Fact Checks

September: week three disinformation trend summary

In the following summary, we cover major disinformation trends observed to prevail in the third week of September along with important recommendations.

“The video claiming to show a military operation in the Afar front”

One of the claims in this week of September is a video asserting to show the Ethiopian military and Afar heroes killing and chasing away TPLF forces.

The social media post claims that the Ethiopian military force and Afar Heroes are chasing away and expelling TPLF forces from a town in Afar.

HaqCheck checked the video and found that it was taken from a military engagement between the Saudi-led forces and Yemen forces in the Jizan axis, Saudi Arabia border, on May 29. Hence, it is confirmed that the video doesn’t show the operation in the Afar front.

Haqcheck, therefore, rendered the post as False due to its appeal to a wrong video to prove the claim.

Controversies over the destroyed Tekeze Bridge 

Social media platforms, mainly Facebook and Twitter, last week were overwhelmed with posts over claims of the destroyed bridge on the Tekeze River.

Controversies heated up between pro-Government and those on the TPLF sides, blaming each other for the damage.

The state-owned news outlet, Ethiopian Broadcasting Corporate shared a news report saying TPLF has demolished the Tekeze Bridge linking the towns of Addis Zemen, Ibnat, and Amdework.

On the other hand, different people tweeted and shared posts accusing the Ethiopian National Defence Force and Amhara forces, of destroying the bridge on the Tekeze River.

It was reported previously that another bridge on the other side of the Tekeze river was also destroyed and the news was similarly controversial. 

“A false image used to show the Ethiopian Air Force in operation”

An image was shared on Facebook claiming to show the Ethiopian Air Force in action. Even though the claim was shared a week before, we observed that it has still been circulating this week. Haqcheck has analyzed the image and obtained a YouTube video posted on June 15, 2017, that contains the exact image posted by the Facebook page.  The image is taken from a YouTube video showing NATO forces conducting military training in Romania. The post has been rendered false due to its use of the wrong image to support the claim.

A false advertisement on Facebook

Another misinformative piece that grabbed our attention this week was a sponsored post on Facebook. Analyzing the message of the post and the logo it used, we could learn that the page had been impostering a reputed organization, Ethio Telecom. Imposter content is one of the types of disinformation used to deceive and mislead users. The post offers prizes including “free 100 GB and iPhones”. It also has an invitation to click on a link that doesn’t actually open.

Such kinds of sponsored or boosted posts are paid advertisements with the privilege of posting the desired message in a text, image, or video. Facebook reviews the post’s appropriateness according to its advertising policies. Despite the fact that misinformation is one of the prohibited intents to be advertised according to the review policies, Facebook could be said to be irresponsible to approve a post that misinforms the public by impostering a well established public organization to the wider audience. 

Recommendations 

No matter what the intention is, social media influencers, activists and public figures should be careful about the information they share and be more alert in choosing a trustable information outlet and act responsibly in whatever content they share. 

People are advised to be well aware of the social media landscape; disinformation trends, identify the right pages and media and take time to understand the intention and credibility of the message they are consuming and sharing.

As a fact checking initiative based in Ethiopia, we call upon giant social media platforms like Facebook to give due attention, responsibility and respect to users from different countries, languages and cultures and work with local initiatives that understand the Ethiopian context and media landscape better.

—————————————————————————————————————————————————–

HaqCheck is a local multilingual fact-checking project based in Ethiopia, formed inside Addis Zeybe’s newsroom, now Inform Africa’s Counter Disinformation Project – a board-led Civil Society Organization (CSO) – dedicated to verifying media contents from social to the mainstream. HaqCheck works in collaboration with media outlets to monitor media contents in English and four local languages (Amharic, Afaan Oromo, Tigrigna, and Somali).

This report is produced with the support of UNESCO under the #CoronavirusFacts: Addressing the ‘Disinfodemic’ on COVID-19 in conflict-prone Environments that the UNESCO Addis Ababa Office is implementing in Ethiopia with financial support from the European Union (EU). The designations employed and the presentation of material throughout this publication do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNESCO or the EU concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city, or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The ideas and opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of UNESCO or The European Union and do not commit these organizations in any way.

