Fact Checks

Does the image show an Ethiopian fighter jet shot during the ongoing conflict in Tigray?

On 29 January 2020 a facebook post was shared by the account Sidaama Today (a personal blog with  17,248 followers) sharing the image below with the claim that a fighter jet of the Ethiopian National Defense Forces (ENDF) was shot down by Tigrian forces. The text which is written in Amharic reads “…. an Ethiopian fighter jet was shot by Tigray special [police] force during the ongoing war in Qola Tenben, Tigray…” However, Haqcheck interrogated the case and confirmed that the picture doesn’t show an Ethiopian fighter jet shot by Tigray special police force during the ongoing conflict, and rated it FALSE due to the usage of an inaccurate image to support the claim.

Since 4 November 2020 there has been armed fighting between the TPLF-led regional forces and Federal government-led forces in Tigray. The federal government has controlled the regional capital city, Mekelle on 28 November 2020. It has also recently announced that it was rapidly capturing senior civil and military officers of the TPLF. Some of the senior civil and military leaders of the TPLF-led force have also been arrested. But instabilities remain in the region during the post-conflict period.

It is in this context that the post was shared by the user making strong allegations that a fighter jet was shot by TPLF-led forces during the recent conflict in Qola Tenben, Tigray. However a reverse image search of the picture used in the post doesn’t prove the claim. The image was first published on 16 September 2017 on ScanNews, an Iranian digital newspaper. The newspaper used the image in a story of  a Russian-made US fighter jet  crash during a test flight in Nevada, USA. However, it didn’t say anything about the image whether it shows the mentioned crash or not. The original post can be accessed with the following link.

Granted, there are claims by the government the war is over and former TPLF leaders are indeed being captured at the time the facebook post was shared. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the image doesn’t show an Ethiopian fighter jet shot by Tigray forces recently during the current conflict and therefore rated it as FALSE due to the usage of an inaccurate image.

Fact Checked by: Hagos Gebreamlak

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking running in five languages (Affan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English)

Does the image show PM Abiy Ahmed is ill and being treated in hospital?

On 24 January 2020 a facebook post by the name Taajudin Ahamadi (a facebook account with 3,953 friends) shared the image below with the claim that Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (PhD) is seriously ill and is being treated in the hospital. The post came out amid the ongoing speculation about the prime minister’s whereabouts and about his safety and so far 28 users had shared it. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the image doesn’t show PM Abiy Ahmed ill and being treated in hospital, therefore rating it ALTERED.

There have been many speculations about the wellbeing and whereabouts of the Ethiopian PM, Abiy Ahmed in recent times.  Some have speculated that the PM is seriously ill with others claiming that he is even deceased. But the Prime Minister Office announced that the speculations about the PM’s safety are false. Amid these unconfirmed speculations on 28 January 2021 the prime minister was seen visiting the prosthetics production for injured soldiers and civilians.

In this context the facebook post emerged claiming the prime minister is ill and he is being treated in a hospital. However, a google reverse image search of the picture doesn’t prove the claim. The image was first published on Gofundme, an internet-based platform for fundraising with information that the image is of a dead body of Bidhan Thapa, a person who died in the USA due to cardiac arrest at the  John Hopkins Hospital on 10 July, 2017 (over two years before the post was published).  The image of the dead body was posted to collect funds to help Bidhan Thapa’s wife, Priscilla Rai. The original post related to the image can be accessed with the following link.

Doctored Image

Original Image

Granted, there have been allegations about the wellbeing of PM Abiy Ahmed in recent times. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the image doesn’t show the Ethiopian PM ill and being treated in a hospital, therefore giving it the rating ALTERED due to inaccurate usage of the image.

Fact Checked by: Hagos Gebreamlak

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking initiative, which is run by its R&D Department.

Has there been a car accident killing 39 people in Dejen woreda on 21 January?

On 21 Jan 2021, a person named Bruck Aynalem posted on a Facebook group called የጨዋዎች ግሩፕ (yechewawoch group), (a Facebook public group with more than 142,000 members) saying that there’s been a car accident in Amhara region and 39 people died. The post which was written in Amharic reads “…A bus carrying 65 people going from Addis Ababa to Bahir Dar overturned, killing 39 people. The accident took place at 5:35 today(21 Jan 2021) in the Amhara region; Dejen district; the bus entered a 50-meter-deep cliff near Balbele Kebele. The deceased’s identities are unknown and their bodies are at Dejen Referral Hospital…”. The post has also been circulating in different other Facebook groups and shared by many people. HaqCheck has interrogated the post and rated it False due to the inaccuracy of the image and the facts used in the post.

