Was the person in the image found dead in Tigray due to the ongoing military operation in the region?

On December 14, 2020 a facebook post was published by a facebook user named ኣነ ንባእላ ትግራይ (an account with 15,849 followers) sharing the picture below of a man who sleeping on straw with the claim that the man (the post claims the person is woman) was found dead because of starvation due to the ongoing military operation in Tigray. The text – which is written in Tigrinya reads “Please share it so that Tigreans and Tigrean-friends in the world can see. … People who managed to escape bullets are dying because of starvation in Tigray… Properties are robbed,.. No electricity, no money due to banks being closed…” The user pleads with other users to share the image worldwide. However, HaqCheck has confirmed that the picture below doesn’t show the realities in Tigray, rendering the verdict FALSE for the usage of the image falsely to support the claim.

Granted, it is true that there have been instabilities in Tigray due to the armed conflict between the federal government-led forces and TPLF-led Tigray Special Forces and militia since November 4, 2020. The Ethiopian National Defence Forces (ENDF) and Amhara regional forces on one front, and the Tigray special police force and militia on the other side have been engaged in conflict since then. It is also true that due to the ensuing conflict and other humanitarian concerns (such as the desert locust invasion and COVID19) have contributed to the humanitarian crisis being compounded in the Tigray region. Due to initial moves by the TPLF it is also true that transportation, electricity and banking service have remained closed since the onset of the armed conflict, until being partially restored in the region after the Federal forces controlled major cities in Tigray. According to international relief organizations such as the UNHCR, UNOCHA and ICRC there is a shortage of food, medicine and other essential resources in the region. 

Recently the federal government sent thousands of quintals of food item humanitarian aid to Mekelle and Shire.

Image 1: Altered Image (“Ohhhh Mother!” With grief emoji)

Image 2: Original Image

However, a reverse image search of the image that was posted by the facebook account indicates that the man slept on straw is not in Tigray. The picture was published for the first time on Reddit, an American social news aggregation, web content rating and discussion website with a text written in Nepali on November 25, 2020. At the time, the reddit user posted the image with the translated text “In the language of KP Oli [the current Nepali prime minister], it is a non-national element that is scared to see prosperity in the country. In the language of KP Oli, this is propaganda that sees the root of development in the country.” The post can be accessed using the following link. Two days later cinekala.com, social media website wrote a story on the image claiming that the man was 77-years-old Rai (ethnolinguistic group in Nepal) and had been ill for 10 years and found slept on straw because he didn’t have any piece of cloth or bed. The story can be accessed using the following link.

HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the picture was not captured during the current crises in Tigray neither was the man on the image found dead in Tigray. Consequently, HaqCheck has rated the above post as FALSE for using the wrong picture to support the claim.

Fact Checked by: Hagos Gebreamlak

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking running in five languages (Affan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English)

Editor’s Note: 

The following article was published as part of Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking initiative. As the reconstruction of our website continues, Addis Zeybe would like its readers to note that it will be publishing fact checking articles on a permanent basis in five languages (Afaan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English. Addis Zeybe will also be publishing monthly pandemic impact assessment and human rights reports in the coming months.

Did these trucks come to rob Tigray?

The facebook post below alleged that trucks are heading to Tigray to loot the region asking its followers (23,253 followers) to share the image. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and the pictures used as evidence to learn that it was false information.

There have been instabilities in Tigray following the conflict that broke out between the federal and regional forces on 4 November 2020. The TPLF-led Tigray regional government forces on the one side and the Ethiopian National Defence Forces and Amhara regional forces on the other side had been in fighting for nearly a month now with the ENDF later controlling Mekele on 28 November 2020. The conflict in the region is still raging on with TPLF leaders still at large in an area close to Mekele, the capital of Tigray.

Amid the conflict a facebook post claiming that trucks from Eritrea are looting the Tigray region has emerged. However, a reverse image search of the first image used in the facebook post shows that the picture is of the heavy-duty trucks that were used by Piccini, an Italian construction firm when constructing residential buildings and resorts in Massawa, Eritrea. The picture was first published in March in 2013 and can be accessed with the following link.

The second picture on the other hand is of an old truck taken from Eritrea. A reverse image search indicates that the image was first published in Flickr, an American image and video sharing platform in 2012 and can be accessed with the following link.

Granted, there were ongoing instabilities in Tigray at the time the facebook post was shared. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and rated it as FALSE information due to the inaccuracy of the claim related to the pictures.

Fact Checked by: Hagos Gebreamlak

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking initiative, which is run by its R&D Department.

Editor’s Note:

The following article was published as part of Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking initiative. As the reconstruction of our website continues, Addis Zeybe would like its readers to note that it will be publishing fact checking articles on a permanent basis in five languages (Affan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English. Addis Zeye will also be publishing monthly pandemic impact assessment and human rights reports in the coming months. 

Does the image in the post show ENDF forces destroying infrastructure using heavy artillery in the Tigray region?