FALSE: the image does not show the Ethiopian Air Force in action

A Facebook page with more than 100 thousand followers posted two similar images on September 12  with an explanatory phrase claiming, “ the Ethiopian air force in action”.

The post had been shared more than 163 times including different public groups until the time this article was published. 

However, HaqCheck looked into the credibility of the images and finally rated the post as False.

This post is among misinformative images that had been circulating across social media following the ongoing armed conflict between the Ethiopian federal government and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) since November 2020. Given some claims that the Ethiopian Air Force is backing up the battle in Tigray, and its employment of modern drones, the Air Force happened to become a center of attention.

However, a reverse image search of the picture led to a youtube video posted on June 15, 2017. The video entitled “how quickly can the nato forces react?  Military exercise in Romania with NATO VJTF “ has more than 15 million views. The footage shows a military training named “Exercise noble jump 17” held in Romania.

Hence, though there are various reports claiming military operations are being held on TPLF, the image doesn’t actually show the Ethiopian Air Force in action, making the post to be rated as False.

False: The video doesn’t show military operation in the Afar front

Video circulating on Facebook since September 17 posted by a page with more than 35,000 followers, reports, “We have received a video showing Afar heroes and the defense force expelling TPLF…” By the time this article is published the post has been shared more than 3800 times. 

However, the video in the Facebook post doesn’t show the claimed operation in the Afar front, and the post is rendered False.

On November 4, 2020, armed fighting started between TPLF and Federal Government forces in Tigray. In the ensuing conflict, the federal army has controlled major areas in Tigray, but there have been reports of armed battles and guerilla attacks in the region. 

Late last month the Ethiopian government, following a request from the Tigray Interim Administration, declared a sudden unilateral ceasefire with the supposition of its concern over humanitarian issues and immediately withdrew its forces from the mainlands of the regional state.

After the federal forces left the region, the TPLF-forces rebranded themselves as Tigray Defense Forces (TDF), taking control of urban centers of the regional state.

The TPLF-forces have been advancing southwards and southeast, moving out of the heartlands of Tigray. Recently armed clashes have been reported in border areas adjacent to Tigray, such as Amhara and Afar regional states.

The Facebook post was circulating amid this situation.

However, a reverse image search of screenshots from the video shows the video was neither from Ethiopia nor shows a recent incident. The footage found shows an operation between the Saudi-led forces and Yemen forces in the Jizan axis, Saudi Arabia border, on May 29.

The footage

Given the result of the aforementioned analysis, the post claiming to show an operation in the Afar front is rendered False.

September: week two disinformation trend summary

False Images

‘Heavy artillery shelling in Mekelle’

One of the claims that appeared during the first week of this September alleges that gunshots were heard accompanied by heavy artillery shelling in Mekelle, Tigray regional capital.

The social media post claims that the sound of the shooting was heard as far as Abala town of the Afar region, approximately 49 Km from Mekelle. The post used an image in a bid to support or prove the claim.

HaqCheck looked into the image and found that the image was taken from an old social media publication and confirmed that the picture doesn’t show heavy artillery shelling in Mekelle. 

As HaqCheck previously interrogated, a reverse image search of the image that is used in the post revealed that the picture was first published by VOA Amharic on November 16, 2020. The report stated that an airstrike was carried out in Mekelle town, at which one person was killed and some houses were burnt down.

HaqCheck, therefore, convicted the post as FALSE due to its appeal to an old image to prove the claim.

‘Demonstration in Mekelle’

The other social media claim, fact-checked by HaqCheck, was that there was a public protest in Mekelle. The Facebook post claimed that people in Mekelle protested against the Tigray People’s Liberation Movement (TPLF) saying that they could no longer tolerate the rule of the TPLF.

The post used three images to support the claim that seemingly shows road blockades, public protest, and some public gatherings.