Granted, Ethiopia is one of the countries in the world with high rates of car accidents. During the last fiscal year (2019/20), 4,133 people died because of traffic accidents across the country. Traffic accidents are a serious problem in the country in general and this also true in the Amhara Regional State. 

However, Addis Zeybe has contacted the Amhara region road and transport bureau, public relation expert, and confirmed that there has been no car accident on 21 January 2021 in Dejen Woreda that killed 39 people. “The Facebook post is very far from true,” the Public relations expert said.  As stated on Facebook post the deceased’s bodies are in Dejen referral hospital, which was confirmed by Addis Zeybe that the woreda has no referral hospital and the nearest referral hospital is found in Debre Markos which is 61.5 km far from Dejen.

Also, a reverse image search of the picture posted to support the claim shows that the picture was taken on 17 March 2019 during the funeral of the Boeing 737 MAX 8 crash victims, the plane crashed shortly after taking off heading to Nairobi, Kenya, killing all 157 people on board on 10 March 2019. The picture is found with other photos from the funeral. 

In conclusion, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the Facebook post claiming that there’s been a car accident in Amhara region, Dejen woreda, killing 39 people and the deceased’s bodies are found in Dejen referral hospital is False due to the usage of inaccurate information. 

Fact Checked by: Rehobot Ayalew

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking running in five languages (Affan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English)

Does the image show Egyptian troops came and deployed in Sudan?

On 20 January 2021 a Facebook post by the name Afmeer tv. (a page with 235,531 followers) shared an image that shows numerous military vehicles with soldiers with the claim that 5,000 Egyptian troops came to Sudan and have deployed to the border areas sharing an image that doesn’t prove the claim. The text which is written in Somali reads “Sudanese news outlets reported that 5,000 Egyptian soldiers came to support the Sudanese army. More than 3,000 Sudanese troops also are marching around the Sudan-Eritrea borders and the situation is worsening.” However, HaqCheck has interrogated the claim and confirmed that the image below doesn’t show 5,000 Egyptian troops that reached Sudan and deployed along the Ethio-Sudanese border. Therefore, HaqCheck has rendered the post as FALSE due to the usage of an inaccurate image to support the claim.

Granted, there have been armed clashes around the Ethio-Sudanese border since recently. Egypt condemned the attack by the Ethiopian armed forces and militias against the Sudanese army along the border terming the attack as an ‘unjustified assault’. Egypt ensured its full solidarity with Sudan and its support of the country’s right to protect its territory. There have also been reports that Sudan has sent more troops to the border areas as tensions rise.

It is in this context that the image was shared claiming 5,000 Egyptian soldiers came to Sudan. However, a reverse image search of the picture used in the Facebook post doesn’t show Egyptian troops recently reached Sudan and deployed along the Sudanese borders. The image was first posted on Ahram Online on 14 February 2018 and shows a military operation in the Sinai desert against terrorists and criminal cliques. Ahram Online borrowed the image from Egypt’s Ministry of Defense. The original post related to the image can be with the following link.

It is true that the border dispute between Sudan and Ethiopia has recently risen with Sudan reportedly deploying more soldiers to the border areas. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the claim and confirmed that the image below doesn’t show Egyptian troops who came to Sudan and deployed along the border, therefore, rendering the post as FALSE due to the usage of an inaccurate image to support the claim.

 

Fact Checked by Hagos Gebreamlak

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

This article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact-checking initiative, which is run by its R&D Department.

 

Does the image show Eritrean troops who partook and died in Tigray during the ongoing conflict?

On 12 January 2020 a facebook post by the name ካብ ሕልሚ ዝነቕሐ ሰብ (a facebook page with 6,551 followers) shared the image below with the claim that many Eritrean soldiers had been killed in Tigray during the ongoing armed conflict sharing an inaccurate image to support the claim. The post adds that many Eritrean troops have been crossing the Ethio-Eritrean boundary to support the Ethiopian army. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the image doesn’t show Eritrean soldiers involved and killed during the ongoing armed conflict in Tigray and rated it as FALSE.

