Does the image show an ongoing armed conflict in Gojjam, Amhara region?

An image was posted on Facebook on June 16, 2023, with a claim that heavy fighting was ongoing between Fano militias and the Ethiopian military troops in Eastern Gojjam, Amhara region. It also claimed that the Ethiopian troops deployed into the area were defeated and forced to retreat.

The Facebook post was viral and shared more than forty-five times on the platform.

However, the image used to support the claim was old and has no connection with the claim. Thus, HaqCheck rated the claim as False.

After the Ethiopian government began demobilizing regional special police forces, there have been resistance and clashes in the Amhara region.

Additionally, a former leader of the Addis Ababa-based Balderas Party Eskindir Nega, recently announced that he formed a military organization named Amhara Popular Force to wage an armed resistance against the Ethiopian government.

The Amhara regional state was embroiled in widespread protest and armed clashes between the Ethiopian government’s armed forces and informal armed militias.

News reports indicate that many people have been killed in the regional state in recent armed confrontations.

Recent conflicts and protests were also reported in East and West Gojjam zones of the region in which protesters were killed by security personnel and armed militias killed Ethiopian army soldiers. 

Against this backdrop, a Facebook post emerged sharing an image with a claim that there was heavy fighting between Fano militias and the Ethiopian military troops in Eastern Gojjam, Amhara region, and the Ethiopian soldiers were defeated and retreated.

HaqCheck looked into the image to see whether it supports the claim. However, the image was old and published on social media platforms years ago.

The picture was published on Twitter for the first time on Nov 23, 2021, when Fano militias, alongside the Ethiopian and Eritrean armed forces, were fighting against the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) forces. The original image was also shared in this context.

Granted that there were armed clashes and resistance in the Gojjam zones of the Amhara regional state, the image doesn’t support the claim. Therefore, HaqCheck rated the claim as False due to its usage of an inaccurate image.

Does the image show an ongoing armed conflict in the Amhara region?

An image was circulating on Facebook supporting a claim that it shows an ongoing armed conflict between the Ethiopian federal troops and armed militia forces in the Amhara regional state.

HaqCheck spotted the image disseminating along with Facebook posts including here, here, and here. The posts reached many users across the Ethiopian landscape.

However, the image is old and it doesn’t show an ongoing armed conflict in the Amhara region.

On Apr 6, 2023, the Ethiopian federal government announced that it had decided that regional special police forces should be dissolved and integrated into the Ethiopian National Defence Forces, the Federal Police, or the regional police.

Following the decision of the government, tensions arose in the Amhara regional state and there were widespread public protests in the region opposing the federal government’s decision to disestablish regional special police forces.

On Apr 27, 2023, Girma Yeshitla, the head of the Amhara Prosperity Party was killed. The Ethiopian federal government and the Amhara regional government accused armed militias, commonly known as Fano, of assassinating the senior party official and vowed to take serious measures.

Unconfirmed social media reports claimed that the government deployed armed forces in the Amhara regional state to disarm Fano militants.

Recent news reports stated that Eskindir Nega, a former leader of the Balderas Party established a military organization named Amhara Popular Force to fight the Ethiopian government.

Amid that, social media posts alleged that there had been clashes in the region between Ethiopian troops and armed militias.

Against this backdrop, Facebook posts came out with an image claiming that the picture shows an ongoing armed conflict between Amhara regional militias and Ethiopian troops in Gojjam, Amhara region.

HaqCheck looked into the image and found out that the picture was published some years ago.

The image was published for the first time on Facebook on Nov 4, 2018. The original Facebook post shared the image with a description that conflict arose between the Ethiopian National Defence Forces troops and residents in Kobo, Amhara region.Thus, HaqCheck rated the Facebook posts that claimed the image shows an ongoing armed conflict in Amhara regional False.

Do the pictures show recently demolished mosques in Oromia?

Four pictures were shared on Twitter on May 22, 2023, supporting a claim that the images show recently demolished mosques in the Oromia region by the government. The post stated that government buildings were being instead constructed in the areas where the mosques previously stood.

The Twitter post further claims that the Ethiopian government recently knocked down five mosques in Oromia and more than 35 religious places have been deliberately demolished since the ascent of Ahiy Ahmed (PhD) to premiership.