HaqCheck interrogated the images in an effort to fact-check the claim and found that the pictures used in the post don’t show protests recently undertaken against TPLF.

The first image in the post was not found. However, the second and the third pictures utilized to support the claim were taken from previous social media posts. The second image is of Mekelle residents safeguarding their neighborhoods some ten months ago during the armed conflict between forces loyal to the TPLF and Ethiopian Federal government-led forces.

The third cropped picture in the Facebook post shows a protest in Abuja, Nigeria on October 30, 2018.

Therefore, HaqCheck concluded that the Facebook post was FALSE due to the fact that it used inaccurate images to prove the claim.

‘Scams’

Last week scams appeared on social media that used the names and logos of globally known companies and were being circulated across social media platforms. HaqCheck found that the scams were sent through inboxes with automatic links. 

The messages sent indicate that people who fill out the prepared forms would be nominated for awards. This is one of the ways in which scammers extract people’s personal information and use it for various purposes. HaqCheck has noticed that the messages have similar contents and has warned users.

“Wollo starvation”

There have been different fundraising campaigns for people affected by the war in Tigray around North Wollo. However, while activists and social media influencers were spreading the news and joining the campaign, we have noticed that a couple of false images were used.  

The first image was actually taken from a fire accident that happened in Wolaita, in December 2020.

The other picture was taken on September 20, 2011, showing a child affected by malnutrition in Somalia. 

Recommendations

Social media influencers and activists should be careful about the information they share with their followers. Even if it is for good intentions they should not misinform the public and need to correct their mistakes at the time they learn about them.

The public should be aware of the disinformation trend and be cautious about what they consume from social media. Cross checking the information from different sources and trying to get information from relatively credible media is recommended. 
 
Regarding scams, when social media users receive such messages and automatic links they should refrain from giving their private information because it can be used for potential scams. 

HaqCheck recommends that social media users should basically look for information from credible and original sources before sharing or consuming such claims. They consider checking out official statements, updates, and clarifications from authorities on such controversial issues. For more recommendations about scams, you can read here.

—————————————————————————————————————————————————–

HaqCheck is a local multilingual fact-checking project based in Ethiopia, formed inside Addis Zeybe’s newsroom, now Inform Africa’s Counter Disinformation Project – a board-led Civil Society Organization (CSO) – dedicated to verifying media contents from social to the mainstream. HaqCheck works in collaboration with media outlets to monitor media contents in English and four local languages (Amharic, Afaan Oromo, Tigrigna, and Somali).

This report is produced with the support of UNESCO under the #CoronavirusFacts: Addressing the ‘Disinfodemic’ on COVID-19 in conflict-prone Environments that the UNESCO Addis Ababa Office is implementing in Ethiopia with financial support from the European Union (EU). The designations employed and the presentation of material throughout this publication do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNESCO or the EU concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city, or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The ideas and opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of UNESCO or The European Union and do not commit these organizations in any way.

True: Debub Global Bank is offering prizes for Telegram users

As we have connoted in our previous fact-checking publication, some Telegram channels and groups had been intending to deceive users in the name of different prominent banks offering people attractive prizes on the condition that they join their channels and share the links to a number of people. HaqCheck clarified these claims and rendered them as Hoax. 

We have been requested by our audiences to look into a Telegram channel with the same content of offering prizes. The channel’s Amharic post published in the name of Debub Global Bank reads, “our bank is offering prizes on the occasion of Ethiopian new year with the supposition of motivating Telegram channels, an opportunity open until Oct 11, 2021.” 

The post has been watched by more than 52,700 people up until this article is published. Unlike the previous misleading Telegram hoaxes, HaqCheck confirmed that the messages are actually from the bank.

The post listed four different prizes. The first prize being modern mobile phones for three lucky winners, there are lists of other prizes such as  DSTv decoder with a one month package, Golden membership account of the bank, and daily mobile air time of 100 ETB. In order to qualify for the prizes, people are reminded to join the channel and invite more than 50 people following the shared link. 