Since 4 November 2020 there has been armed fighting between TPLF-led regional forces and Federal government-led forces in Tigray. There have also been claims that the Eritrean army has been involved in the ongoing military operation in Tigray supporting the Ethiopian federal government.

In this context the facebook post emerged claiming that several Eritrean soldiers who were involved in the armed conflict in Tigray have been killed. However, a google reverse image search of the picture shows that the image doesn’t support the claim. The image was first published on InfoMigrants, a web based news outlet in 09/08/2019 in an article that Eritrea’s military conscription had forced many to migrate. The original post related to the image can be accessed with the following link.

Granted, there have been allegations and unproven claims of Eritrean army involvement in the war supporting the Ethiopian army. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the image doesn’t show Eritrean troops involved and killed during the ongoing armed conflict in Tigray, therefore rating the post as FALSE due to inaccurate usage of the image.

Fact Checked by: Hagos Gebreamlak

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking initiative, which is run by its R&D Department.

Did 39.8 billion cyber attacks were exerted on Ethio Telecom? 

As the conflict between the Ethiopian National Defence Forces and TPLF led Tigray Special Police and Militia broke out on November 4, 2020, there were disruptions with regards to electricity, banking and telecom connectivity for nearly over a month. This made it hard to communicate and widened the information gap in the country. Families were separated, people couldn’t get in touch with one another, there was no banking service. Overall it was a very difficult situation for people who lived in tigray as well as for those who have family and relatives there.

After the ENDF controlled the capital, Mekelle, on 28 November 2020 there have been efforts to restore these basic amenities and the damages on the phone and internet services. In a statement made on 2 December 2020 Ethiotelecom stated that the telecom service had partially resumed in six towns – namely Maykadra, Shiraro, Humera, Dansha, Turkan and Maytsebri. The telecom service providers also added that telecom services were fully resumed in Alamata. Again on 12 December  2020, it was also announced that the country’s sole telecom service provider – Ethiotelecom – had managed to restore mobile voice service in Mekele and Maychew.

At a press conference on 10 December 2020, Frehiwot Tamre (CEO, Ethio telecom), said there has been infrastructural damages on the telecom system and there is evidence regarding the perpetrators of the attack. Frehiwot also added that over 39.8 billion separate cyber attacks – an assault launched by cybercriminals using one or more computers against a single or multiple computers or networks in order to steal, alter, or destroy a specified target by targeting into a susceptible system – were attempted in 14 days from 25 November to 07 December 2020, averaging 2.8 billion attacks everyday. These attacks mainly targeted the assets of the government, the education system, the banking and telecom systems as well as the broadcasting and media infrastructures, according to the Chief Executive Officer of Ethiopia, Frehiwot Tamre.  

As mentioned in the press conference the attacks were mainly DDoS attacks (distributed denial of service attack) – a malicious attempt to disrupt the normal traffic of a targeted server, service or network by overwhelming the target or its surrounding infrastructure with a flood of Internet traffic. These DDoS attacks were over 14 billion in number and in addition to an attempt to get illegal mobile voice service from 20 November – 30 November 2020 in some parts of Mekelle. Those data were discovered from the log file – a file that records either events that occur in an operating system or other software runs, or messages between different users of a communication software – located in Mekelle core site where the transmission and the power distributors were shut off. 

As Hiskias Dingeto- (Cyber Security expert, P.H.D Dongguk South Korea ) explains the DDoS attacks are not just separate attacks but rather botnets (zombies)- a software application that runs automated tasks over the internet. Typically, these “zombies” perform tasks that are simple and repetitive – requests to create a jam (traffic) to the server because every server has a limited capacity to run in a given time. Ergo, these attacks will send data that is beyond the capacity of the servers affecting the ability of the telecom to provide undisturbed telecom services. However, according to Hiskias, the log is prone to registering these repetitive attacks as separate ones. That is why the number is the billions according to the cyber security expert.

One of the Information System professionals and a Cyber security specialist Addis Zeybe talked to – who choose to remain anonymous – also adds that the DDoS attack may be a redundancy, because such botnets or zombies can be programmed to attack automatically and the attacker may not need to create different kinds of zombies again and again. But labeling it as 14 billion attacks in 14 days is a little shady as the yearly statistics shows, it’s not even close to a billion annually.

