the claim that the government will disarm Fano (armed militia) is false.

However, the controversy continued. Social media posts appeared claiming the Amhara regional government had been calling armed militia (Fanos) to emergency meetings at localities.

Recommendations

HaqCheck recommends social media users be conscious of the origin and intention of the unverified information posted on social media platforms. They should question the authenticity of the information before they read and share it with others. They should identify trustable pages and sources to grasp the crux of the issue.

The public should be provided with up-to-date information by the government and relevant media outlets. Information discrepancy always prompts controversies and disinformation. Offering sufficient information is the best and most efficient way to prevent disinformation.

Social media influencers and content creators should also be responsible for their activities on the platforms. They should avoid feeding false and damaging information that can misinform people and may trigger offenses.

Partly False: The images don’t show local militia & Fano checking the movement of departing Ethiopian army

A Facebook post, published with three pictures, on Jan 17,  claimed that Fano (volunteer youth patriots) and local militia checked the movements of the departing federal government army. According to the post, the federal army was leaving the area with the command of the army Chief-of-Staff following the approach of TPLF forces which supposedly intended to re-control the town. 

The post was shared by close to three hundred users at the time this article was published.

However, HaqCheck fact-checked the three images used to support the claim and found out that from the set of images including three pictures, the two were taken from sources dated 4-8 years ago and don’t prove the claim, while the third image can not be found. Therefore, the post is rendered PARTLY FALSE.

The war which erupted between  Tigray People Liberation Front (TPLF) forces and the federal government in Nov 2020 is still protracted. The federal government withdrew from Mekelle in June 2020. Thereafter, TPLF forces advanced southward and expanded their control as far as Debre Sina town of the Amhara Regional State.

In Nov 2021, the Ethiopian Government launched counter-offensives against TPLF forces and pushed them out of the Amhara and Afar regional states.

At the end of its operation, the government announced that its forces would not advance further into Tigray. It stated its forces would stay in areas the Tigray Regional State shares borders with Amhara and Afar regions.

A regional state media affiliated with the TPLF claimed that Amhara and Afar regional armed forces and Eritrean armed units were trying to penetrate and enter into Tigray.

It was in this context the post was published with the images.

According to HaqCheck’s inspection, the first image was first posted on 16 Dec 2015 in an article about the then youth protests against the rule of the EPRDF regime. The link to the first image can be found here.

The third image out of the three images was taken from a Facebook post in Mar 2019. The post shared the image with a claim to show people blocking the road that connects Bahir Dar and Hamusit. Here is a link to the original image.

However, we could not find the second image that is shared to support the post’s claim.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post PARTLY FALSE due to the usage of inaccurate images to prove the claim.

False: The image doesn’t show a truck destroyed by a drone attack

A Facebook page with more than 45,000 followers posted an image on Jan 07, 2022, claiming that an action was taken in response to an attack by the Tigray people liberation front (TPLF)  at the Humera front during which its army was destroyed by a drone attack. Other Facebook pages also posted the image with the same claim.

However, the image doesn’t show a truck destroyed by a drone attack and HaqCheck rendered it as false.

It had been over a year since the war between the Tigray people liberation front (TPLF) and The Federal Government of Ethiopia began. After staying in control of Mekelle for seven months, The federal government declared a unilateral ceasefire and pulled out its troops from most parts of Tigray at the end of June 2021. 

The declaration of ceasefire was not accepted by TPLF; rather the rebel group started advancing to Afar and Amhara regional states. TPLF stayed in control of several cities until the military offensives and counter-offensives led by prime minister Abiy Ahmed(Ph.d.) from the frontlines, which started on Nov 22, 2021. Most parts of both regions were liberated in a short period of time. 

Even though TPLF Officials stated that they were not defeated, but retreated from the neighboring regions in order to give a chance for peace. The federal government stated that TPLF didn’t retreat but was completely defeated. Marking the end of the operation led by the Prime Minister,  the federal government announced that the defense forces won’t advance further to Tigray and will be positioned at the borders. 

There had been accusations on the federal government and its allies that they had been in engagements on different fronts trying to advance into Tigray and TPLF troops were conducting counter-offensive on the federal government forces.

A claim appeared on Facebook in the framework of this situation.

In addition to the clear visual differences between the trucks that can be detected by a naked eye, HaqCheck used Reverse image search to interrogate the image used in the post to show the destroyed truck. 

Original image

However, HaqCheck found out that it was posted on Dec 26, 2021, by the #nomore-Ethiopia website as one of the properties destroyed by TPLF during its control of Kombolcha town.

Hence, due to the inaccuracy of the image used to support the claim, HaqCheck rated it as false.

False: The image doesn’t show Sudanese protesters holding the Ethiopian flag during a recent rally in support of the ENDF

A Facebook account with 262,812 followers posted a photo on Dec 31, 2021, claiming that Sudanese demonstrators who protested against the government marching to the palace were holding the Ethiopian federal flag to show their support to Ethiopia and the Ethiopian National Defense Forces (ENDF) on Dec 30. By the time this article was published, the post had 13,000 reactions and was shared two thousand times.

However, Haqcheck looked into the image used to support the claim and rendered it FALSE due to its inaccuracy.

Sudan’s crisis started as an Economic problem, due to the rise in the cost of bread and fuel in Dec 2018, which later grew to be a political problem and led to the overthrow of the government of President Omar Al-Bashir who ruled Sudan for 30 years. After the formation of a transitional government called the ‘Sovereignty Council of Sudan’ to be led by Abdalla Hamdok as Prime Minister, protests have been held asking higher officials of the former government to be arrested and face accountability for their actions.

The military, led by Abdel Fattah Al-Burhan, took control of power in a military coup On Oct 25 2021, and Prime Minister Abdalla Hamdok was arrested with the majority of his cabinet. The coup was followed by pro-civilian government protests that started On Oct 26. Later General Abdul Fattah Al-Burhan announced that he was willing to share power and restore the Sovereignty Council of Sudan and signed a deal. But civilian groups rejected the deal, refusing the power-sharing deal with the military, and had been holding a series of protests with an ever-increasing number of participants.

It is reported that many Ethiopians living in Sudan participated in the rallies. Sudan and Ethiopia have been in a state of disagreement particularly since last year due to a border dispute.

In this context, the claim appeared on Facebook stating that during the protest held on Dec 30, 2021 millions of Sudanese were holding the Ethiopian flag singing, “Ethiopia is our second country, peace to Ethiopia, victory to the   Ethiopian National Defense of Force[s].” 

HaqCheck looked into the image and confirmed that the image does not support the claim that millions of Sudanese held the Ethiopian flag during a recent protest. The image was taken from another previous publication by CBS 42 news in Aug 2019 entitled, “Sudanese pro-democracy supporters celebrate a final power-sharing agreement with the ruling military council…”. The report used the picture with the supposition of showing the Sudanese holding the Ethiopian flag since the Ethiopian Government played an important role in the peace process.

Therefore, Haqcheck rated the image used to support the claim as FALSE. 

Exit mobile version