In an effort to ratify the claim, HaqCheck spoke to Temesgen Fekadu, an officer in the marketing department of Debub Global Bank.“ Telegram Channel is real. We provided different prizes for Telegram users including 100 airtime packages, mobile devices, and DSTv decoders. The opportunity is open for members of the channels until the deadline” he explained.

HaqCheck also reached out to  Asnake Worku, Marketing and Brand Officer of the bank. He also confirmed that the prize offer is real. Moreover, we have called to different branches of the bank to find out that all the information we had from the bank is in accord.

Therefore, the Telegram messages offering new year prizes in the name of  Debub Global Bank are confirmed to be True. 

False: the images do not show a recent demonstration in Mekelle

A Facebook page that has more than 60,000 followers published a post with a compilation of images on September 14. The post states that people of Mekelle are in resistance saying, “We had enough! We don’t tolerate the Junta (referring to TPLF) anymore! We don’t know the whereabouts of our children, while those alive are coming back losing their limbs”. The images attached to the post show road blockades, demonstrating people clashing with security forces, and dwellers gathering on streets in surprise.

However, the images are found to be inaccurate and are rated as False.

The ongoing  Tigray conflict between the Ethiopian federal forces and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) since November 2020 had various social repercussions. One of the issues that were tremendously focused on by the international community and the media was TPLF’s use of child soldiers on the front line of active battles

Basically triggered by the story published in The New York Times and other similar allegations, it was reported that TPLF is conscripting child soldiers into fresh battles. Interviews of supposedly captured child soldiers were also aired on Ethiopian national television. Over the past few months, different false information had been emerging regarding the subject, including the one debunked by HaqCheck and this Facebook post.

However, a reverse image search of the pictures shows that they are not related to the incident reported by the post. While the first image can not be found from any source in our investigation, the other two were actually taken at different times and places. 

The Second Image

The second image can be found in a Tweet from December 3, 2020. The caption reads “…People of Mekelle are out in the streets blocking all roads & confronting the armed Eritrean troops & Amhara militias…”

The Third Image

The third image was taken during a protest in Abuja, Nigeria, by Reuters reporter Abraham Achirga, on October 30, 2018. It is found attached in a news article entitled “Nigeria police fire on Shi’ite march, kill protester-group” alongside other pictures from the incident. 

It is apparently clear that the image in the Facebook post is also cropped out from the original one.

Therefore, due to its usage of inaccurate images, the post is rated as False.

False: the image doesn’t show a recent heavy artillery shelling in Mekelle

A Facebook page with more than 11 thousand followers shared an image on September 8 saying that gunshots were heard accompanied by heavy artillery shelling in Mekelle. The post also adds that the shooting was audible as far as Abala town of the Afar region, approximately 49 Km from Mekelle. 

However, the image is found to be inaccurate and the post is rated as False.

The Ethiopian federal government has been at war with the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) since November 2020 following TPLF’s alleged attack on the Ethiopian National Defence Forces’(ENDF) northern command. After three weeks of armed conflict, the federal government occupied the regional capital, Mekelle, and most parts of the regional state. Sustaining an eight-month prolonged war with TPLF, the Ethiopian government announced its decision to withdraw troops from the region and declared a unilateral ceasefire. 

As the ENDF confirmed its withdrawal from the region, the TPLF  claimed to have regained control of the regional capital on 28 June 2021. The saga of the conflict had continued spilling over to the neighboring Afar and Amhara regional states. The Facebook post has been shared in the context of this narrative, putting forward its claim of shootings and artillery shelling. Nevertheless, a reverse image search of the picture revealed that the image was first published in a report by VOA Amharic on November 16, 2020. The report stated that an airstrike was carried out in Mekele town, at which one person is killed and some houses were burnt down.

Therefore, the Facebook post’s claim of gunshots and heavy artillery shelling in Mekele is rated False, given its use of an inaccurate image to support the claim. 