Another anonymous Cyber Security expert also said that there is a very big chance these kinds of attacks could happen especially on organizations like Ethio telecom which is system based. He also adds that any person can try to attack whether the internet connection is poor or not but the chance to succeed may be very low. And when the log file registers every attempt and event it also records the severity of the attack, type of the attack, target of the attack and every detail about every attack.

According to an article published on December 14, 2020 by Cyber Security Intelligence (a news website focusing on cyber security and intelligence), a security researcher and a white-hat hacker named Sisay Sorsa has recently found a critical security flaw on Ethiopia’s Ethio Telecom servers that makes it possible for a hacker to control the entire Ethiopian GSM communication system. At the time the Sisay – who is working as a cyber researcher and white hat hacker – told CSI that he was able to access the system of Ethiopia’s sole telecom provider after writing a python program in an effort to demonstrate the flaws in the security system of the telecom service provider. At the time Sisay had expressed intentions to support the Ethiopian Telecommunication Corporation patch up these key vulnerabilities despite not receiving response from the Ethiopian Information Network Security Agency until the date the above article was published by CSI.

 

Does the image show a donkey looted by Eritreans from Tigray?

On 10 January 2020 a facebook post by the name World Page (a facebook page with 39,253 followers) shared the image below with the claim that the donkey in the minivan was looted by Eritreans from Tigray. The post came out amid the ongoing military operation and following instability in Tigray and it points to a license plate [Eritrean] of the minivan in an effort to show the donkey was stolen by Eritreans. The post became viral on facebook and at the time this article was written around 45 users had shared it. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the image doesn’t show a donkey looted by Eritreans from Tigray and rated it as ALTERED.

Since 4 November 2020 there have been armed fighting between TPLF-led regional forces and Federal government-led forces in Tigray. The federal government also recently announced that it was rapidly capturing senior civil and military officers of the TPLF. Amid the military operation and instabilities there have been allegations and unproven reports that Eritrean troops have been involved in the war supporting Prime Minister  Abiy Ahmed’s administration. Additionally , many claim that Eritrean soldiers are looting in Tigray amid the war.

In this context the facebook post emerged claiming the donkey was robbed by Eritreans from Tigray. However, a google reverse image search of the picture doesn’t prove the claim. The image was first published on Reddit, an American internet-based image and video sharing platform and social media aggregation with a text “This donkey getting a ride home in a minivan” on 24 August 2019. The original post related to the image can be accessed with the following link.

Doctored Image

Original Image

Granted, there have been allegations and unproven claims of Eritrean army involvement in the war and lootings amid the conflict in Tigray at the time the facebook post was shared. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the image doesn’t show a donkey looted by Eritreans from Tigray and being taken to Eritrea in a minivan, therefore, rated as ALTERED due to inaccurate usage of the image.

Fact Checked by: Hagos Gebreamlak

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking initiative, which is run by its R&D Department.

Does the image show Ethiopian soldiers entering Tigray during the current military operation?

On January 8, 2020 a facebook post was made by the name ደሃይ ውቅሮን ትግራይን (a personal blog with 1,934 followers) sharing the image below that shows trucks loaded with many troops and some people along the road a claim that they are soldiers of the National Defence Forces who were entering to Tigray as an additional deployment for the ongoing military operation against the TPLF-led forces. The text which is written in Tigrinya reads “ Please share this urgent information so that the Tigray Defence Forces can see it. [Abiy Ahmed] is sending many trucks loaded with soldiers to urban centers of Tigray.” However, Haqcheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the picture below doesn’t show Ethiopian troops who were recently sent to Tigray, rendering the post FALSE due to the usage of an inaccurate image to support the claim.

Granted, there has been an armed conflict currently ongoing in the Tigray region between the Federal government and the TPLF led Tigray special police and militia since 4 November 2020. After nearly three weeks of fighting in the region, it was confirmed that the ENDF led Federal forces had assumed control of major cities in Tigray including Mekele, Shire, Adigrat, Axum and others. Recently the ENDF and Federal Police force in joint operation have killed and captured higher civil and military leaders of the TPLF-led forces including Sibhat Nega on January 08 and Abay Weldu, former Tigray regional president on january 10, 2020. 

It is in this context that the image was shared claiming the many troops are entering Tigray as an additional deployment against the TPLF-led regional forces. However, a reverse image search of the picture used in the facebook post doesn’t show soldiers of the Ethiopian Defence Force that were going to Tigray during the recent military operation. The image was first posted on The World, an American digital media website on 17 May 2017 with information that the troops in the picture were Ethiopian soldiers who were passing on its way to the frontline at Zalambessa during the Ethio-Eritrean war on June 11, 1998. The original article related to the image can be with the following link.