The Addis Ababa city administration and the Oromia regional government have been demolishing allegedly illegal houses in Addis Ababa and surrounding areas in Oromia. The government says that the houses being pulled down were illegally constructed.

The administration of the newly established city of Sheger has recently demolished many illegal houses on the outskirts of Addis Ababa. The city administration claimed that it was knocking down illegally constructed housings.

Furthermore, there were unconfirmed reports that religious buildings such as mosques and churches were bulldozed during a recent ‘illegal houses demolition’ campaign launched by the Sheger city administration, in the Oromia region.

On May 18, 2023, the Ethiopian Islamic Affairs Supreme Council wrote a letter to Prime Minister Abiy complaining about the alleged demolition of mosques in Sheger City.

In this context, a Twitter post came up with four images claiming that the Ethiopian government recently demolished five mosques in Oromia and was constructing government buildings instead.

HaqCheck looked into the images and found out that the pictures were old and had no connection with the claim.

The pictures show the al-Nejashi Mosque, an old mosque, damaged due to shelling during the war between the Ethiopian government and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF).

The images were published by different news outlets and across social media platforms.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the claim False as it used inaccurate images to support it.

Do these images show houses demolished for the construction of the new Ethiopian Palace?

On May 19, 2023, a claim appeared on Twitter sharing two images that they show houses recently demolished for the construction of the new Ethiopian palace in Addis Ababa.

The Twitter account has over nine thousand followers. The post was viewed more than eighteen thousand times and it was shared by 238 accounts across the platform.

However, HaqCheck inquired about the claim and confirmed that one of the two pictures was old and doesn’t support the claim. Thus, the claim was rated Partly False.

The Ethiopian government has embarked on the building of a new palace in the Yeka district of Addis Ababa. The palace project and other related facilities being built are dubbed by the government as ‘Chaka Project’.

The palace was first reported to cost 49 billion Birr, but later on, Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (PhD) told the Parliament that his government was constructing the Chaka Project for hundreds of billions of Birr.

The Project to be sprawled on 503 hectares of land will comprise halls, artificial lakes, housing units, and road infrastructures.

It is supposed that thousands of people would be evacuated from the area where the project lays on. As part of it, a 20-kilometer long asphalt road was being built for 15 billion Birr.

Recent social media reports claim that people have been told to evacuate the area where the Chaka Project is being built within a few days.

On the other hand, the Addis Ababa city administration and the Oromia regional government have been engaged in house demolitions in Addis Ababa and surrounding areas in Oromia. The government says that the houses being demolished were illegal.

The administration of the newly established city of Sheger have recently demolished many illegal houses in the outskirts of Addis Ababa. The city administration claimed that it was knocking down illegally constructed houses.

Against this backdrop, a claim emerged on Twitter sharing two images that they show recently demolished houses for the construction of the new Ethiopian Palace.

However, HaqCheck investigated the claim and found out that one of the two pictures was old and has no connection with the construction of the new palace.

The first image used to support the claim was first published on Facebook on Feb 19, 2019 with a description that houses were being razed in the Legetafo Legedadi city administration, part of the then Finfinne Special Zone of the Oromia regional state.

The second picture in the Twitter post was first published by Addis Standard, a local media outlet, on Jan 6, 2023, along with a news article. The news outlet stated that the picture shows a recently demolished house and it was one of many images it received. But, Addis Standard didn’t give a further description of where was the house demolished. Therefore, HaqCheck rated the claim Partly False because one of the pictures used was old.

Is the alleged Mihret Wodajo phone call recording audio released by the government AI-generated and Fake?

Social media platforms particularly Facebook recently surfaced with a claim that the phone call conversation between Mihret Wedajo and a Fano member released by the Ethiopian government to prove that Girma Yeshitla was assassinated by Fano militias was examined and debunked by an American organization called ‘Digi Forensic Experts’ as an AI constructed audio.

Background

Girma Yeshitla, the head of the Amhara Prosperity Party, a branch of the Ethiopian Prosperity Party and a ruling party in the Amhara regional state, was killed on Apr 27, 2023, in the Semen Shewa zone of the region.

The federal government accused ‘extremist forces’ of assassinating Girma Yeshitla. It said that these ‘extremist forces claimed to be fighting for the Ahmara people and in reality were trying to capture state power using force’.