HaqCheck Re-established Under a New Identity

HaqCheck is re-established under a new corporate identity and social media platforms and will operate independently under a civil society association called Inform Africa. One of the pioneering initiatives of countering disinformation in Ethiopia, HaqCheck has been working on fact-checking projects under Addis Zeybe Digital Media, publishing its productions in English and four other local languages. 

The re-establishment is necessitated with the supposition of creating its own distinctive identity, increasing its visibility, engaging & building its own audience more profoundly, and realizing its vision of being one of the significant fact-checking and media literacy initiatives in the country and the region at large. 

First established under Addis Zeybe digital media, HaqCheck had been monitoring and verifying false information from social and mainstream media. It has been undertaking fact-checking work for the past 10 months, during which time it has published over 200 fact-checked articles and analyses, in English and four local languages (Amharic, Afaan Oromo, Tigrinya, and Somali). 

Despite a previous in-existence of fact-checking discipline, and professional training in the Ethiopian media landscape, HaqCheck has managed to build the professionalism of its team and maintain standards in its works. 

In addition to the periodical fact-checking articles, HaqCheck prepares weekly and monthly disinformation/ misinformation trend summaries apparent in the media landscape coupled with recommendations aimed at countering disinformation. The fact-checking publication content is also discussed in the weekly video presentation on YouTube. 

Hence, starting from the Ethiopian new year, Sep 11, 2021, HaqCheck will be operating with its new corporate identity under Inform Africa, while being an affiliate of Addis Zeybe Digital Media. Its fact-checking works will be published on its own Facebook, Twitter, and Telegram social media platforms.  

We would like to call on our partners, stakeholders, the media community, and our audience to follow us on our new platforms and maintain their professional partnership in the remarkable work of countering disinformation. 

HaqCheck social media links 

facebook.com/HaqCheck

twitter.com/HaqCheck 

t.me/HaqCheck 

For further information, please contact 

Rehobot Ayalew

Lead Fact-checker 

E-mail: haqcheck@gmail.com 
           : rehobot.ay@gmail.com

 

Fact Checked Hoaxes and Other Disinformation Trends

In the following summary, we cover major disinformation trends observed to prevail in the first week of September along with important recommendations.

False Images

One of the issues that had been circulating on social media platforms, mainly Facebook, was a post saying “the Ethiopian and Israeli air forces agreed to work together in order to keep the regional peace”. The content, which was shared on August 31, 2021, had been backed with a compilation of five images in a bid to support the claim.

Nevertheless, a reverse image search of the pictures revealed that the images were not related to the specific issue.

The first two images were taken on October 3, 2019, while a Casa CN235 and Mirage 2000-5 fighter aircraft of French landed at Dire Dawa airport. While the third image taken 7 years ago is noted to show a former Ethiopian Air Force pilot who defected to Canada in 2003, the fourth image, back from July 22, 2008, is noticed to be used in a number of online sources that attached different stories to it, making it arbitrary to identify the right story behind the picture.

Image 1 & 2

Image 3

Image 4

Hence, analyzing the pictures and relating their identity with the story they are referenced to, HaqCheck has rendered the post False.

Hoaxes

The other disinformation trend that had been happening this week was an enormous viral circulation of hoax Telegram messages. Though the Telegram messages had been disseminated in different channels with the name of different organizations, they have similarities in nature. The channels are created in the names and branding identity of Commercial bank of Ethiopia, Abay bank, and Amhara bank. The Amharic text messages sent via Telegram offer people attractive prizes on the condition that they join their channels and share the messages with others. 

In this way, the messages try to lure people by listing five different attractive prizes ranging from the first prize of a 300,00 Br three-wheeler vehicle to be awarded for 200 winners along with a package of housewares worth 50,000 Br each to the last offer of 5,000 Br for 100 people and a number of smartphone prizes. However, the posts remind people to comply with its instructions in order to qualify for the prizes: joining the channel and inviting more than 50 people by following the shared link. 