It is true that there have been battles and instabilities between the Federal army-led and TPLF-led regional forces in Tigray. However, HaqCheck has interogetted the claim and confirmed that the image below doesn’t show Ethiopian troops entering Tigray as a fresh deployment during the ongoing military operation, therefore, ratinging the post as FALSE due to the usage of an inaccurate image to support the claim.

Fact Checked by: Hagos Gebreamlak

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking running in five languages (Affan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English)

Does the image show traffic being back to normal in Mekelle city?

On 12 January 2020 a facebook post by the Ethiopian Press Agency/The Ethiopian Herald (a facebook page with 39,253 followers) shared the image below with the claim that traffic is back to normal in Mekelle. It interviewed Ataklti Haileselassie, interim mayor of Mekelle city before stating that traffic has been restored following the arrest news of senior TFLF leaders. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the image doesn’t show traffic returning back to normal in Mekele rating it as FALSE.

Since 4 November 2020 there has been armed fighting between the TPLF-led regional forces and Federal government-led forces in Tigray. The federal government has controlled the regional capital city, Mekelle on December 28, 2020. It has also recently announced that it was rapidly capturing senior civil and military officers of the TPLF. Some of the senior civil and military leaders of the TPLF-led force have also been arrested. It is also true that upon controlling the capital of Tigray on 28 November 2020, Ataklti Hailesillase was appointed as the interim mayor of Mekele by the Provisional Interim Government of Tigray.

In this context, the facebook post by the state news outlet emerged claiming traffic has returned to normal following the capture of senior TPLF leaders. However, a google reverse image search of the picture doesn’t show the scenes in Mekelle. To the contrary the picture was taken 15 years ago. The image which depicts a street in the heart of the city was taken in Mekelle city on 12 March 2006 and first published on Wikimedia Commons, an online file-sharing platform on 17 January 2007. The original post related to the image can be accessed with the following link.

Granted, there are claims by the government the war is over and former TPLF leaders are indeed being captured at the time the facebook post was shared. However, HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed that the image doesn’t show traffic being back to normal in Mekelle city and therefore rated it as FALSE due to the usage of an inaccurate image.

Fact Checked by: Hagos Gebreamlak

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking initiative, which is run by its R&D Department.

Does the picture show Ethiopian soldier that captured Italian troops?

A facebook post emerged on 4 January 2020 by a facebook page named African Full Facts. (with over 88,000 followers) claiming that the picture in the post shows Ethiopian soldiers that captured  Italians troops. The post reads “When a hunter becomes a prey & when the invaders become captured. An Ethiopian soldier and his Italian war captives during the invasion of Italians in Ethiopia.” HaqCheck interrogated the post and rated it as False.

 

In an era of European expansion, history shows that Italian interest in East Africa dates from 1869. The battle of Adwa broke out  mainly due to the difference in the translation of article XVII of the Wichale treaty, signed on 2 May 1889, between Ethiopia and Italy. In 1895 the Italian force led by General Oreste Baratieri was reluctant to attack the Ethiopian army in the open field. Menilik’s (Emperor of Ethiopia at the time) force, traditional warriors, farmers and pastoralists as well as women, defeated the well-armed Italian army in 1896. The defeat led to a change of government in Italy, due to public protest and failure of his colonial policy, Prime Minister Francesco Crispi resigned. Ethiopia became a symbol of freedom for black people globally and the victory served as the model for future anti-colonial efforts.

Despite the claims of the post, however, a reverse image search of the picture in the post shows that the picture was taken during the Second World War and it shows an African American soldier guarding German prisoners in 1945. The photo is also found in the National archive of the United States of America along with other photos.

Granted the Ethiopian army defeated the Italian during the battle of Adwa in 1896, However HaqCheck has interrogated the post and confirmed the picture that is used to support the claim is not actually related to the battle of Adwa, therefore rated the post False due to the inaccuracy of the picture.

 

Fact Checked by: Rehobot Ayalew

Edited by: Bruck Negash Teame

The following article is part of HaqCheck, Addis Zeybe’s multilingual fact checking running in five languages (Affan Oromo, Amharic, Somali, Tigrinya and English)

Exit mobile version