The Amhara regional government blamed the Fano armed group, a group of armed militias in eastern parts of the Amhara regional state for the killing of Girma Yeshitila.

The militia group that was accused of murdering the senior party official is led by a person named Mihret Wedajo.

On Apr 29, 2023, state-affiliated media outlets such as the Addis Media Network came up with audio that claimed to be a phone call conversation between the militia group’s leader Mihret Wedajo, and Belete Shegaw, a member of the militant group. 

The government released the audio as evidence that Girma Yeshitla was killed by the Fano militia group.

The audio recording allegedly indicating Mihret Wedajo and another militant confirming they killed Girma Yeshitla had infested the Ethiopian social media landscape.

Days later, on May 7, 2023, a claim circulated across social media platforms that the audio released by the government as a conversation between Mihret Wedajo and Belete Shegaw was proven fabricated and fake.

The social media posts claimed that the audio was examined by an American technology company named Digi Forensic Experts and confirmed as the audio was generated using artificial intelligence.

The social media posts include screenshot papers allegedly taken from the forensic examiner organization. The claimed article was also published on a blog.

HaqCheck endeavored to cross-check the claim.

Is the organization ‘Digi Forensic Experts’ real?

HaqCheck couldn’t find any organizational entity on the Internet registered as ‘Digi Forensic Experts’.

But, there is a company called Digital Forensic Experts. The website of the company claims that it investigates the authenticity of audio and video files.

However, the alleged investigation of the audio released by the Ethiopian government was not on the website of Digital Forensic Experts.

We have searched the social media accounts of the company if the alleged article was published there. But, there was no social media handle with the same name as the company.

HaqCheck looked into the alleged (Digi Forensic Experts) organization’s address on the screenshots. The call number given belongs to a company named Digital Forensic Experts and the postal code, street address, and suite address belong to Kaufmann Media Group, a film company based in California, USA. Digital Forensic Experts and Kaufmann Media Group were founded by the same person named Sam Kaufmann.

Additionally, HaqCheck looked into the screenshot document and the images there. The text and the images are blurred.

[Image taken from the alleged forensic investigation by ‘Digi Forensic Experts’.]

The blurriness of the images and the texts clues that there is a probability that the images and the texts could be altered.

HaqCheck also found similar images on other sites to those used in the alleged forensic examination article.

These images are very similar to the pictures in the screenshots. These pictures were obtained published in a blog along with an article about an audio music forensic analysis.

HaqCheck approached the film production company, Digital Forensic Experts via email to inquire about the case. However, they did not yet respond to our inquest until this article was published.

False: The image doesn’t show an ongoing drought in Ethiopia

On Feb 23, 2023, a Twitter account posted an image claiming that it shows an ongoing drought in Borana, Oromia regional state. The image depicts several carcasses.

The Twitter post was seen over two thousand times and was shared more than fifty times.

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the image doesn’t show the ongoing drought in Borana, Oromia. Thus, the post was rated False due to the application of an inaccurate picture.

Reports indicate that many areas in the Oromia and Somali regional states of Ethiopia have been hit by severe drought. The drought has endured for more than five consecutive years now. A severe drought has decimated the Borana Zone of the Oromia region.

The eastern and southern parts of the Oromia region particularly the Borana Zone was highly affected by drought during the previous years. Last year, thousands of children, women, and elderly people faced severe health problems such as malnutrition and thousands of cattle died due to the drought.

The enduring drought has been caused by climate change followed by an acute shortage of rainfall in the areas. Climate change resulted in land degradation and significant depletion of pasture in Borana.

The drought exposed eight hundred thousand residents in the zone to an immediate food assistance.

The people in the eastern parts of Ethiopia such as Borana are pastoralists and semi-pastoralists and their lives depend on the availability of pastures for cattle. The absence of rainfall for five subsequent years has devastated the livelihood of the communities of Borana.

Against this backdrop, a Twitter post came out sharing an image that depicts carcasses lying on the ground with a claim that the picture shows an ongoing drought in the Borana zone of the Oromia regional state.