However, it was confirmed, from the website of CBE and Abay bank, that the messages are not from the official channels of the banks and the banks are not giving prizes over a telegram promotion.

Furthermore, Dr. Letenah Ejigu Wale, a board member of Amhara Bank told HaqCheck that the telegram posts are not real, referring to them as “hoaxes” and confirmed that Amhara bank has not created any social media accounts yet. 

In this regard, the messages are rated as Hoaxes.

Recommendations

HaqCheck has been following up on such disinformation trends and creating awareness. A recent scam on social media platforms could also be debunked in a short time.

In general, the public needs to be aware of such scams and hoaxes on social media and should be cautious in its interaction with the pages. Hence, before acting upon any post or message are advised to consider the following tips

  • Check the web address (URL) and domains.
  • Stay alert and be skeptical, know who your providers are, and cross-check from the impersonated organization.
  • Don’t give your personal or financial information in response to a request that you didn’t expect.
  • Resist the pressure to act immediately, take your time to check and cross-check the identity of the sender.
  • Do not click on links or open any attachments or pop-up screens from sources you are not familiar with.
  • Read the site’s privacy policies because most scammers do not have any privacy policy on what they are going to do with your information.
  • Most organizations realize the potential for scamming and now don’t request confidential data online. So don’t offer up anything about yourself, even your mother’s maiden name. You can also contact the organization independently if you have any doubts.

—————————————————————————————————————————————————–

HaqCheck is a local multilingual fact-checking project based in Ethiopia, formed inside Addis Zeybe’s newsroom, now Inform Africa’s Counter Disinformation Project – a board-led Civil Society Organization (CSO) – dedicated to verifying media contents from social to the mainstream. HaqCheck works in collaboration with media outlets to monitor media contents in English and four local languages (Amharic, Afaan Oromo, Tigrigna, and Somali).

This report is produced with the support of UNESCO under the #CoronavirusFacts: Addressing the ‘Disinfodemic’ on COVID-19 in conflict-prone Environments that the UNESCO Addis Ababa Office is implementing in Ethiopia with financial support from the European Union (EU). The designations employed and the presentation of material throughout this publication do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNESCO or the EU concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city, or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The ideas and opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of UNESCO or The European Union and do not commit these organizations in any way.

Do the Images show Ethiopian and Israeli Air Force members on duty?

On  August 31, 2021, a compilation of images in support of the claim that Ethiopian and Israeli air forces agreed to work together in order to keep the regional peace, had been shared on a Facebook group having more than 200,000 members. However, HaqCheck has examined the images and rated the post as False.

The ongoing armed conflict in the Tigray region has spilled over to the neighboring Afar and Amhara regional states since the federal army withdrew from the major areas in Tigray at the end of June 2021.

It is to be remembered that Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed recently met Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan and signed a military cooperation agreement. The post stating that Ethiopian and Israeli air forces agreed to work together on regional peace emerged. The Facebook post shared four images to support the claim.

However, HaqCheck has undertaken a reverse image search of the pictures to learn that the post doesn’t actually prove the claim. The first two images were taken on October 3, 2019, while a Casa CN235 and Mirage 2000-5 fighter aircraft of French landed at Dire Dawa airport. The pictures show the Defense Attaché of the French Ambassador to Ethiopia, as well as several authorities of the Ethiopian Air Force.

Image 1

Image 2

The third image was posted 7 years ago on a website article entitled “Four Ethiopian air force pilots defect to Kenya.” The image is noted to show a former Ethiopian Air Force pilot who defected to Canada in 2003.

Image 3

According to a Tineye search, the fourth image was first found on July 22, 2008. HaqCheck couldn’t confirm the history behind the picture, for the sources that used the image have attached different stories making it arbitrary to identify the right one.

Image 4

HaqCheck has analyzed the images and proved that they do not show members of Ethiopian and Israeli air forces on duty to support the claim that air forces of the two countries have agreed to work together. Furthermore, no official statement is made regarding the military cooperation of the countries until this article is published and consequently rendered the post False.

 

Exit mobile version