The picture in the post by the facebook profile Felmi Bar – which has 5,000 friends as of 7 December 2020 – does not show the Ethiopian National Defence Force’s operation in Tigray neither does it support the claim in the post written in Affaan Oromo and posted on the above profile on 7 December 2020. The post claims that the Federal government is looting and destroying infrustructures in the Tigray region before proposing that the government should be held accountable for this. HaqCheck has interrogated the pictures in the post to reach the conclusion that the first image was a FALSE image while the second one couldn’t be located anywhere. 

As can be seen from the image above, the page posted two pictures to support the above claim. The first one shows shots from heavy artillery tanks while the second picture depicts an individual wearing a military uniform trying to shoot a heavy artillery weapon. The user uses these pictures to support his claim that the Ethiopian National Defense force is destroying infrastructure using huge heavy artillery in the Tigray national regional state without specifically mentioning the exact place in the Region.

Granted, there is an ongoing conflict in the Tigray National Regional State between the ENDF and it’s the Amhara Special Police and Militia on one side and the Tigray Special Police and Militia on the other. There have also been scattered claims that the ENDF side was looting and destroying infrastructure in the  Tigray region, including from the Communications head of the TPLF Getachew Reda. However, amid the continuing network and internet blackout, there are no confirmed incidents of such looting in the region, including in the capital of the region, Mekelle. 

Image 1: Original Image 

Image 2:     Altered image  

A reverse image search of the image used by  the page Felmi Bar so as to support the claim that says the national defense forces were destroying infrastructure in Tigray region using heavy artillery doesn’t accurately show the reality. To the contrary the image was first posted by  Indian Ocean Newsletter on May 7,2011 showing the conflict between Ethiopia and its northern neighbour Eritrea during the Ethio-Eritrea war. No result appears for the first image in any of HaqCheck’s tools. 

It is true that there has been conflict in the region in which both warring parties have used heavy artilleries but HaqCheck has confirmed that the first photo used by the page in order to support the claim in the post, leading it to rate the above post as FALSE. 

Fact Checked by: Abdulahi Abdulakadir  

Edited by:  Bruck Negash  

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking running in five languages (Afaan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English)

Editor’s Note: 

The following article was published as part of Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking initiative. As the reconstruction of our website continues, Addis Zeybe would like its readers to note that it will be publishing fact checking articles on a permanent basis in five languages (Afaan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English. Addis Zeye will also be publishing monthly pandemic impact assessment and human rights reports in the coming months.

Was the picture below taken during the Mai Kadra massacre?

On December 11, 2020 a facebook post was published by a facebook user named Selam Nkulu (an account with 3418 friends and 1337 followers) sharing the picture below of men who handle chopper billhook in their hands with the claim that the people in the image are responsible for the Mai Kadra massacre. The text – which is written in Amharic- translates to read “let the image be archived properly, these men [the six individuals in the picture] are among those who will be held accountable. The image shows who partook in the Mai Kadra massacre.” However, HaqCheck has confirmed that the picture below doesn’t show the realities during the Mai Kadra incident, rendering the verdict FALSE for the claim by the facebook user.

Granted, it is true that at the cusp of the current conflict on November 9 and 10 there were mass killings of civilians based on their ethnic identity with numbers as high as 600. The massacre of civilians was executed amidst armed conflict between the Federal government and the TPLF led Tigray special police and militia. According to the government, the Ethiopian Human Rights Commission and other international and local outlets, the attacks were jointly carried out by local authorities in Mai Kadra and an extremist group known as Samri which is made up of youth from Tigray. According to the preliminary study conducted by the Ethiopian Human Rights Commission (ECHR) over 600 civilians were killed during the massacre which was carried out on November 9 and 10, 2020. It is also true that according to the ECHR and Amnesty International, the perpetrators of the mass and gruesome killings in the Mai Kadra town used machetes, axes, sharp objects and ropes to claim lives of ethnic Amhara and Wolkait Ethiopians living in the town. Currently investigations are underway according to the ECHR, even though the Spokesperson of the State of Emergency in Tigray Task Force, Redwan Hussien said that no independent external investigation will be allowed on the Mai Kadra killings. 

Image 1: Altered Image

Image 2: Original Image (ebisa )

However, a reverse image search of the image that was posted by the facebook account indicates that the picture is not of the incident in Mai Kadra in which over 600 people were killed. The picture was published for the first time on twitter by the name ebisa on July 10, 2020. At the time, ebisa posted four images along with the above one with a text that reads “#Justice for Oromo people in [the] Empire of Ethiopia? #AbiyMustGo.” The post can be accessed using the following link. 

HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the picture was not captured during the current crises in the northern part of the country and that it does not support the claim of the persons in the picture partook in the killing. Based on this HaqCheck has rated the above post as FALSE for posting the picture to support the claim. 

Fact Checked by: Hagos Gebreamlak

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking running in five languages (Affan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English)

Editor’s Note: 

The following article was published as part of Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking initiative. As the reconstruction of our website continues, Addis Zeybe would like its readers to note that it will be publishing fact checking articles on a permanent basis in five languages (Afaan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English. Addis Zeybe will also be publishing monthly pandemic impact assessment and human rights reports in the coming months.

Exit mobile version