However, the image is old and doesn’t show a current drought in Borana. The picture first appeared on Facebook on Mar 18, 2022, describing that the Bale and Borana zones of the Oromia region were severely affected by the drought.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the post False because of its employment of an inaccurate image to support the claim.

False: The image doesn’t show a church destroyed in Tigray during the armed conflict

A Facebook post emerged on Feb 6, 2023, sharing an image with a claim that the picture shows a church destroyed in Tigray during the armed conflict between the Ethiopian government and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF). The post alleges that the Ethiopian and Eritrean Orthodox Tewahdo churches were collaborators when churches were destroyed in Tigray during the war.

However, the image was very old and doesn’t prove the claim that it shows a church destroyed in Tigray during the recent war. HaqCheck rated the claim as False.

War broke out on Nov 3, 2020, between the Ethiopian government and the TPLF forces after the latter attacked Ethiopian military bases in Tigray.

On Nov 17, 2020, Ethiopian state-affiliated media outlets (EBC, Ethiopian News Agency) reported that the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church expressed its support for the Ethiopian armed forces.

News reports indicate that churches were damaged in Tigray regional state during the armed conflict.

Amid the war, Orthodox Tewahido clergies in the Tigray regional state announced last year that they cut ties with the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church.

On Jan 22, 2023, Abune Sawiros, Archbishop of South West Shoa, along with two others appointed 26 bishops without the recognition of the Holy Synod of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church. The breakaway clergy announced that seventy bishops would be dispatched to churches in the Oromia regional state.

The Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church denounced and excommunicated Abune Sawiros and other bishops who co-organized the appointment.

A few days later, the breakaway archbishops denounced and excommunicated twelve archbishops of the Ethiopian Orthodox Church.

The split stirred up tensions in various parts of the country. VOA reported that conflict erupted in Shashemene town at a church and three people were killed.

The Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church called upon its members to wear black for three days to protest against the breakaway group and alleged government involvement in the issue.

Against this backdrop, a Facebook post shared an image on Feb 6, 2023, claiming that the picture shows a church destroyed in Tigray during the war between the Ethiopian government and TPLF forces. The Facebook account has over twenty thousand followers and the post can reach many audiences.

However, the image was old and doesn’t support the claim that it shows a church destroyed in Tigray during the recent war.

The image shows a church in the town of Adi Keyh, Eritrea, destroyed during the war between Ethiopia and Eritrea. The picture was taken from a video published by Reuters in April 1999.

Later on, the post was edited and the image was replaced with three pictures. HaqCheck could not confirm whether the later three images prove the claim or not.Therefore, the post was rated False.

False: The image doesn’t show a recent conflict in Ataye town, Amhara region

An image that shows burning houses was circulating on Facebook with a claim that the picture belongs to a recent conflict in the town of Ataye, Amhara regional state. The image was posted along with two others on Facebook on Jan 24, 2023, by a page that has over five thousand followers.

Two hours later, the image was published by a Facebook page with more than five thousand followers on the same platform with the same claim that it shows an ongoing conflict in Ataye.

However, HaqCheck investigated the claim and confirmed that the image was first published three years ago and doesn’t show an ongoing conflict in the area. Thus, the claim was rated False.

Recurrent conflict and violence have been raging in the North Shewa and the Oromo Special zones of the Amhara regional state and adjacent areas since 2019.

In October 2019, a conflict in which three people were killed was reported. Two years later in 2021, a severe conflict occurred in the Oromo Special Zone, particularly in Ataye town.

The conflict spanned two months and hundreds of civilians were killed and injured. More than three hundred thousand people were displaced and over three thousand houses were destroyed in the April and March 2021 conflict and violence.

A quarter of the town of Ataye was destroyed during the conflict. The Amhara regional government asked for 1.5 billion Birr for the reconstruction of the town and for other rehabilitation efforts.

In April 2022, a conflict broke out in the North Showa and Oromo Special zones of the Amhara region. Over a dozen people were killed in that particular conflict.

This week, there were social media reports that conflict recently erupted in the North Shewa and Oromo Special zones and in the towns of Ataye and Jewha in particular.

Against this backdrop, an image came to circulate on Facebook with the claim that the image shows an ongoing conflict and violence in Ataye town. The picture shows properties being burnt. The image was shared by two Facebook pages each with over five thousand followers on Jan 24, 2023.

Yet, HaqCheck confirmed that the image was old and doesn’t show an ongoing conflict in the area.

The image was first published three years ago on Facebook in April 2019. The text that accompanied the image claims that the image shows a church destroyed by fire in the town of Ataye at that time.

Therefore, HaqCheck rated the claim as False.

False: Ambassador Misganu Arega is not appointed as Ethiopia’s Foreign Minister replacing Demeke Mokennen.

On Jan 11, 2023, a Facebook post emerged sharing the picture of Ambassador Mesganu Arega with a claim that he was appointed as Ethiopian Foreign Minister by Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed.

The post also stated that the new minister replaced the incumbent foreign minister Demeke Mokkonen.

The Facebook page has over thirteen thousand followers and the post is highly likely to reach a wider audience.

HaqCheck however confirmed that Ambassador Mesganu Arega was not appointed a foreign minister. Prime Minister Abiy appointed the former ambassador as a state minister of the Ethiopian Foreign Ministry.

Ministerial reshuffling has been recurrent since Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed came to power.

When Abiy came in 2018, Workneh Gebeyehu, the current Executive Secretary of the Intergovernmental Authority on Development (IGAD) was Ethiopia’s Foreign Minister.

The former Amhara regional president, Gedu Andargachew replaced Workneh Gebeyehu as Foreign Minister in 2019.

As the war between the Ethiopian government and Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) broke out in November 2020, Prime Minister Abiy appointed Demeke Mekonnen as the Minister of Foreign Affairs. Demeke has since been the Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister.

On Jan 11, 2023, the Ethiopian Ministry of Foreign Affairs published a short news statement on its Facebook page that Prime Minister Abiy named former ambassador Mesganu Arega as Foreign State Minister, effective January 10.

The claim that PM Abiy picked Mesganu Arega as Ethiopian Foreign Minister replacing Demeke Mokonnen immediately emerged on Facebook.

The post was later edited and stated that the former ambassador was appointed as Ethiopia’s Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs.

However, HaqCheck cross-checked the information and confirmed that Ambassador Mesganu Arega was not appointed as a new Foreign Minister.

Additionally, he was not named as Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs.

The statement from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ethiopia asserts that the former CEO of the Ethio-Engineering Group and former ambassador to Qatar and UAE was appointed as a State Minister of Foreign Affairs.

Thus, HaqCheck rendered the post False.

False: The circulating video of alleged Debretsion Gebremichael’s recent remarks on the peace deal and PM Abiy’ is old

A viral video was shared across social media platforms, mainly Facebook and Twitter, with a claim that the video was of a recent interview with TPLF chairman, Debretsion Gebremichael (PhD) about the peace agreement and he made good remarks on the deal and PM Abiy Ahmed (PhD).

The video was shared many times. It was watched by over 41 thousand users on a particular Twitter post.

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the video clip was taken from an old interview in 2018 on the peace agreement between Ethiopia and Eritrea. It was published on YouTube on Jul 15, 2018.

The Ethiopian federal government and the TPLF had been fighting a two years war that started on Nov 3, 2022.

They agreed to a humanitarian truce at the end of March 2022. However, fighting resumed between the belligerents in August.

Reports indicated that there were informal talks between the TPLF and the Ethiopian federal government to solve the war peacefully.

Finally, they signed a peace deal dubbed ‘Agreement for lasting peace through a permanent cessation of hostilities between the Government of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF)’ on Nov 2, 2022.

According to the deal, TPLF agreed to surrender its weapons to the Ethiopian government and a transitional government to be installed in Mekelle until a regional election is conducted.

The hostile propaganda against each other seems to have discontinued since the agreement was signed.

Against this backdrop, a viral video came out with a claim that it was a recent interview with TPLF chairman, Debretsion Gebremichael (PhD) about the peace agreement and he made good remarks on PM Abiy. The video clip circulated across social media platforms such as Facebook and Twitter.

However, HaqCheck confirmed that the video clip was taken from an old interview with Debretsion in 2018 about the peace agreement between Ethiopia and Eritrea. The recent video was extracted from the old one and was edited to make it look like a recent interview.

The original video was published on YouTube on Jul 15, 2018.

Thus, the posts were rated False.

Exit mobile version